top of page

Search Results

Search this site

419 results found with an empty search

  • Community Groups Decry Escalating Low-Level Arrests Targeting People of Color Under Mayor Mamdani

    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Thursday, August 13, 2026 Community Groups Decry Escalating Low-Level Arrests Targeting People of Color Under Mayor Mamdani Advocates call for an end to harmful Broken Windows Policing, which has continued to intensify in 2026 New York – On Thursday, community groups, among them Court Watch NYC, Drug Policy Alliance, Freedom Agenda, Justice Committee, The Legal Aid Society, SURJ NYC, VOCAL-NY and others, released data from a week of observing arraignment shifts across the five boroughs. The action was timed with Black August to illuminate the way low-level, quality of life enforcement arrests are continuing to harm Black, Latine, and low-income New Yorkers. Highlighting the data they collected, the groups called on Mayor Mamdani to deliver the new approach to community safety that he promised during his campaign. “Our observations of court arraignments this week proved what our members from Black and Brown communities are continuing to experience - hyper-policing, over-criminalization and incarceration,” said Darren Mack, Co-Director of Freedom Agenda. “The false promise that Broken Windows Policing leads to community safety has been debunked over a decade ago. What it has resulted in is low level arrests flooding the courts, New Yorkers' lives being disrupted, and families being separated. Arrests skyrocketed during the Adams administration and remain high under the Mamdani administration, which has promised to transition from the status quo and lead into a new direction. Ending Broken Windows Policing is a necessary step in that direction.” The groups viewed over 370 arraignments across four days and noted that 93% of people arraigned appeared to be people of color, with Black New Yorkers making up a staggering 57%. In over 50 instances, defense attorneys said their clients were struggling with mental health needs, substance use disorders, or housing instability. Fifty-eight percent of arraignments observed were for misdemeanor charges, including at least 137 for the lowest-level accusations like petty larceny and minor drug possession, in which police could have instead issued a desk appearance ticket. In fact, only 84 of the 377 arraignments observed were for felony charges that would not qualify for a desk appearance ticket. Beyond data collection, the groups said they hoped that by having a presence in court they would be able to remind the NYPD, along with judges and district attorneys, that New Yorkers are watching them. Under the Mamdani administration, arrests for low-level issues like taking up two seats on the subway have remained high, or even increased, despite campaign promises to focus police resources on serious crime. Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch began the quality of life offense crackdown under former Mayor Eric Adams, expanding police duties to “non-criminal, non-emergency issues” such as responding to 311 complaints, and has further escalated the arrests under the current administration. “What was saw this week make clear is that - no matter what NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch wants us to believe - broken windows policing is out of control in this city and it is causing immeasurable harm to Black, Latine, and working class New Yorkers,” said Samy Feliz, Organizer at Justice Committee, and brother of Allan Feliz, who was killed by NYPD in 2019. “Mayor Mamdani was elected on a promise of making New York a livable city for all. Ending the criminalization of poverty, mental health, substance use, and homelessness is not separate from that promise - it’s essential to it. We’re calling on him to follow through on the vision for real safety that his campaign promised by ending broken windows policing, removing NYPD from social service roles, and investing in housing, services and care, not cops.” “Broken windows policing isn't effective and doesn’t make us safer. ” said Council Member Sandy Nurse. “New Yorkers are ready for a new era of community safety that doesn’t criminalize poor Black and Brown New Yorkers. I stand with advocates and New Yorkers harmed by that disastrous policing era in demanding the NYPD stop low-level arrests and end broken windows policing. “New Yorkers should not be arrested, jailed, and dragged through the criminal legal system simply because they are poor, unhoused, struggling with mental health or substance use, or engaging in conduct that poses no genuine threat to public safety,” said Amanda Jack, Director of Policy with Criminal Law Reform at The Legal Aid Society. “Broken Windows policing has always fallen hardest on Black and brown New Yorkers, and what we see every day in arraignments shows the real human cost of continuing this failed approach. Mayor Mamdani campaigned on a different vision for community safety, and his administration must make good on that promise by ending the criminalization of poverty and directing resources away from police encounters and toward housing, community-based treatment, services, and other investments that actually keep communities safe.” “So many New Yorkers want issues in their communities addressed. We don’t want people to have to sleep on the trains, they should be housed, we don’t want family members to be in conflict. But if you spend a couple hours in criminal court you can’t help but understand that putting the police, jails and the court system onto these issues is not an effective government intervention into actually addressing these issues. In many cases it makes things worse,” said Nick Encalada-Malinowski, organizer at VOCAL-NY. "What we observed in arraignment courts across the city this week is a racial equity issue that must be met with expanded services to prevent, intervene, and provide care for people," said Maya Williams, Senior Director of Research and Policy at the NYC Commission on Racial Equity. “Black, poor, low-income New Yorkers are being arrested for low-level offenses coupled with high bail amounts which undermine community safety and family well-being. The system continues to criminalize poverty and punish people who need services rooted in care, dignity, and racial equity." ###

  • Defeat of Proposed NYPD Headcount Increase is a Victory for New Yorkers

    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Tuesday, June 30, 2026 Defeat of Proposed NYPD Headcount Increase is a Victory for New Yorkers Justice Committee responds to removal of proposed 580 new cops in FY27 budget deal Today, the New York City Council and Mayor Mamdani reached a handshake agreement on the FY27 city budget. In a major movement victory, championed by a large coalition of grassroots, legal, advocacy and civil rights organizations New Yorkers, the agreement does not include any expansion of the NYPD headcount. In response, Loyda Colón (they/them), Executive Director of Justice Committee, issued the following statement: “The defeat of the administration's proposal to invest ~$70 million in 580 additional NYPD officers is clear proof of the power New Yorkers have when we unite in our refusal to accept further expansion of policing and criminalization. While we wish Mayor Mamdani had simply kept his campaign promise to maintain a flat NYPD headcount in his executive budget proposal, in the final budget, he and the City Council made the right decision to stand with New Yorkers, instead of caving to NYPD political pressure. Now New Yorkers need Mayor Mamdani to maintain that political courage by truly embracing a transformative approach to public safety. This must begin with firing NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera, who killed Allan Feliz; scheduling the discipline trial for Office Wayne Isaacs, who killed Delrawn Small; ending Q-Team response to 311 calls, homeless encampment sweeps and arrests for low-level offenses; and ending Commissioner Tisch’s expansion of broken windows policing.”

  • 70 Organizations Deliver Letter to Mayor Mamdani: Reject NYPD Expansion, Invest in Care

    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Thursday, June 25, 2026 70 Organizations Deliver Letter to Mayor Mamdani: Reject NYPD Expansion, Invest in Care Days before budget deadline, groups, electeds, and community members urge Mayor to deliver on his campaign promises & public safety vision New York, NY – In a show of widespread, unified opposition to the direction of the Mamdani administration's public safety policy, 70 organizations delivered a letter to the mayor today, urging his him to reverse his proposed NYPD headcount increase and end broken windows policing in favor of investments in housing, healthcare, and other social services. Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, State Senator Julia Salazar, Council Member Alexa Avilés, Council Member Tiffany Cabán, Council Member Shahana Hanif, and community members joined many of the organizations outside City Hall less than a week before the City budget deadline, to call on Mayor Mamdani to align his budget with the promises he campaigned on by rejecting police expansion and instead investing in the services New Yorkers need. “Mayor Mamdani, New Yorkers elected you because they believed in your vision for a New York City in which we can all thrive, including the most marginalized New Yorkers who are suffering in public and have been met by past administrations with brutality, arrests and tickets,” reads the letter. “This vision must include an approach to public safety that is rooted in care, not criminalization. Accommodating a Police Commissioner and NYPD doubling down on broken windows policing, proposing to grow the force, and staying silent in the face of documented abuses — is contradictory to that vision, a failed approach, and waste of resources that could be transformative if invested in communities.” In the letter, the 70 organizations call on the Mamdani administration to remove the proposed 580 new NYPD officers from the FY27 budget and end Q-Team response to 311 calls, homeless encampment sweeps, and unnecessary arrests for low-level offenses. “New York City does not have a police staffing shortage,” the letter states. “It has a resource allocation problem — too many resources flowing to criminalization and too few flowing to care.” The letter calls for funding to be re-allocated to “care, preventative, and community-based support, including Intensive Mobile Treatment (IMT) teams, crisis stabilization and respite centers, community-based behavioral health services, low-barrier housing, school restorative justice programs, non-police violence prevention, and expansion of the social services workforce.” Quotes “I supported our Mayor when he ran for office and I believe in our shared vision of a New York City that is truly for all of us,” said Neil Berry of VOCAL-NY. “One of the things he said was that the police are doing too many things that social workers and mental health workers should be doing. So why are we spending more money on the police, instead of investing in mental health or social workers? Let’s take the police out of mental health response, out of homeless sweeps and invest in the City agencies and organisations that can actually address the issues that New Yorkers are facing.” “More officers interacting with community members doesn’t equal more safety, just more opportunities for harm, and more families being ripped apart – and we know Black and Latine New Yorkers will bear the brunt of it,” said Samy Feliz, Organizer at Justice Committee and brother of Allan Feliz, who was killed by NYPD in 2019. “Mayor Mamdani: You pledged to keep the NYPD headcount flat, to get the NYPD out of mental health response, and to end sweeps of homeless encampments. You even stood with my family and called for Lt. Jonathan Rivera to be fired. Why haven’t you delivered on any of it?” "Mayor Mamdani promised a different approach to community safety, that ends the ineffective and harmful reliance on police to address social and economic needs,” said Darren Mack, Co-Director of Freedom Agenda. “There are so many New Yorkers excited to work with him to make that vision a reality, and we want to see that vision reflected in his budget. Unfortunately, what we're seeing right now indicates that the mayor is planning to intensify the NYPD crackdown on poor and working-class New Yorkers that started under Eric Adams. Our City does not need 580 more cops to arrest more people who can't afford a home or a subway ride. We need that money invested in healthcare, housing, and meeting people's basic needs." "Public safety requires far greater investments in meeting our basic needs, from housing and health care to childcare and schools,” said State Senator Julia Salazar (Brooklyn/Queens), Chair of the Senate Committee on Crime Victims, Crime, and Correction. “Adding 580 more police officers to the NYPD's already swollen ranks not only is a misallocation of resources, but also deepens all-too-familiar cycles of over-policing, criminalization, incarceration, violence, and trauma. Mayor Mamdani won his historic election on a campaign platform that centered on caring for New Yorkers in need instead of ensnaring them in the criminal legal system, and I implore him to follow through. That means not inflating the police headcount, but instead acting to end the NYPD's aggressive and discriminatory enforcement of low-level offenses. It means finally disbanding the Strategic Resource Group, dismantling the discriminatory Gang Database, empowering the Department of Community Safety, and expanding alternatives to incarceration." “Access to housing and mental health care are key to delivering safer, healthier communities,” said Council Member Tiffany Cabán. “The current budget proposal does not expand City FHEPS, a program critical to getting New Yorkers out of shelter and into permanent housing. It also fails to expand the resources of mobile treatment teams, leaving hundreds of New Yorkers in need of mental healthcare stuck on waiting lists for that care. Instead, it proposes throwing millions more dollars into reactive and failed policies of policing and punishment by adding 580 officers to an already bloated NYPD budget. We deserve better and we demand better.” "New Yorkers voted for a different vision of public safety — one rooted in dignity, care, and investment in communities, not a continuation of the failed policies of broken windows policing and criminalization," said Tina Luongo, Chief Attorney of the Criminal Defense Practice at The Legal Aid Society. "Expanding the police force while continuing arrests for low-level offenses will not make our city safer. It will only deepen the harms that Black and brown communities, immigrants, unhoused New Yorkers, and people with unmet mental health and substance use needs have endured for decades. Mayor Mamdani has an opportunity to chart a new course by investing in housing, healthcare, and community-based services that address the root causes of instability. Public safety is not built through punishment. It is built through care, opportunity, and ensuring every New Yorker has what they need to thrive." “The NYPD’s use of so-called ‘quality of life’ policing, overreliance on custodial arrests, and a lack of police accountability has subjected New Yorkers to increased police interactions and contributed to a crisis in New York City courthouses," said Yung-Mi Lee, Legal Director of Criminal Defense at Brooklyn Defender Services. “To truly make our neighborhoods safe, New York City must prioritize its investments in community support and care, not in policing and the criminalization of poverty.” “New Kings Democrats values a public safety model, beyond policing, based on respect for and holistic investment in communities,” said New Kings Democrats. “Adding hundreds of new officers and surging quality of life/broken windows policies is contrary to these values and contrary to what New Yorkers voted for when they elected Mayor Mamdani last year. NKD joins the Justice Committee in urging the mayor to put an end to discriminatory policing practices and to embrace a more inclusive, democratic approach to community safety.” “The NYPD’s use of so-called ‘quality of life’ policing, overreliance on custodial arrests, and a lack of police accountability has subjected New Yorkers to increased police interactions and contributed to a crisis in New York City courthouses," said Yung-Mi Lee, Legal Director of Criminal Defense at Brooklyn Defender Services. “To truly make our neighborhoods safe, New York City must prioritize its investments in community support and care, not in policing and the criminalization of poverty.” "On the campaign trail, Mayor Mamdani made commitments to end the ‘jail-first’ approach to public safety that harmed Black, brown, and low-income communities under the Adams administration,” said Yonah Zeitz, advocacy director at the Katal Center for Equity, Health, and Justice. “While the new administration has made important strides in the first six months, this executive budget continues the status quo of excessively funding the NYPD and the DOC at the expense of essential services that New Yorkers rely on. We demand a budget for New Yorkers that will reduce the number of cops, cut the jail population, shut down Rikers, and invest in real community safety such as housing, health care, including mental health care, education, and jobs.” “Mayor Mamdani rightly campaigned on a transformative vision of public safety that invests in basic human needs rather than over-policing and mass surveillance,” said Michael Sisitzky, Assistant Director of Policy at the New York Civil Liberties Union. “It is still early in the administration and the Mayor still has time to deliver on that vision. But there have also been worrying signs the administration is backing away from key promises, from expanding the NYPD headcount and continuing the NYPD's gang database and Strategic Response Group, to continuing to include police in mental health crisis response. We urge the administration to preserve the Mayor’s vision and to advance true public safety." "Mayor Mamdani promised New Yorkers he would not expand the NYPD, and he needs to keep that promise," said Council Member Shahana Hanif. "Spending hundreds of millions on police expansion won't solve our housing crisis, address unmet mental health needs, or help families stay in their homes. If we're serious about keeping New Yorkers safe, we should invest in housing, care, and community—not more policing. New Yorkers deserve a budget that puts care, not cops, at the center of public safety."

  • [Gothamist] Police reformers call on Mamdani to rein in NYPD's quality of life crackdown

    By Liam Quigley and Elizabeth Kim Dozens of community groups sent Mayor Zohran Mamdani a letter on Thursday calling for him to scale back the NYPD’s crackdown on low-level offenses. The groups, largely made up of criminal justice advocates, criticized Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch’s focus on “quality of life” arrests, arguing the approach criminalizes poverty. The letter also called on Mamdani to halt plans to hire 580 new police officers, and said the money should instead be used to provide more social services to low-income communities. “New Yorkers elected you because they believed in your vision for a New York City in which we can all thrive, including the most marginalized New Yorkers who are suffering in public and have been met by past administrations with brutality, arrests and tickets,” the letter reads. “This vision must include an approach to public safety that is rooted in care, not criminalization.” Roughly 70 groups signed the letter, including Brooklyn Defender Services, the New York Civil Liberties Union, Desis Rising Up & Moving and Make the Road New York. The groups plan to hold a rally on the steps of City Hall on Thursday. The letter and rally are the latest signs of growing frustration among some advocates who think Mamdani isn’t delivering on his campaign promises around police reform. Tisch’s push to enforce low-level crimes pre-dates Mamdani’s tenure as mayor. She took the helm at the NYPD under previous Mayor Eric Adams while top department officials were under federal investigation. Mamdani kept Tisch on as police commissioner when he took office. Under her direction, the NYPD has deployed Q-Teams, which focus on quality of life issues identified by 311 requests. Violent crime rates have fallen to record lows under Tisch’s tenure. When asked about the letter, a spokesperson for Mamdani pointed to previous comments the mayor has made on his policing strategy that highlight the city’s drop in crime. Edwin Santana, a community organizer with the group Freedom Agenda, which signed the letter, said Mamdani needs to choose a new police commissioner if he is to cement his legacy as a police reformer. “I don't know why he's keeping Jessica Tisch on, but I think that he's going to maybe tarnish his administration and his reputation if he continues to have her deal with these broken window policies and just coming down on communities hard,” Santana said. The groups argued in the letter that TIsch’s crackdown on low-level offenses has coincided with an increase in people dying in police custody. Yul-san Liem, deputy director of police reform group The Justice Committee, said that Mamdani should exercise his power as mayor and force Tisch to back off on her hardline approach to low-level offenses. “Safety does not come from criminalizing people,” she said. “It comes from meeting people's needs. Public safety can be way better served by using the tens of millions of dollars for one year that it would cost to hire those new officers to invest in the kinds of services and support that will increase New Yorkers' safety for the long term.”

  • Letter from 70 Orgs to Mamdani: Invest in Care, Not More Cops

    June 2026 Mayor Zohran Mamdani City Hall New York, NY 10007 Cc: First Deputy Mayor Dean Fuleihan, Deputy Mayor of Community Safety Renita Francois, Office of Community Safety Commissioner Ayesha Delany-Brumsey, NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch Subject: Opposition to NYPD Headcount Increase and Expansion of Broken Windows Policing Dear Mayor Mamdani, Your election as mayor gave us hope for a genuine break from the failed policing-first approach that has criminalized our communities for decades and left unaddressed the actual challenges that low-income New Yorkers are facing. We, the undersigned 70 organizations, share urgent and deep concerns about the direction your administration’s approach to public safety appears to be headed. We write not as opponents but as partners who believe New York City can lead the nation in building public safety systems grounded in care, as opposed to the ineffective, harmful and costly status quo of criminalization. To do so requires political courage and the willingness to hear from and act on the concerns of communities most harmed by over-policing: The NYPD’s Escalating Criminalization of Poverty Will Result in Increased Harm, Not Safety Under Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch, beginning under Mayor Eric Adams and continuing into your administration, the NYPD has doubled down on using stops, tickets, and arrests in response to so-called quality of life issues. The department has launched a dedicated Quality of Life division and is deploying Q-Teams to respond to non-criminal, non-emergency 311 calls. Officers routinely violate the law by arresting New Yorkers for low-level offenses in situations where a non-arrest Desk Appearance Ticket (DAT) is mandatory, and abuse their discretion by automatically arresting New Yorkers in situations where DATs are discretionary and - could more effectively be addressed by connecting New Yorkers to services rather than arrest and prosecution. This enforcement surge has resulted in a sustained crisis of overcrowding and unsafe conditions - including multiple deaths and a birth - in central bookings this year. The department is also increasing the criminalization of public gatherings and spaces — a trend with particularly alarming implications this summer as our City hosts major sporting events and outdoors gatherings and the push to make vulnerable New Yorkers less visible will intensify. This kind of aggressive enforcement of low level offenses is broken windows policing, regardless of whether the Police Commissioner is willing to admit it or not. It has no causal relationship with a reduction in major crime and results in the criminalization of Black, Latine and other New Yorkers of color, immigrants and those with increased vulnerabilities due to unmet housing, substance use and mental health needs. It is harmful, costly, racist and ineffective public policy. The Proposed Addition of 580 New Officers Is the Wrong Investment On the campaign trail, you pledged to keep NYPD officer headcount flat, yet your executive budget proposes to expand an already enormous police force at a moment when the city faces urgent unmet needs in housing, healthcare, and community-based mental health services. More officers will almost assuredly mean an escalation of the harms our communities are already suffering: more arrests for low-level offenses, more encounters that escalate unnecessarily, and more pressure on an already broken and biased discipline system that allows officers to abuse New Yorkers with impunity. New York City does not have a police staffing shortage. It has a resource allocation problem — too many resources flowing to criminalization and too few flowing to care. Every dollar invested in expanding NYPD headcount is a dollar not invested in the community-based, care and housing-first infrastructure that actually produces safety. We call on your administration to take the following concrete steps: 1. Eliminate the 580 proposed new officers and keep NYPD headcount flat. 2. End Q-Team response to 311 calls. 311 is a civilian service system. These calls should be routed to city agencies that are designed to address the underlying concerns, rather than the NYPD, which only leads to the criminalization of public concerns. 3. End sweeps of homeless encampments. Sweeps are not public safety — they are displacement. They cause harm, destroy property and make it harder for unhoused New Yorkers to access services. 4. End arrests for low-level offenses that are based in social and economic challenges. Instead, invest in connecting New Yorkers to services to meet their needs and in addressing our City’s affordability crisis, for example by increasing access to free transit and truly affordable housing. 5. Invest in care, prevention, and community-based support. Fund Intensive Mobile Treatment (IMT) teams and step-down capacity; crisis stabilization centers and respite centers; community-based behavioral health services; low-barrier housing; school restorative justice programs, non-police violence prevention, and a robust expansion of the social services workforce. These are the investments that increase safety. Mayor Mamdani, New Yorkers elected you because they believed in your vision for a New York City in which we can all thrive, including the most marginalized New Yorkers who are suffering in public and have been met by past administrations with brutality, arrests and tickets. This vision must include an approach to public safety that is rooted in care, not criminalization. Accommodating a Police Commissioner and NYPD doubling down on broken windows policing, proposing to grow the force, and staying silent in the face of documented abuses — is contradictory to that vision, a failed approach, and waste of resources that could be transformative if invested in communities. We are ready to partner with you and offer our expertise rooted in the lived experience of our members, clients and constituents. We ask that you bring the political will to meet us. We look forward to your response and to meaningful engagement on each of the demands above. In solidarity, Allan Feliz Foundation Alliance for Quality Education America On Trial Inc. (AOT) American Friends Service Committee Anthony Baez Foundation Bronx Móvil Brooklyn Defender Services CASES Center for Community Alternatives (CCA) Center for Constitutional Rights Center for Law and Social Justice at Medgar Evers College Citizen Action of New York Community Capacity Development Community Connections for Youth Community Voices Heard Court Watch NYC Drug Policy Alliance DRUM - Desis Rising up & Moving El Puente Equality for Flatbush (E4F) Exodus Transitional Community, Inc. Freedom Agenda G.A.N.G.S. Coalition Gender Liberation Movement HALT Solitary Campaign Harlem United Housing Works Immigrant Defense Project Jails Action Coalition (JAC) Jews For Racial & Economic Justice (JFREJ) Jim Owles Liberal Democratic Club Justice and Beyond inc. Justice Committee Justice for Families, LTD Katal Center Equity, Health, and Justice LatinoJustice PRLDEF Legal Action Center LIFE Camp, Inc. Make the Road New York Malcolm X Grassroots Movement - NYC Chapter Middle Church Muslim Community Network (MCN) Myra's Kids Inc. NAACP Legal Defense Fund National Harm Reduction Coalition National Homelessness Law Center Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem New Kings Democrats New York Civil Liberties Union New York Communities for Change New York County Defender Services North American Climate, Conservation and Environment (NACCE) Osborne Association Policing and Social Justice Project Safety Net Project - Urban Justice Center SURJ NYC Tempest Collective-NYC The Bronx Defenders The Center for Anti-Violence Education The Circle Keepers The Fortune Society The Gathering for Justice / Justice League NYC The Legal Aid Society The People's Plan UAW Region 9A Vera Institute of Justice Visionary V Ministries VOCAL-NY WCJA Youth Represent

  • Public Safety Testimony from Samy Feliz to City Council

    My name is Samy Feliz. I am representing the Justice Committee, a grassroots organization committed to ending police violence and systemic racism in New York City. I was born and raised in the Bronx and Washington Heights. To me, public safety is very personal. My brother, Allan Feliz, was killed by NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera and Officers Michelle Almanzar and Edward Barrett in 2019. Lt. Rivera has since been promoted, despite a documented record of 40 misconduct allegations and multiple shootings. Since 2020, he has received over $1 million in salary (not including benefits), and cost taxpayers at least $115,000 in settlements so far, with several lawsuits still pending. Lt. Rivera continues to patrol the streets, despite the fact that the CCRB and NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Trials have recommended he be fired. This is an egregious misuse of city money and it is not keeping New Yorkers safe. But this is not an aberration – this is how the NYPD operates. Consider NYPD Officer Wayne Isaacs, who killed unarmed father Delrawn Small in 2016. He has received no discipline in the near decade since he killed Delrawn, despite being indicted by the New York State Attorney General and having fireable charges substantiated by the CCRB nearly six years ago. The NYPD has intentionally delayed the CCRB’s prosecution of Isaacs, allowing him to collect well over $1 million in salary and, more egregiously, continue working long enough to secure his pension. The pattern is clear: the NYPD systemically shields officers who harm New Yorkers while rewarding them with promotions, raises, and job security. Meanwhile, misconduct complaints remain at decade-high levels, with misconduct complaints in 2025 nearly as high as they were in 2024, and use of force complaints even higher. Last year alone, NYC paid out over $117 million in police misconduct settlements. Why are we continuing to pour so much money into the NYPD when there is no accountability for officers who hurt New Yorkers? This is not the cost of public safety – it’s the cost of impunity. New Yorkers voted for change with the new Mayoral administration, but so far, Mayor Mamdani has maintained the status quo and allowed the NYPD to create chaos and violence at the expense of New Yorkers. Mayor Mamdani’s executive budget invests about $12 billion dollars in the NYPD and, despite promises not to, increases the officer headcount by 580. Overtime is set to cost the City nearly a billion dollars, double its allocated budget for this year – and because overtime pads officers’ pensions, New Yorkers will continue paying for this overtime for years to come. Meanwhile, low-level arrests and summons, under the guise of ‘quality of life’ enforcement, are surging. Court cases for people sleeping or taking multiple seats on the subway went up 3000% from 2024 to 2025, and they’re on track to even exceed that in 2026 – all while the department shows no accountability for the harm it causes. The city cannot arrest its way to safety. Instead of continuing to flood city resources into policing and criminalization, we are calling on the City Council to pass a budget that cuts Mamdani’s proposed 580 new officers, implements a hiring freeze for school police, eliminates funding for vacant school police positions, further reduces the NYPD’s bloated budget, and eliminates funding increases to B-HEARD so that resources can be channeled into services that actually increase safety and well-being for New Yorkers who need care. Some of these services include: At least $66.3M, baselined, for Intensive Mobile Treatment (IMT) teams – $22M more than the Executive Budget allocates, which should allow the program to expand sufficiently to eliminate the current waitlist. At least $23.8M, baselined, for Assertive Community Treatment (ACT) – $4.5M more than the Executive Budget allocates. At least $6M, baselined, for Forensic Assertive Community Treatment (FACT) – $2M more than the Executive Budget allocates), which provide both mental health and reentry services to people returning from jail and prison. At least $8.8M, baselined, for crisis respite centers – $6M more than the Executive Budget allocates, which should enable the opening of four new centers, in compliance with Local Law 118-2023. $20.3M to establish at least 150 units of low-barrier housing for people with court-involvement and mental health diagnoses. At least $12M, baselined, for Restorative Justice that is funded by City dollars. $6M of this funding was baselined in the FY26 budget. The remaining $6M expires in June. NYC Public Schools must be safe, welcoming spaces where young people can grow, learn, resolve conflict and navigate challenges. You cannot have public safety without accountability, and you cannot have real safety without addressing the root causes of crises. The choice before this Council is clear: continue funneling billions into a system that protects officers who kill and criminalizes survival, or invest in the services that truly keep New Yorkers well and safe. Thank you for your consideration.

  • Christine Henson's Testimony to City Council on Public Safety & Mental Health

    My name is Christine Henson. I am the mother of Andrew Henson, who is affected by autism and limited speech abilities. When he was 16, Andrew was assaulted by the NYPD. It is disappointing that Mayor Mamdani’s executive budget invests approximately $12B in the NYPD, increases the officer headcount by 580, and increases funding to the failed B-HEARD program while failing to make real investments in services New Yorkers need. In 2018, I requested a speech evaluation at Andrew’s school, and the principal referred us to BronxCare. The principal told me there would be transportation, but I wasn’t told it would be an ambulance. When we got outside, the street was blocked off and filled with police. There were officers from two different precincts and, surprisingly, they followed us to BronxCare. When we arrived at BronxCare, Andrew pointed to a store. When we started to walk, the EMT grabbed Andrew’s arm and said “You are not going anywhere”. I told him we came voluntarily. Within seconds, multiple NYPD officers rushed over, grabbing Andrew’s arms and forcing them behind his neck. His neck was choked and twisted. His body went limp. Then he was forced into the waiting area, where his face was pressed down into a seat. His arm was bent aggressively and his screams were disregarded. He cried out, “Mom!”, and I said “he has special needs” but I was ignored. Police don’t need to respond to mental health and health calls, especially for people with Autism. My son was just hungry. He was in no way a threat. But instead of being treated with care, the NYPD, EMTs, and hospital security violently escalated against him. Andrew has regressed and his independence has been altered because of the police. They destroyed a part of his life. The NYPD should not be responding to people with developmental or mental health concerns AT ALL. Until our city moves away from criminalization and meaningfully invests in trauma-informed, evidence-based services for people like Andrew, the most vulnerable New Yorkers will continue to be endangered by NYPD violence. Mayor Zohran Mamdani promised to move away from the city’s historically harmful police-first approach to responding to people with developmental, mental health and substance use needs, and he said the Office of Community Safety is going to help do this. However, based on the Executive Order that created it, OCS is not doing anything to reduce police involvement or increase services for the people it is supposedly supposed to serve. The emphasis on expanding and increasing funding for the failed B-HEARD pilot program is extremely worrying. B-HEARD fails to follow best practices for crisis response, over-relies on traumatizing involuntary hospitalizations, and manages only a small fraction of mental health calls. Just last week, NYPD Commissioner Tisch testified that B-HEARD responded to less than 8% of potentially eligible calls – leaving the vast majority of New Yorkers in need of care with only police responses. Expanding B-HEARD risks further entrenching NYPD in mental health response rather than removing them. On top of this, the mayor’s executive budget pours approximately $12 billion dollars into the NYPD, (including its expense budget, debt services, benefits and pensions) and funds 580 new officers - even though, on the campaign trail Mamdani promised to keep officer headcount flat. At the same time, outside of B-HEARD, he proposes to make almost no new investments in mental health services. In other words, his executive budget follows the same old trends that we saw with Eric Adams. If the City Council truly cares about New Yorkers’ safety, dignity and health, you will pass a City budget that cuts Mamdani’s proposed 580 new officers, implements a hiring freeze for school police, eliminates funding for vacant school police positions, further reduces the NYPD’s bloated budget, and eliminates funding increases to B-HEARD so that resources can be channeled into services that actually increase safety and well-being for New Yorkers who need care. Some of these services include: At least $66.3M, baselined, for Intensive Mobile Treatment (IMT) teams – $22M more than the Executive Budget allocates, which should allow the program to expand sufficiently to eliminate the current waitlist. At least $23.8M, baselined, for Assertive Community Treatment (ACT) – $4.5M more than the Executive Budget allocates. At least $6M, baselined, for Forensic Assertive Community Treatment (FACT) – $2M more than the Executive Budget allocates), which provide both mental health and reentry services to people returning from jail and prison. At least $8.8M, baselined, for crisis respite centers – $6M more than the Executive Budget allocates, which should enable the opening of four new centers, in compliance with Local Law 118-2023. $20.3M to establish at least 150 units of low-barrier housing for people with court-involvement and mental health diagnoses. At least $12M, baselined, for Restorative Justice that is funded by City dollars. $6M of this funding was baselined in the FY26 budget. The remaining $6M expires in June. NYC Public Schools must be safe, welcoming spaces where young people can grow, learn, resolve conflict and navigate challenges. Thank you for your attention. We would like to see our concerns considered and implemented.

  • [BOLTS] The NYPD Has Final Say on Civilian Oversight. Will That Change Under Mamdani?

    New York City’s Civilian Complaint Review Board, ostensibly a police watchdog, cedes much power to police leadership. Experts say the mayor has the power to boost its independence. By Piper French New York City’s Civilian Complaint Review Board, the watchdog agency that oversees the New York Police Department, consistently touts its independence—“independent agency” is the first descriptor on all of the board’s official communications. The board, which investigates instances of alleged misconduct by officers and votes on whether to recommend discipline, is led by 15 civilian members who, in theory, represent democratic control over the police. But in practice, the department retains control over virtually every step of the civilian review process, even right up to the final one, where the police commissioner can simply overturn a disciplinary recommendation. “Even if it were functioning as fairly as possible, it’s still very much set up so that the power is in the hands of the NYPD,” said Yul-san Liem, the deputy director of the Justice Committee, which organizes against police abuses. What’s at stake for officers isn’t incarceration or a criminal conviction. At most, it’s termination from the NYPD and the loss of a pension. More often, it’s the loss of a few vacation days—sometimes, just a fraction of one day—or extra training. But the NYPD, and its unions in particular, tend to react to CCRB investigations with as much furor as they display in response to criminal cases against NYPD officers, and have insisted on police leadership having the final say. The push to make the board independent from the NYPD in the 1990s provoked an infamous cop riot. More recently, under Mayor Eric Adams, two successive CCRB interim chairs were forced out after their vocal support for greater independence put them in the NYPD’s crosshairs. When, on the campaign trail, Zohran Mamdani briefly expressed support for giving the CCRB final say on disciplinary decisions, the police unions’ chief spokesperson responded that such a change would mean the “end of policing in this city.” In April, the city’s largest police union sued the CCRB twice over disputes involving public access to disciplinary records. Lately, the union has been leaking investigators’ social media posts to theNew York Post, demanding they be fired for “cop-bashing” rhetoric. It has even singled out one of its own, a former NYPD chief and police commissioner pick, for recommending discipline too often. The union told Bolts it believes that the CCRB doesn’t give officers a fair shake, in violation of the city charter mandate for it to conduct investigations impartially and in a way that both the public and the department can have confidence in. “It would be a mischaracterization to imply we are seeking ‘control over the process,’” union spokesperson John Nuthall told Bolts, noting that false accusations of misconduct can hurt officers both personally and professionally. “We are simply seeking the fairness required by the Charter.” The city’s elected leaders don’t appear to possess a countervailing urgency to curb the NYPD’s influence and bolster CCRB’s independence. The board currently has only 11 out of 15 seats filled; the seat representing the Bronx, ground zero for abusive police practices like stop-and-frisk, has been empty for nearly three years. On Dec. 31, the final day of his mayoralty, Adams vetoed a bill opposed by the city’s police unions that would have allowed CCRB investigators automatic access to NYPD bodyworn camera footage. This would have constituted a major reform to the “central issue with the CCRB,” according to Mac Muir, a former senior investigator for the board: “the agency cannot be a real, functioning oversight entity without direct access to body cam [footage].” But this January, as the new city council overrode a slew of Adams’s last-minute vetoes, the CCRB bill was one of just three the council failed to revive—in part because new members reportedly didn’t understand its import. Liem and other advocates and experts argue that this deficit of attention to the CCRB has created a lack of accountability for everything from routine humiliations to police killings, allowing the NYPD’s pattern of violence and disregard for civilians to continue. “The CCRB has no constituency,” said LatinoJustice PRLDEF criminal justice counsel Andrew Case, who worked at the board from 2001 to 2008. “People only think about these entities in a crisis.” Still, the city’s mayor retains “extraordinary power” over the CCRB, according to Udi Ofer, former executive director of the New Jersey ACLU and an expert on law enforcement oversight. While Ofer has long criticized the CCRB for granting too much control to the city’s executive, he told Bolts that same flaw also presents an opportunity to reimagine the city’s beleaguered civilian review board now that a mayor who has professed support for civilian oversight and police reform is in charge. Over Mamdani’s tenure, the CCRB will test just how interested the mayor is in using his considerable power in creative and novel ways to bolster independent civilian oversight, or whether he will defer to the police unions and his commissioner on a complex issue that attracts little public attention. The CCRB’s structural pitfalls “can be compensated by a mayor who’s committed to strong civilian oversight over the police,” Ofer said. “We’re now in the Mamdani era, so let’s see what the mayor’s office will do with the CCRB.” Civilian oversight of the NYPD has been contested since its earliest incarnation in the 1960s. After police objected strenuously to the mayor’s creation of a review board, prominent New York City conservatives such as William F. Buckley collected signatures to trigger a referendum challenging its legality, and the union mounted a “vociferous red-baiting media campaign” against the board that was ultimately successful—a history that is recounted in Blue Power, Stuart Schrader’s new book on the history of police unions. In 1992, when David Dinkins, New York’s first Black mayor, tried to make a later iteration of the CCRB independent of the NYPD, drunken off-duty cops rioted at city hall, brandishing racist signs and shouting slurs. The police union president told the crowd that the CCRB represented “the forces of evil.” Eric Adams, then a young cop, would compare the scene to a lynch mob. Rudy Giuliani, who spoke at the riot, ousted Dinkins from the mayor’s office a year later, backed by the police union. Giuliani intervened to stop the CCRB nomination of Iris Baez, whose son was killed by police—the only time in the history of the CCRB that a mayor has done so. To this day, no family member of a person killed by the NYPD has ever served on the CCRB. Muir worked at the CCRB from 2016 to 2022. Last year, he and fellow former investigator Greg Finch published Cop Cop: Breaking the Fixed System of American Policing, a rare look inside the CCRB and its limitations. Emphasizing the importance of civilian oversight, Muir told Bolts,“You see the real gap between an officer’s perspective on the harm that they can do and the harm that is apparently done. A stop and frisk that can seem totally normal to a cop can be life altering to the person who’s actually stopped and frisked.” One issue is the board’s comparatively narrow jurisdiction. Oakland’s civilian oversight body, which Muir ran after leaving the CCRB, is empowered to investigate any allegation against an officer, including extracurricular criminal activity like drunk driving or domestic violence. The CCRB, by contrast, only has authority toward on-duty behavior in five categories. Cop Cop also details the NYPD’s wide latitude to hold up, interfere with, and ultimately overturn the results of a CCRB investigation. “Final authority is the last moment where the NYPD or the police unions can subvert the case,” Liem told Bolts. “Really, there are these obstacles and roadblocks every step of the way.” Take the case of Allan Feliz, whom NYPD lieutenant Jonathan Rivera shot and killed in 2019 during a traffic stop in the Bronx — a traffic stop that only commenced because a cop thought Feliz wasn’t wearing his seatbelt. After New York Attorney General Letitia James declined to file criminal charges, Feliz’s family decided to pursue consequences for Rivera via the CCRB, Allan’s brother Samy told Bolts. This was the beginning of a five-year journey that would span the tenure of two mayors and seven different police commissioners, and see Samy Feliz change careers and become an organizer working with the Justice Committee. “It is an extremely arduous process that requires a lot of strength and tenacity,” Liem said. While some aspects of a CCRB case mirror those of a criminal procedure, the agency only handles administrative proceedings against officers. Serious disciplinary “charges,” like those against Rivera, usually go before an administrative judge who either exonerates or holds the officer culpable, in which case she recommends discipline rather than a prison sentence. CCRB attorneys, meanwhile, serve as the prosecutors, and police union lawyers or private attorneys as the defense. But unlike every other civil service employee in the city of New York, including correctional officers, whose disciplinary hearings are held by the same administrative office, police officers’ disciplinary trials are held at department headquarters, and the judge is a NYPD deputy commissioner. “Everything is handled internally, even up to the location,” Samy Feliz told Bolts. “It’s NYPD all around.” As the Feliz family fought to ensure “a semblance of justice” for Allan, the NYPD held onto the case for two years, waiting until the CCRB’s 18-month statute of limitations for most disciplinary charges had expired to turn it over to the CCRB. This meant that CCRB attorneys would have to prove that the lieutenant violated state law, not just NYPD policy, in order to get a guilty verdict. Once the CCRB gets a case, its investigators gather and review evidence and then either “exonerate” the officer or substantiate allegations against them, but those findings have to go through a panel composed of three CCRB members. It’s customary that one NYPD-appointed member serve on each disciplinary panel—which effectively “overweighs” the NYPD in these decisions, according to Case. In Feliz’s case, the investigators substantiated five total disciplinary charges against four cops involved in the incident, but the panel only substantiated two of those charges, and only against Jonathan Rivera, the lieutenant who pulled the trigger. The NYPD subsequently tried to use its power to intervene in the case several more times, including trying to take the case back away from CCRB entirely. Finally, in 2025, came the administrative trial. Feliz had only “slim hope” that the NYPD judge—who often exonerates officers—would find Rivera guilty. When she did, and recommended he be fired, it “gave us light at the end of the tunnel,” he said. But their hope was short-lived. Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch, who holds final authority over CCRB and the judge, overturned the verdict on the grounds that the state attorney general had declined to file charges in the first place—a move Feliz called “completely heartbreaking” and that LatinoJustice, in a lawsuit against Tisch, has argued constitutes the wrong evidentiary standard to boot. “By letting a person like Jonathan Rivera walk, she sent a message to all cops that they can racially profile, abuse, and kill New Yorkers with total impunity, and that they’re always going to be protected,” Samy Feliz told Bolts. In this, Allan Feliz’s case was far from an outlier: a 2020 New York Times investigation found that, over the previous two decades, commissioners reduced penalties or overturned 71 percent of serious charges against officers. In the history of the CCRB, only one officer has been fired following a CCRB prosecution—Daniel Pantaleo, following a national public outcry over his killing of Eric Garner. Rivera remains on the NYPD, where in early May he pleaded guilty to another administrative misconduct charge, admitting he abused his authority during a different civilian interaction from 2023. Experts all agree that the mayor of New York City does not actually have the direct power to make the CCRB more independent, by taking final say on discipline away from the police commissioner. Such a change would require the revision of state law and the city charter. “This can’t be done through executive fiat, but if the mayor’s office believes in it, it has a lot of political capital,” both at city council and in Albany, Ofer said. But, he told Bolts, the mayor “does have unilateral authority in the type of police commissioner that he has.” Adams’ term as mayor represented a low point for the CCRB’s independence. In addition to serious allegations of corruption within the NYPD, and spikes in the jail population and stop-and-frisk rates, Adams forced out one CCRB chair who spoke out against the NYPD’s interference with cases. Adams also stood by while the next CCRB chair was bullied by the police union, and appointed a police commissioner who flagrantly disregarded and undermined the board. In April 2024, Adams reportedly asked for Chair Arva Rice’s resignation after she criticized the department for taking 18 months to turn over bodyworn camera footage of police killing Kawaski Trawick, which limited the range of disciplinary charges. Police unions then spent much of last year waging a scorched-earth media campaign against Rice’s successor, Mohammad Khalid, for voting in favor of officer discipline at slightly higher than average rates and calling for the CCRB to retain final authority over discipline. In his resignation letter, Khalid, a Staten Island dentist initially appointed to the board by Mayor Bloomberg, wrote that he felt he had “no other choice,” saying that the union’s spokesperson had “pushed me to the brink.” In December 2025, after Khalid resigned, Adams tapped board member Pat Smith to serve as the CCRB’s interim chair—a New York Post veteran who has bemoaned “spurious” civilian complaints and argued that complainants whose claims are dismissed should face perjury charges. While CCRB panels historically disagree with their investigators in only about 10 percent of cases, a Hell Gate series found that two 2025 panels including Smith flipped their investigators’ determinations at rates of 48 percent and 40 percent. (The two panels evaluated 190 and 146 discrete instances of misconduct where investigators found enough evidence to substantiate charges). One of Adams’ last acts as mayor was to veto the bill that would have allowed the CCRB automatic access to bodyworn camera footage. Before bodyworn cameras, it was almost always the civilian’s word against the cop’s for CCRB investigations—and the cop’s word carried more weight. But even today, the NYPD still controls the timing and degree of access to footage, frequently holding up cases past the statute of limitations for many disciplinary charges. And under Adams, Muir noted, the number of staffers in the Office of the Inspector General shrank to just three, down from 37 during de Blasio’s mayoralty. That office is meant to complement the CCRB by focusing on the bigger-picture issues with the NYPD as the CCRB investigates individual complaints and officers. Tisch, Adams’s fourth and final police commissioner, has allowed the CCRB notably more independence than Adams’s second commissioner, Edward Caban, who overturned some 70 percent of CCRB disciplinary recommendations and made a habit of tossing charges the CCRB substantiated within 60 days of their deadline. Still, she continued to exercise her power to block cases regularly in 2025 (she has only done so once since Mamdani’s term started), and her decision to overturn the firing of the lieutenant who killed Allan Feliz provoked outrage. “I cannot wait for the day that the Adams administration is over, and with it, he takes Commissioner Tisch,” a Bronx councilmember said at a rally for Feliz following the decision. This summer, then-candidate Mamdani caused a brief commotion when he expressed support for a more independent CCRB, rather than the police commissioner, to have the final word on discipline, saying he would “ensure that the recommendations of the CCRB be understood to be the final voice of the question of accountability.” Shortly after this dust-up, however, Mamdani asked Tisch to stay on as police commissioner—the first time an incoming mayor has retained a predecessor’s commissioner in half a century. The day after the announcement, Mamdani backtracked, now saying merely that the CCRB’s recommendations “should be taken seriously” and that the agency should receive more funding. (The Times reported that Tisch made retaining final authority a condition of her acceptance of the job). This has left many onlookers skeptical of Mamdani’s commitment to taking power back from the NYPD. The decision to retain Tisch “brings great concern for us about…how the CCRB can be changed and reformed within this administration,” Feliz told Bolts. Case likened Mamdani’s power to effect outcomes at the CCRB to his famous “Freeze the rent” campaign pledge: “Mamdani can’t unilaterally freeze the rent—but he can appoint the rental guidelines board.” The mayor, he said, can appoint CCRB members who are willing to reconsider established policy, take on the police unions, and even sue the commissioner. A bolder CCRB could end the custom of having one police representative on each three-member panel. Long-term, the Justice Committee wants NYPD-appointed board members off the CCRB entirely, arguing the department is already overrepresented throughout a supposedly independent process. Such a change would require a revision to the city charter, which would have to happen through popular referendum, but the mayor can initiate the process. (There is recent precedent—in 2019, the charter was revised to add a public advocate designee to the board). Case also supports moving disciplinary trials under the same administrative office that adjudicates other city employees’ disciplinary proceedings. Come fall, Mamdani will have to make a decision regarding the fate of Pat Smith, the interim chair under Adams who has overturned up to 50 percent of his investigators’ charging guidelines. While Mamdani installed another board member with a more traditional police reform background as interim chair in March, Smith remains on the board; his term is up in November. The Justice Committee is asking Mamdani to remove Smith, who Liem said “has consistently been an adversary of police oversight and accountability.” The mayor’s office declined to respond on the record to a detailed request for comment about how Mamdani would use his power, but offered a statement to Bolts: “Public trust in policing cannot exist without real accountability. New Yorkers deserve an independent CCRB with the power, resources, and autonomy to hold misconduct accountable and bring transparency to our public safety system. The Mamdani administration will continue to support civilian oversight, protect due process, and uphold a fair, credible legal framework for governing police oversight and discipline.” The city council, which like the mayor has control over five of the 15 CCRB seats, also has a role to play in making the board more effective, namely by filling empty seats. Disciplinary panels have been cancelled because the board has had only 11 members for months now. Bolts asked the public advocate and the Bronx and Staten Island city council delegations why these three seats are vacant. Representatives for the public advocate and the Staten Island delegations did not respond to repeated requests for comment; the Bronx delegation would not comment on the record. Feliz noted that the NYPD has no trouble keeping their three positions filled: “Those seats are never empty.” The council could also choose to bring back the bill giving the CCRB automatic access to bodyworn camera footage —which many other cities already have — but no sponsor has emerged yet this session. The CCRB’s 2025 annual report noted that lack of resources has led to case triage. Mamdani’s recently unveiled budget includes $3.2 million in new spending for the CCRB, a promising development if enacted: it would seemingly allow the board to hire well beyond the eight new positions the budget endows. “My position was always, you should tie the CCRB budget to the police department budget,” Ofer said. (Mamdani’s executive budget includes an additional $120 million for the NYPD). Last year, the city spent over $117 million dollars on legal settlements to civilians who experienced police misconduct (and the true number is likely higher, since this doesn’t include payouts that were agreed upon prior to formal litigation). Case noted that the city continues to spend millions of dollars paying a federal monitor because the NYPD has not been able to get out of stop-and-frisk oversightfor one main reason: it’s not disciplining officers. “If the city were to take a quarter of the money that is paying the monitor and give it to the CCRB in order to appropriately and thoroughly discipline officers, it would be out of the monitorship in two years and be able to spend the rest of the money on free busses,” he said. Longer-term, Muir said, the CCRB’s jurisdiction should be expanded and the board empowered to investigate the NYPD in a more comprehensive and holistic fashion. Robust independent oversight is “core to the public’s confidence in the NYPD behaving ethically, which is a serious concern post-Eric Adams.” he said. “We got all these lawsuits, we got all these scandals, and then we got radio silence. And I want to know what happened, and I think a lot of New Yorkers and people around the world do too.” Muir added, “Whatever it takes to have that happen, that’s what Mamdani has got to do – and that’s what the leaders across New York have to do.”

  • Allan Feliz’s Family Challenges NYPD Commissioner's Refusal to Fire Killer Cop in State Supreme Court Hearing 

    Suit calls Commissioner Tisch’s decision to overturn her own deputy commissioner’s guilty verdict an abuse of discretion New York, NY – Today, the family of Allan Feliz asked the New York State Supreme Court to order NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch to fire the police officer who killed him more than six years ago. In an oral argument on the landmark lawsuit filed by the family and Justice Committee in October 2025, their lawyers argued that Tisch abused her discretion when she rejected the ruling of her own deputy commissioner, who found Lt. Rivera guilty of excessive force and recommended he be fired. Rivera is the third officer to be found guilty for killing a New Yorker via an NYPD discipline trial, following Daniel Pantaleo, who killed Eric Garner in 2014, and Richard Haste, who killed Ramarley Graham in 2012. “I was born and raised in New York City, but now I can’t imagine staying in this place that has caused my family so much harm – I don’t want us to live in a place where police get away with killing people with impunity,” said Julie Aquino, partner of Allan Feliz and mother of Allan’s son, Eli. “I hope Justice Saunders sees this case for what it is: Jessica Tisch’s decision to overturn the guilty verdict was unjust and illegal. It should be reversed and Rivera should be fired. Then, this overwhelming fear that comes from knowing Lt. Rivera is patrolling the city will be relieved. Then I can tell our son there was finally some justice for his father.” The Article 78 petition, filed on behalf of the Feliz family and Justice Committee by the Center for Constitutional Rights, LatinoJustice PRLDEF, Beldock, Levine, & Hoffman LLP, and civil rights attorney Gideon Oliver, says Commissioner Tisch’s “arbitrary and capricious” refusal to fire Rivera has caused the Feliz family harm that compounds their suffering over the loss of their loved one. “Lt. Rivera shot a teenager 16 times in 2013, wasn’t fired, and went on to kill Allan Feliz,” said Justice Committee Deputy Director Yul-san Liem. “He has a record seven lawsuits and 40 misconduct allegations, including multiple since taking Allan’s life. Commissioner Tisch’s decision to overturn her own Deputy Commissioner’s guilty verdict and allow Rivera to keep his badge and gun was illegal, corrupt, and a message to officers that they can abuse New Yorkers with impunity. In filing Samy Feliz v Jessica Tisch, we are calling on the court to recognize this and take action so that Rivera cannot harm anyone else and NYPD commissioners – including Tisch and any that come after her – understand that they are not above the law.” “Allan Feliz should be alive today, and it is shocking that the NYPD promoted and continues to protect the individual who killed him, Lt. Jonathan Rivera,” said Samah Sisay, Staff Attorney at the Center for Constitutional Rights. “Allan Feliz’s family and Justice Committee have been harmed by Police Commissioner Tisch’s irrational decision to ignore the trial evidence and recommendation to fire Lt. Rivera, and the court must hold her accountable.” “The refusal to fire Lt. Jonathan Rivera despite overwhelming evidence of misconduct and a clear recommendation for termination sends a dangerous message that NYPD officers who abuse their power and take lives can continue to operate with impunity,” said Andrew Case, Supervising Counsel at LatinoJustice PRLDEF. “For the Feliz family this case is about accountability, truth, and dignity. LatinoJustice PRLDEF stands with them in demanding that the courts reject this arbitrary decision and affirm that no officer is above the law.” “Commissioner Tisch’s decision constitutes both a clear abuse of discretion and a complete disregard for police accountability,” said Olivia Clark, an attorney at Beldock Levine & Hoffman, LLP. “Her decision, which is neither legally or factually sound, should be reversed, and Rivera must finally be held responsible for the death of Allan Feliz, who would be alive today if not for Rivera’s violent conduct.” The oral argument took place just days after 20 elected officials sent a letter to Mayor Zorhan Mamdani calling for Lt. Rivera to be fired in conjunction with a separate substantiated misconduct charge for an illegal summons he issued to a New Yorker a few years after killing Mr. Feliz. “It’s outrageous that we have to file a lawsuit and go back to court after over a decade of fighting NYPD and police union obstructions and ensuring Rivera faced a discipline trial and was found guilty,” said Samy Feliz, brother of Allan Feliz. “Tisch and Mamdani have the opportunity to do the right thing and put an end to our suffering right now. Rivera is a repeat offender. He’s got a separate serious misconduct case against him for harming someone else. Mayor Mamdani and Commissioner Tisch can and must fire him today.” Background On October 17, 2019, in the Bronx, Lt. Rivera, then a sergeant, and two other officers pulled Mr. Feliz over for allegedly not wearing a seatbelt. (Bodyworn camera footage would show the officers acknowledging that he was, in fact, wearing a seatbelt.) During the struggle that ensued, Sgt. Rivera climbed into the passenger side of the car, tasered, beat, threatened to shoot, and then shot Mr. Feliz in the chest, killing him. After several years of intentional delays by the NYPD, in May 2023, the Civilian Complaint Review Board substantiated fireable charges against Lt. Rivera. In November 2024, an NYPD discipline trial proved he killed Feliz because the struggle had tired him out. “My hand was getting tired,” he explained immediately afterward. He later claimed that he had feared for the life of one of the other officers. But Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado, who presided over the hearing, said his story was a “carefully constructed departure from the truth” that “fell apart under the weight of the credible evidence.” Maldonado found Rivera guilty of excessive force and assault in the first degree and recommended his immediate termination. In July 2025, Commissioner Tisch overturned the guilty verdict and issued a preliminary order dismissing charges against Lt. Rivera, relying on a 2020 Office of Attorney General (OAG) report. But the OAG was considering criminal charges and used a beyond-a-reasonable doubt standard, a higher burden of proof than the preponderance-of-evidence standard in police discipline proceedings. Further, the OAG report long predates the trial and does include the evidence that led to his guilty verdict. Commissioner Tisch issued her final decision to let Lt. Rivera walk in August 2025. The Feliz family and Justice Committee are currently suing Commissioner Tisch for her arbitrary and capricious decision to ignore her Deputy Commissioner’s guilty verdict and let Rivera off with no discipline. Since killing Mr. Feliz in 2019, Jonathan Rivera was promoted to lieutenant and received another six misconduct allegations, including a substantiated unlawful summons. Rivera has been named in seven lawsuits, costing the City at least $115,000 in settlements so far. ### Since the 1980s, Justice Committee (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice. LatinoJustice PRLDEF works to create a more just society by using and challenging the rule of law to secure transformative, equitable and accessible justice, by empowering our community and by fostering leadership through advocacy and education. For over 50 years, LatinoJustice PRLDEF has acted as an advocate against injustices throughout the country. The Center for Constitutional Rights works with communities under threat to fight for justice and liberation through litigation, advocacy, and strategic communications. Since 1966, the Center for Constitutional Rights has taken on oppressive systems of power, including structural racism, gender oppression, economic inequity, and governmental overreach. Follow the Center for Constitutional Rights on social media: Center for Constitutional Rights on Facebook, @theCCR on Twitter, ccrjustice on Instagram, and @ccrjustice.org on Bluesky.

  • 20 Electeds Deliver Letter Urging Mayor and NYPD Commissioner to Fire Jonathan Rivera Over Deadly Force & Repeated Misconduct

    New York, NY –– Today, elected officials joined the family of Allan Feliz, advocates, and community members to call on NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch to fire repeat offender Lt. Jonathan Rivera and Mayor Zohran Mamdani to ensure she does so. The rally was organized in response to a troubling plea deal offered to Rivera by the Civilian Complaint Review Board that would allow him to once again avoid meaningful discipline, despite his documented pattern of abuse, including killing unarmed father Allan Feliz in 2019. Rivera has a history of 40 misconduct allegations and 7 lawsuits, including one filed after he shot an unarmed teenager sixteen times. “Rivera murdered my brother in 2019, but even though he was found guilty by the NYPD’s Deputy Commissioner of Trials, he has never faced discipline,” said Samy Feliz, brother of Allan Feliz. “Instead, Rivera has continued harming New Yorkers while the NYPD, the lieutenants union, and now even the CCRB protects him. Mayor Mamdani, you stood with my family and called for Rivera to be fired while you were an Assemblymember and on the campaign trail. Now, you have the power to see it through. Direct your Police Commissioner to reject this plea deal and fire Rivera before he can harm another New Yorker.” “After over half a decade of tireless advocacy from the Feliz family, it is time to turn the page,” said Council Member Carmen De La Rosa. “This plea deal does not meet the devastation that this family has faced and the trust lost in our communities. We must show New Yorkers that accountability and transparency matters, and the demand has been clear — Lieutenant Rivera must be fired.” Although Rivera accepted the plea deal at the end of April, the final discipline decision to either accept or reject it rests with Commissioner Tisch, but the Feliz family and advocates have little faith in her after she overturned her own deputy commissioner’s guilty verdict against Rivera for killing Allan Feliz last year, allowing him to keep his job. Prior to the rally, Council Member De La Rosa sent a letter from her and 19 of her city and state colleagues, urging mayor Mamdani - who previously called for Rivera to be fired and who recently asserted his control over the NYPD - to use his power to ensure Rivera is dismissed. “Mayor Mamdani, your backing has been invaluable; you signed two letters and rallied with the Feliz family outside One Police Plaza, advocating for Lt. Rivera’s dismissal from the department. We once again seek your support on this vital issue you previously championed,” the letter reads. “We ask that you employ your power as Mayor to direct NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch to deny the plea deal and promptly dismiss Lt. Rivera. This is for the family of Allan Feliz, the everyday New Yorker who desires transparency and accountability from our police, and everyone harmed by Lieutenant Rivera’s actions while in the line of duty.” “It is truly sickening to know that Jonathan Rivera, who is responsible for the murder of Allan Feliz, is still a Lieutenant within our police force. This is a danger to our citizens, and not the public safety I want for our children, neighbors, and friends,” said Council Member Alexa Avilés. “Jonathan Rivera must be removed from the force immediately and the unjust system that has allowed him to remain in his position must be rooted out. His story is evidence of the systemic harm plaguing the NYPD. It is beyond heartbreaking and unacceptable. My heart goes out to the Feliz family, who is still suffering from the loss of their loved one.” “Jonathan Rivera’s case exposes how fundamentally biased and corrupt the NYPD discipline system is,” said Justice Committee Executive Director Loyda Colón (they/them). “An officer with 40 misconduct allegations, multiple substantiated complaints, multiple lawsuits, and a record of deadly violence was not only allowed to keep his job after murdering Allan Feliz — he was promoted and has continued harming New Yorkers. Rivera’s recent plea bargain reeks of a backroom deal to protect an officer who the NYPD’s own Deputy Commissioner found guilty of excessive force and assault after determining he lied on the stand. As an Assemblymember, Mamdani stood with Allan’s family and called for Rivera to be fired. Now he has both the responsibility and the power to follow through by directing Commissioner Tisch to reject this disgraceful plea deal and finally fire Rivera from the NYPD before another family is forced to suffer. Our safety depends on it.” ### Background NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera has a history of 40 misconduct allegations, 5 of which have been substantiated by the CCRB. Not included in these allegations (because a CCRB complaint wasn’t filed) is the 2013 shooting of an unarmed Black 15-year-old, who Rivera fired at 16 times, including as he appeared to surrender. Not only does he have a lengthy misconduct record, but Rivera has a history of being shielded from discipline. On October 17, 2019, then-Sgt. Rivera and Officers Edward Barrett and Michelle Almanzar pulled Allan Feliz over in an unjust traffic stop and illegally detained him. Rivera tasered, beat and threatened to shoot Mr. Feliz, and then shot him point blank in the chest. After years of delays and obstruction, the CCRB substantiated fireable charges against Rivera and then prosecuted him at a discipline trial in November 2024. In February 2025, Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado determined Lt. Rivera to be guilty of excessive force and assault in the first degree and recommended he be fired, noting that he was not credible and lied on the stand to protect himself. Despite public outcry, Commissioner Tisch unjustifiably overturned Maldonado’s guilty verdict and refused to fire Lt. Rivera in August 2025. The Feliz family and Justice Committee are currently suing Commissioner Tisch for her arbitrary and capricious decision to ignore her Deputy Commissioner’s guilty verdict and let Rivera off with no discipline. Since killing Mr. Feliz in 2019, Jonathan Rivera was promoted to Lieutenant and received another 6 misconduct allegations, including a substantiated unlawful summons. Rivera has been named in 7 lawsuits, costing the City at least $115,000 in settlements so far. About the Justice Committee: Since the 1980s, the Justice Committee (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice.

  • 20 City & State Elected Officials Call for the Immediate Firing of Lt. Jonathan Rivera in Letter to Mayor Mamdani & Commissioner Tisch

    May 11, 2026 Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch New York Police Department 1 Police Plaza New York, NY 10038 Mayor Zohran Mamdani City Hall New York, NY 10007 cc: Jonathan Darche, Executive Director, Civilian Complaint Review Board Re: Call for the Immediate Firing of Lt. Jonathan Rivera Dear Commissioner Tisch and Mayor Mamdani, We, the 20 undersigned New York City, State and Congressional elected leaders, write to call for the immediate termination of Lt. Jonathan Rivera from the NYPD. Lt. Rivera has a documented pattern of abuse: he shot an unarmed 15-year-old in 2013, brutally killed Allan Feliz in 2019, and has continuously accumulated 40 misconduct allegations and at least 7 lawsuits. His appalling history of abuse, as substantiated by NYPD Deputy Commissioner Rosemarie Maldonado’s guilty verdict in the killing of Allan Feliz and a more recent substantiated charge for issuing an unlawful summons, makes him clearly unfit to serve. Until recently, the Civilian Complaint Review Board was on track to prosecute Lt. Rivera and seek termination. The CCRB’s sudden offering of a plea deal enables a notoriously violent officer to continue patrolling our streets. We urge you to reject this plea deal as contrary to the safety of New Yorkers, and to instead fire Lt. Rivera without access to his pension or a “good-guy” letter that would allow him to keep his gun. Commissioner Tisch, your decision last year to overturn the guilty verdict against Lt. Rivera for killing unarmed Allan Feliz eroded New Yorkers’ faith in the NYPD and its discipline system. We urge you not to repeat the same error. We call on you to reject the CCRB’s plea deal and fire Lt. Rivera from the NYPD immediately, without pension benefits or a “good guy” letter that would allow him to retain his firearm. Mayor Mamdani, your backing has been invaluable; you signed two letters* and rallied with the Feliz family outside One Police Plaza, advocating for Lt. Rivera’s dismissal from the department. We once again seek your support on this vital issue you previously championed. We ask that you employ your power as Mayor to direct NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch to deny the plea deal and promptly dismiss Lt. Rivera. This is for the family of Allan Feliz, the everyday New Yorker who desires transparency and accountability from our police, and everyone harmed by Lieutenant Rivera’s actions while in the line of duty. Accountability is not about punishment for its own sake; it is about restoring public trust. Every instance where misconduct goes unchecked wears away the relationship between the NYPD and the communities it is sworn to protect, endangering our public safety goals as a city. As City leaders, you have the opportunity to affirm your commitment to police accountability and genuine public safety. We urge you to do the right thing: reject the CCRB’s plea deal and fire Lt. Rivera from the NYPD immediately, without pension benefits or a “good-guy” letter that would allow him to retain his firearm. Sincerely, NYC Council Member Carmen De La Rosa NY State Senator Jessica Ramos NY State Senator Julia Salazar NY State Assembly Member Emily Gallagher NYC Public Advocate Jumaane D. Williams Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso NYC Council Member Alexa Avilés NYC Council Member Chi Ossé NYC Council Member Chris Banks NYC Council Member Christopher Marte NYC Council Member Crystal Hudson NYC Council Member Harvey Epstein NYC Council Member Jennifer Gutiérrez NYC Council Member Julie Won NYC Council Member Lincoln Restler NYC Council Member Pierina Ana Sanchez NYC Council Member Sandy Nurse NYC Council Member Shahana Hanif NYC Council Member Shekar Krishnan NYC Council Member Tiffany Cabán *The second letter is here.

  • [AmDam] Mamdani once called for his firing, now this NYPD officer faces discipline for another misconduct claim.

    Published Thursday, May 7, 2026 By Tandy Lau Lt. Jonathan Rivera, who NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch refused to fire for killing Washington Heights man Allan Feliz, pleaded guilty last week to an Abuse of Authority allegation for unlawful summons from a 2023 incident. He will likely lose 20 vacation days, but keep his job after a separate substantiated misconduct complaint for an offense potentially punishable by termination. Previous calls to fire Rivera stem from him fatally shooting Feliz during a 2019 Bronx traffic stop and came from multiple elected officials, including Mayor Zohran Mamdani when he was a state assemblymember. Last year, the NYPD’s own administrative judge ruled in favor of terminating the officer for violating department rules following a long-delayed disciplinary trial. But Tisch, who gets sole discretion, reversed course and handed down no punishment for killing Feliz. Retaining Rivera drew criticism for the NYPD disciplinary process, which allows a police deputy commissioner to internally preside as judge over misconduct trials and the commissioner to overrule any rulings made during the proceedings. Tisch, who made the call under Mamdani’s predecessor Eric Adams, was retained by the current administration. Under the NYPD disciplinary matrix, improper or wrongful enforcement action involving abuse of discretion and authority (like an unlawful summons) is a fireable offense but comes with the presumptive penalty of losing 20 vacation days. Much like traditional criminal cases, Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) prosecutors can reach a plea agreement with the offending officer in lieu of a trial. Again, Tisch will make the final call on what discipline Rivera actually faces. “The CCRB investigates each case in an independent and impartial fashion, following the evidence and the law in making its determinations,” said CCRB spokesperson Dakota Gardner in an emailed statement. “Lt. Rivera pled guilty to an Abuse of Authority allegation relating to an unlawful summons and will forfeit 20 vacation days as discipline — pending Police Commissioner approval. This is the presumptive penalty under the NYPD disciplinary matrix.” The unlawful summons occurred years after Feliz’s death and while disciplinary proceedings against Rivera brewed. While the complainant’s identity remains unknown, filings show a Black male in his mid-late 30s made the allegation. Feliz’s younger brother, Samy, expressed frustration with the plea, as he hoped the CCRB would pursue termination in a disciplinary trial against Rivera due to his misconduct history. “This is just an officer that [continues] harmful practices [that] are going to put all New Yorkers at risk,” said Samy Feliz in a phone interview. “As a family who’s been vocal about removing this officer from the police force, we now feel like either Commissioner Tisch or Mayor Mamdani have to do what’s right and remove this police officer.” Mamdani’s public calls for firing Rivera over the killing of Feliz date back as recently as early last year when the NYPD courts made the guilty verdict and Tisch was already appointed commissioner. In a Feb. 2025 press conference, he deemed the officer’s termination “the most basic form of justice.” A month later, Mamdani signed a letter to Tisch calling for Rivera’s firing over the NYPD trial court’s decision. The ruling did not come easily, either. Feliz’s family fought for years to try Rivera in a disciplinary trial, which finally occurred late 2024, around when Tisch was appointed. Just one other officer — Daniel Pantaleo for the death of Eric Garner — faced a similar guilty verdict and was fired soon after. After Feliz’s death, the NYPD promoted Rivera from sergeant to lieutenant. He was also involved in non-fatally shooting a Black teenager in 2013, allegedly firing 16 shots and landing three. The incident is not documented in Rivera’s misconduct history. Video evidence obtained years later by the New York Daily News showed the 15-year-old unarmed and surrendering. Concerns over the NYPD deploying officers with long misconduct track records remain after cellphone footage caught two narcotics squad detectives beating a Black man named Timothy Brown and allegedly dragging him across broken glass in a Brooklyn liquor store last month over mistaken identity. The CCRB previously substantiated Abuse of Authority allegations against both officers, according to a claim of notice court filing. Efforts to remove Rivera from the NYPD continue next week. Opening arguments for an Article 78 lawsuit filed to reverse Tisch’s decision will take place next Thursday. If successful, the courts could overrule the commissioner to fire Rivera for killing Feliz. The NYPD did not respond to a request to comment.

bottom of page