Search Results
Search this site
419 results found with an empty search
- LETTER: Almost 50 Orgs Write to Mayor Mamdani’s New Office of Community Safety
Dear Mayor Mamdani, We, the undersigned, 48 organizations, write to share feedback, concerns and recommendations as you continue to develop the Office of Community Safety (OCS), move towards its expansion into a full Department of Community Safety (DCS), and further shape your administration’s approach to addressing the interconnected issues of homelessness, substance use and unmet mental health needs in ways that increase access to care and improve safety for all. For far too long, the City’s approach to these critical public health issues has been characterized by criminalization and police intervention – an ineffective, costly and harmful approach that often results in unnecessary violence and worsening outcomes for the very people who need care, support and a vast array of social services, including housing. New York’s most vulnerable communities, including Black, brown and immigrant communities bear the brunt of this harm and would greatly benefit from a different approach. The launch of the Office of Community Safety, and stated intention to expand it to a full department, presents a meaningful opportunity to chart a different, holistic path forward, one rooted in care, prevention and meeting the needs of the most vulnerable New Yorkers. To realize this, the development of OCS and its expansion into DCS must be undertaken intentionally and in partnership with organizations like ours — groups that are led by and serve New Yorkers directly impacted by the current system. This includes people who have experienced mental health or substance use crises, homelessness, and family members whose loved ones were harmed or killed during police responses to crises and perceived crises. The long-term goal must be for the City to develop a cohesive, health- and care-first response to these issues so that they can be effectively addressed. This effort must be paired with a clear commitment to reduce—and ultimately end—the criminalization of people who are unhoused, live with substance use, or are navigating mental health concerns, otherwise it will not succeed. We highlight below several key principles and priorities that must guide the City’s approach to acute situations involving homelessness, substance use, and mental health: 1. Build a robust system of crisis response teams with leadership from communities, service providers and experts The City should work with community organizations and crisis response experts who have successfully built non-police response systems in other municipalities to develop a model rooted in established best practices. The current model, BHEARD, does not follow proven best practices, manages only a fraction of mental health calls citywide, overrelies on traumatizing involuntary hospitalizations, remains too reliant on police infrastructure and policy, and has demonstrably failed to meaningfully reduce police involvement in mental health crises. Crisis response should: Be culturally competent. The program should involve peers and people with lived experience throughout the process from program creation, execution, evaluation and staffing Invest in proven, evidence- and health-based models like Housing First Prioritize voluntary, non-coercive engagement, de-escalation, and a harm reduction approach Connect individuals to suitable long-term, wraparound care—including housing, healthcare, and case management—not just immediate stabilization Operate within a coordinated, citywide system with consistent standards and resources Not include co-response with the NYPD 2. Establish authority to drive accountability and alignment, including meaningful authority over the NYPD The full Department of Community Safety should be built out as a coordinating and oversight body with real authority to drive accountability and alignment across city agencies. This includes having the authority to set and enforce limits on the NYPD with respect to crisis response, require participation in interagency coordination, and ensure compliance with new protocols. As currently structured, the Executive Order does not grant OCS sufficient authority to fulfill this role. 3. Align broader policies to prioritize (implement) effective interventions, while ending ineffective criminalization approaches The success of OCS/DCS depends on broader policy alignment across the administration. It is concerning that, in spite of campaign promises, your administration has not halted Adams-era criminalization efforts, including: sweeps of homeless encampments, arrest surges on low-level drugs charges and continued aggressive broken windows enforcement by the NYPD through expansion into non-criminal, non-emergency complaints from 311. These tactics have failed to yield increased public safety and must be ended in favor of care-based approaches that take us out of the cycle of ineffective, violent interventions. 4. Transform call triage and dispatch systems A truly effective crisis response system requires significant changes to how calls for support are classified and routed. The City must redesign 911 and 311 triage and dispatch systems to incorporate mental health expertise, including new call coding, improved assessment tools, interoperability and specialized training for dispatchers. Over time, crisis response infrastructure related to mental health, homelessness and drug use should be separated from NYPD control. 5. Invest in care, prevention, and community-based support. This includes significantly scaling up proven services such as Intensive Mobile Treatment (IMT) teams, IMT step down, crisis stabilization centers, respite centers, and community-based behavioral health services as well as expanding access to low-barrier housing. A critical expansion of a social services workforce will also be required. These recommendations are informed by the expertise of our organizations’ members and participants, who are directly impacted by the City’s failed approach to addressing housing, mental health and substance use concerns and by our decades of experience serving New Yorkers. Your acknowledgement that the status quo approach is untenable gives us hope that real change is possible. For too long these issues have been considered by politicians to be intractable but we know – and nearly 200 cities around the country know – that solutions exist and that with the appropriate political will we can develop an effective response to reduce and eliminate public suffering. Doing so successfully will provide a vision for governance that can solve what is really a nationwide humanitarian and political crisis. We look forward to collaborating with your administration to implement these principles and to ensure meaningful community leadership as this process moves forward. Signed: The Ali Forney Center Alliance for Quality Education Allan Feliz Foundation Amadou Diallo Foundation Asian American Legal Defense and Education Fund Beldock Levine & Hoffman Brandworkers Brooklyn Defender Services Campaign Zero Center for Community Alternatives Center for Constitutional Rights The Circle Keepers Citizen Action of New York Coalition for the Homeless Community Connections For Youth, Inc Dream.Org Drug Policy Alliance DRUM Equality for Flatbush Families and Friends of the Wrongfully Convicted Freedom Agenda Fountain House The Gathering for Justice Gender Liberation Movement Housing Works Immigrant Defense Project Justice Committee Jews for Racial & Economic Justice Jim Owles Liberal Democratic Club Justice and Beyond Lambda Independent Democrats of Brooklyn LatinoJustice PRLDEF Legal Action Center Long Island Social Justice Action Network (LISJAN) Malcolm X Grassroots Movement Make the Road New York Muslim Community Network (MCN) Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem New Hour for Women and Children New York Communities for Change New York Immigration Coalition NYCLU Rise Up for Ramarley Safety Net Project at the Urban Justice Center St. Mary's Episcopal Church, Harlem SURJ NYC VOCAL-NY Youth Represent
- 47 Organizations Issue Blueprint for Mayor Mamdani’s New Office of Community Safety
Ahead of Mamdani’s executive budget, coalition demands meaningful authority over NYPD, investments in services, and binding commitments for change NEW YORK — Today, a coalition of almost 50 organizations, including mental health providers, civil rights groups, legal services, religious, community, youth and immigration organizations cosigned a letter to Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Deputy Mayor of Community Safety Renita Francois, providing a blueprint for the Office of Community Safety in order to have a truly transformative impact on public safety. The letter was sent in advance of the release of the Mayor’s executive budget, now due May 12, which will shed more light on the direction of the new office after being excluded from the preliminary budget in February, leaving its priorities unclear. “For far too long, the City’s approach to these critical public health issues has been characterized by criminalization and police intervention – an ineffective, costly and harmful approach that often results in unnecessary violence and worsening outcomes for the very people who need care, support and a vast array of social services, including housing,” the letter states. “New York’s most vulnerable communities, including Black, brown and immigrant communities, bear the brunt of this harm and would greatly benefit from a different approach.” The coalition listed best practices and principles for non-police response and policy areas that the Administration should focus on in order to ensure effective implementation, including: Build a robust system of culturally competent, non-police crisis response teams with leadership from communities, service providers and experts; Establish authority to drive accountability and alignment, including meaningful authority over the NYPD; Align broader policies to prioritize effective interventions, while ending ineffective criminalization approaches including sweeps of homeless encampments and rising court cases for sleeping on the subway, arrest surges on low-level drug charges, and continued aggressive broken windows enforcement; Transform call triage and dispatch systems for 911, 311 and 988; and Invest in care, prevention, and community-based support, including Intensive Mobile Treatment (IMT) teams, IMT step down, crisis stabilization centers, respite centers, community-based behavioral health services, and low-barrier housing. “As long as the City continues sending armed officers as first responders, we are endangering the most vulnerable New Yorkers,” said Loyda Colón (they/them), Executive Director of Justice Committee. “Mental health, substance use, and homelessness are not public safety issues, and they never should have been treated as such. Mayor Mamdani’s new Office of Community Safety is a necessary acknowledgement that our current system is failing New Yorkers, but it falls dangerously short without dismantling armed police response. Expanding the failed B-HEARD program is case in point: the vast majority of calls are routed to police, teams often fail to meet best practices, and the overreliance on traumatizing involuntary hospitalizations leaves people disconnected from their communities and the long-term care they need. We need to see significant investments in preventative and post-crisis care, accessible services, housing, and other non-punitive approaches alongside the removal of NYPD from crisis response in order to see and experience real systemic change.” “When I called for help for a family member in crisis I didn’t have any options and only the police showed up. They came in guns drawn and the situation almost ended up in a death,” said Susan Shervington, a community leader at VOCAL-NY. “When I call for a mental health crisis, I’m calling for a non-police response – so that people with mental health expertise and experience deescalating these specific types of incidents can respond. I’m hoping that the Mayor will listen to those of us with lived experience and change the way the City handles these issues to prevent more harm and even deaths.” "In March, a large group of New York's leading civil rights advocates gathered at City Hall to celebrate the announcement of the Office of Community Safety, recognizing that it was an important first step towards a more serious overhaul of how this administration will approach public safety. With Mayor Mamdani's first budget approaching, we want to make clear that we want to see a robust Department of Community Safety that will bring the resources and attention to crisis response that the people of this city deserve, have been asking for, and were promised by Mayor Mamdani during his candidacy,” said Janos Marton, Chief Advocacy Officer, Dream.Org. BACKGROUND: Then-candidate Mamdani campaigned on the idea of creating a non-police response team as a part of his public safety plan, entitled the Department of Community Safety. Last year, Councilmember Restler introduced legislation to create this agency, and in January, a mix of more than 30 service providers and legal, advocacy and anti-violence groups cosigned a letter calling for a hearing on legislation to create a Department of Community Safety. In March, Mayor Mamdani signed an executive order establishing the Office of Community Safety as a first step toward realizing his plans for a Department, appointing Renita Francois to oversee gun violence prevention, mental health and substance abuse treatment, hate crime prevention, victims services, and subway safety as Deputy Mayor. ###
- CCRB Plea Deal Keeps Notoriously Abusive Cop on the Street; Sparks Outrage and Demands for Mayor to Intervene
New York, NY – This morning, NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera avoided being fired for harming a New Yorker yet again, despite a record of 40 misconduct allegations and 7 lawsuits. In a shocking reversal, the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB), which was on course to prosecute him and seek termination, offered Rivera a plea deal for his latest misconduct - issuing an unlawful summons. The deal means Rivera will avoid a discipline trial and is merely being docked vacation days. This deal comes a year after NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado found Lt. Rivera guilty of excessive force and assault in the first degree and recommended he be fired for killing Allan Feliz, but Commissioner Jessica Tisch unjustifiably overturned the verdict. In response, Samy Feliz, brother of Allan Feliz issued the following statement: “Jonathan Rivera should have been fired after he shot an unarmed 15-year-old in 2013. Instead, he went on to kill my brother, Allan Feliz, in 2019. Then he was outrageously promoted to lieutenant, even as the discipline case for Allan’s murder was ongoing, allowing him to continue abusing New Yorkers, like the person he illegally targeted in this latest case. Lt. Rivera is a threat to all New Yorkers. Mayor Mamdani, while campaigning you stood with my family outside One Police Plaza calling for Lt. Rivera to be fired. Now it’s time to show New Yorkers you are serious about police discipline and real safety by ensuring your Police Commissioner rejects this plea deal and fires Rivera. CCRB, why the sudden reversal? How do you go from prosecution and recommending firing again to twenty docked vacation days? This is not discipline. It just means 20 more days Lt. Jonathan Rivera is patrolling our streets, armed and dangerous – and somehow, it’s still more discipline than he received for murdering my brother in cold blood. NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch, the Lieutenants Union, and now even the CCRB have bent over backwards to protect Lt. Rivera. The only way to understand the CCRB’s plea bargain is as a backroom deal with the NYPD and Mamdani Administration aimed at letting him off the hook at the expense of New Yorkers’ safety. If and when Rivera harms or kills someone else, the blood will be on all of their hands.” “This latest move by the CCRB reeks of a backroom deal designed to once again protect a notoriously dangerous cop with a terrifying number of misconduct complaints, who was found to have lied under oath, shot an unarmed teenager, killed an unarmed father, and has cost this city at least $115,000 in lawsuits. It is a cowardly betrayal of the New Yorkers the CCRB allegedly serves,” said Loyda Colón (they/them), Executive Director of Justice Committee. “Even the NYPD’s own Deputy Commissioner of Trials agreed that Lt. Rivera should not be allowed to keep his job, badge, and gun. The CCRB should be held to account. Mayor Mamdani has recently asserted that he ‘holds the final decision’ over policing matters. Now is the time to prove it. He must order the Police Commissioner to reject this plea deal and fire Lt. Rivera before he can harm another New Yorker.” Background NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera has a history of 40 misconduct allegations, 5 of which have been substantiated by the CCRB. Not included in these allegations (because a CCRB complaint wasn’t filed) is the 2013 shooting of an unarmed Black 15-year-old, who Rivera fired at 16 times, including as he appeared to surrender. Not only does he have a lengthy misconduct record, but Rivera has a history of being shielded from discipline. On October 17, 2019, then-Sgt. Rivera and Officers Edward Barrett and Michelle Almanzar pulled Allan Feliz over in an unjust traffic stop and illegally detained him. Rivera tasered, beat and threatened to shoot Mr. Feliz, and then shot him point blank in the chest. After years of delays and obstruction, the CCRB substantiated fireable charges against Rivera and then prosecuted him at a discipline trial in November 2024. In February 2025, Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado determined Lt. Rivera to be guilty of excessive force and assault in the first degree and recommended he be fired, noting that he was not credible and lied on the stand to protect himself. Despite public outcry, Commissioner Tisch unjustifiably overturned Maldonado’s guilty verdict and refused to fire Lt. Rivera in August 2025. The Feliz family and Justice Committee are currently suing Commissioner Tisch for her arbitrary and capricious decision to ignore her Deputy Commissioner’s guilty verdict and let Rivera off with no discipline. Since killing Mr. Feliz in 2019, Jonathan Rivera was promoted to Lieutenant and received another 6 misconduct allegations, including a substantiated unlawful summons. Rivera has been named in 7 lawsuits, costing the City at least $115,000 in settlements so far.
- Police Union’s Lawsuit is a Brazen Attack on Transparency Wins
Police Union’s Lawsuit is a Brazen Attack on Transparency Wins Rollbacks to 50-a would endanger communities and make police discipline even more difficult Yesterday, the Police Benevolents Union (PBA) filed an outrageous lawsuit against the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) over the release of police misconduct records. In response, Loyda Colón (they/them), Executive Director of Justice Committee, issued the following statement: "The PBA’s baseless lawsuit against the CCRB is a brazen attack on transparency and part of a broader, coordinated effort by police unions to rollback the repeal of 50-a, which families whose loved ones were killed by police, organizations, and advocates fought for and won in 2020. New York already made a definitive decision on this issue when it repealed CL 50-a: by law police discipline records must be accessible to the public in the interest of civil rights, safety, and police accountability. Communities deserve to know officers’ patterns of misconduct, which may endanger their lives. Take NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera, who killed Allan Feliz during an unjust traffic stop in 2019 and has a record of 40 misconduct allegations. Five of those allegations were substantiated. If the PBA has their way, the other 35 would essentially disappear from public view. There is a critical misrepresentation at the heart of this lawsuit: the PBA wants the public to believe thatunsubstantiated complaints are synonymous with false ones. In fact, there are many reasons why a complaint may not result in substantiation, for example if a complainant becomes unavailable or, more insidiously, when NYPD appointees flip investigators’ findings, as happened in a shocking number of cases in recent years. In short, the PBA is attempting to make it more difficult for organizers, advocates, and journalists to track patterns of abuse and intervene by further obscuring the messy and corrupt reality of police discipline. This lawsuit should be rejected for what it is: a blatant attempt to shield the full truth of police abuse and rollback hard won transparency measures."
- Grassroots Coalition Against Buffer Zone Bills Statement on the Passage of Intros 1-B and 175-B
STATEMENT ON THE PASSAGE OF INTROS 1-B AND 175-B Yesterday, the New York City Council voted to pass Intros 1-B and 175-B, two bills that task the NYPD with establishing anti-protest buffer zones surrounding houses of worship and educational institutions. Both are blatant attacks against pro-Palestine protest and protected dissent at large. Despite the passage of these bills, we celebrate the tireless grassroots mobilization that has severely diminished their draconian reach and the direct harm they sought to enact on our communities. Unlike the initial proposals, the final bills no longer include blanket buffer perimeters of up to 100 feet on protests. The dilution of these bills, to the point that the NYPD insisted that it will not change its practice nor create any new legal authority or criminal liability, marks a humiliating defeat for Julie Menin's rapidly floundering Speakership, and her attempt to institute sweeping anti-Palestinian protest bans that would ultimately silence all New Yorkers. The many councilmembers who fell for Speaker Menin's empty promises betrayed their own constituents, choosing to silence them and exposing them to intensified NYPD brutality. They failed to see the bills for what they really are: an attempt to suppress pro-Palestine protests outside synagogues and college campuses complicit in US-Israel’s ongoing genocide of Palestinians, as well as an attack against all New Yorkers mobilizing for justice. Disturbingly, our local representatives have chosen to mirror the federal administration’s policy of cracking down on dissent. We are particularly concerned that members of the Council’s so-called Progressive Caucus allowed either of these bills to move forward. Councilmembers Nurse, Epstein, Brewer, Marte, Won, De La Rosa, Encarnacion, Aldebol, Farías, Thomas-Henry, Krishnan, Williams, Restler, Gutiérrez, Hudson, Joseph, Pierina Sanchez and Justin Sanchez — you are on notice. We will not forget that you voted to pass bills that will further harm New Yorkers and discourage protest. Likewise, we will not forget the councilmembers who fought for our rights: Councilmembers Ossé, Aviles, Cabán, Hanif, and Santosuosso for rejecting both bills, as well as Councilmember Stevens for rejecting 175-B and abstaining on 1-B. We are proud of the grassroots campaign we advanced in opposition to these attacks on New Yorkers. We outnumbered supporters of the bill at the February 25th hearing, applied enough pressure to water down the bills, and strengthened the bonds between our diverse organizations. Our coalition brought together all kinds of New Yorkers — pro-Palestine advocates, anti-war organizers, reproductive justice activists, faith leaders, labor and housing unions, LGBTQ+ groups, workers, teachers, and students of all ages. For the first time in City Hall, we directly called on our officials to address the issue that these bills seek to protect in the first place: the illegal sales of stolen Palestinian land taking place in our city. We reminded City Council members that while they are busy stifling our free speech, real estate companies are still using houses of worship in our neighborhoods to commit state, federal, and international crimes. Our coalition will continue to campaign at the state level against Governor Hochul’s proposed buffer zone legislation, which seeks to go even further than the city bills in criminalizing protest. And despite the passage of these bills, we will continue to protest genocide. Free Palestine. We will never be silenced. Signed, The grassroots coalition against buffer bills: 139 for Palestine Al Quds Day Committee of New York ARMOR Coalition (Armenian Organized Resistance) Art Against Displacement (AAD) Association of Legal Advocates and Attorneys - UAW 2325 Brooklyn Against War Brooklyn College Students for Justice in Palestine Capital District DSA CCNY Students for Justice in Palestine (CCNY SJP) CODEPINK NYC College of Staten Island Students for Justice in Palestine (CSI SJP) Columbia-Barnard YDSA Crown Heights Tenant Union Palestine Solidarity Working Group CUNY for Palestine CUNY Faculty and Staff for Justice in Palestine (CUNY FSJP) CUNY Graduate Center for Palestine CUNY Students for Justice in Palestine (CUNY SJP) CUNY Law Students for Justice in Palestine (CUNY Law SJP) CU Stands Up DRUM (Desis Rising Up and Moving) Fordham YDSA Indivisible Manhattan Jews Against White Supremacy (JAWS) Justice Committee Making Mensches National Lawyers Guild International Committee National Women's Liberation - NYC Chapter National Students for Justice in Palestine New York Alliance Against Racist and Political Repression (NYAARPR) New York City Labor for Palestine New York City Students for Justice in Palestine (NYC SJP) NOLSW, UAW Local 2320 NYC-DSA Anti-War Working Group NYC-DSA Socialist Feminists NYC for Abortion Rights NYC PYM NYU Law Students for Justice in Palestine NYU National Lawyers Guild Board NYU Students for a Democratic Society NYC Young Democratic Socialists of America (NYC-YDSA) PAL-Awda NY/NJ Palestinian Feminist Collective Palestine Solidarity Working Group Party for Socialism and Liberation Albany/Hudson Valley Queer Liberation March Rise and Resist SALAM (South Asian Left) Shoresh Springs of Revolution NYC Sudanese Resistance Front (SuRF) SUNY BDS SWC UAW Local 2710 (Student Workers of Columbia) The Bushwick-Ridgewood Shul The New School YDSA Undocumented Women's Fund Westchester for Palestine Within Our Lifetime Writers Against the War on Gaza
- Mamdani’s Office of Community Safety Fails to Effectively Address Mental Health Concerns
Yesterday, Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed an Executive Order establishing a new Office of Community Safety , run by Deputy Mayor Renita Francois. In response to his announcement, Loyda Colón (they/them), Justice Committee Executive Director, issued the following statement: For too long, the City’s approach to New Yorkers struggling with mental health challenges has been characterized by criminalization and police intervention, an ineffective, costly and harmful response that fails to connect people to the care they need and often results in unnecessary violence by the NYPD and even death, as in the cases of Jabez Chakraborty, Win Rozario, Kawaski Trawick, Mohamed Bah, Iman Morales, and too many others. Mayor Mamdani’s campaign promise of a Department of Community Safety and his creation of a Mayor’s Office of Community Safety as a first step towards it comes out of an acknowledgment of the need for change. However, his focus on bringing the failed B-HEARD program under MOCS and expanding it raises serious concerns. B-HEARD has consistently failed even by its own metrics: it does not follow proven best practices, manages only a fraction of mental health calls citywide, overrelies on traumatizing involuntary hospitalizations, and has demonstrably failed to reduce police involvement in mental health response, further endangering vulnerable New Yorkers when they need care the most. Expanding a failed program is not reform or transformative change, and it will only further entrench the NYPD’s role in mental health response. The city should phase out B-HEARD and instead work with crisis response experts who have successfully built non-police response systems in other municipalities to develop a model rooted in established best practices. As Mayor Mamdani continues to flesh out the full Department of Community Safety, he must do so in collaboration with those directly impacted by the city’s failed police-based mental health response and the organizations led by and accountable to them.
- Jabez Chakraborty's Arraignment from Hospital Bed Sparks Outrage; Family Demands DA Katz Drops Charges
Gunned down by NYPD while seeking care, Jabez is now being doubly punished with criminal charges while recovering from multiple gunshot wounds New York, NY– Following the video arraignment of 22-year-old Jabez Chakraborty , who was shot by NYPD Officers on January 26, Julie Chakraborty, the mother of Jabez Chakraborty , issued a statement from his family: “This is a nightmare. We didn’t need police, we just needed medical transport. When we called 911 for an ambulance, we never could have imagined that we would end up here today. Jabez and our family were safe in our home until the NYPD arrived. Now Jabez is recovering from multiple surgeries, handcuffed to a hospital bed. He has a long, difficult recovery ahead. Now, DA Katz wants to put him in prison. Hasn’t he suffered enough? Locking him up will destroy his life. All we want is for him to be able to heal. This has all been so traumatizing. We witnessed Jabez be shot right in front of us. Then the NYPD interrogated us about our immigration status, took our phones, and kept us from seeing him. Now Jabez is being unjustly charged with a crime and we are being forced to pay bail to the system that keeps hurting him. DA Katz must have no heart at all. Why does she want to torture a young man who has already suffered so much? Our family is demanding that she drop these charges against Jabez and that he be unshackled as he recovers.” Additional Quotes “DA Katz's rushed, secret indictment of Jabez and request that the Court remand him are both unnecessary and unconscionable,” said Gideon Oliver, Jabez Chakraborty’s civil attorney . “Jabez needs real help - not being locked up. We call on her to do the right thing and drop the charges.” “The system has failed Jabez on every level — and now, rather than supporting his recovery, the DA is further punishing him,” said Fahd Ahmed, Executive Director of Desis Rising Up and Moving (DRUM) . “This is the exact opposite of what Jabez needs and deserves: quality health and mental healthcare. Jabez was not a threat to his family - he was safe at home until the NYPD arrived. What purpose does it serve to punish someone who needed medical and mental health care, and got bullets instead? This shooting was not an isolated incident: it’s a devastating example of how our systems repeatedly fail the most vulnerable New Yorkers.” “We all know that the presence of armed police can trigger distress, yet the City continues to place the NYPD at the center of mental health response, and then blame the victims of their violence,” said Justice Committee Executive Director Loyda Colón . “Jabez needed care and was safe in his home, just like Win Rozario, Mohamed Bah, Iman Morales, and too many others. This is the horrifying, yet predictable result of elected officials prioritizing the NYPD over the lives and well-being of New Yorkers, while prosecutors like DA Katz criminalize and cage the most vulnerable among us in the name of ‘public safety,’ ignoring the well documented fact that incarceration results in deteriorating mental health and increased developmental harm. DA Katz must drop the charges, and Mayor Mamdani must stop defending police-led models and act on his campaign promises to remove the NYPD from mental health response.” ### About the Justice Committee: Since the 1980s, the Justice Committee (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice. About Desis Rising Up and Moving: DRUM - Desis Rising Up and Moving is a multigenerational, membership led organization of low-wage South Asian and Indo-Caribbean immigrants, workers and youth in New York City. Founded in 2000, DRUM has mobilized and built the leadership of thousands of low-income, South Asian and Indo-Caribbean immigrants to lead social and policy change that impacts their own lives- from immigrant rights to education reform, racial justice, and worker’s justice. Our membership of over 5,000 adults, youth, and families is multigenerational and represents the diaspora of the South Asian communities – Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Guyana, India, Nepal, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Suriname, Trinidad & Tobago, and beyond. In over a decade, we have built a unique model of South Asian and Indo-Caribbean undocumented workers, women, and youth led organizing for rights and justice from the local to the global rooted in base building, leadership development, running short and long term campaigns to reform policies on all levels, strong cross-community alliances locally and nationally, and building democratic and mass participatory spaces.
- NYPD Must Fire Officers Who Unnecessarily Shot Jabez Chakraborty, Probed Immigration Status, Seized Phones by Threat
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Wednesday, February 4, 2026 MEDIA CONTACTS: Tess Weiner, tess@justicecommittee.org , 224.213.5495 NYPD Must Fire Officers Who Unnecessarily Shot Jabez Chakraborty, Probed Immigration Status, Seized Phones by Threat Partial NYPD bodycam footage proves cops must be fully removed from mental health response Yesterday, the NYPD released partial bodyworn camera footage of Officer Tyree White shooting Jabez Chakraborty. In spite of the fact that the less than 2 minutes of edited footage is accompanied by 5 minutes of biased NYPD narration, the video shows clearly why the NYPD is the wrong agency to respond to mental health calls, a reality Mayor Mamdani recognized in his campaign platform to remove NYPD from mental health. Once again, we see a New Yorker who needed care and was safe in their home gunned down within minutes of officers arriving, just like Win Rozario, Mohamed Bah, and too many others. The presence of armed officers is frightening to most of us and is all too often terrifying for New Yorkers who are already in distress. In this case, Jabez was clearly calm before he saw that Officer White had entered his home. Rather than make any attempt to de-escalate, White barked orders and immediately reached for his gun. When Jabez was safe behind a door, rather than holding the door closed, White chose to open it, claimed he feared for his life, and shot the young man multiple times. What we don’t see in the short clip the NYPD selected to release, but have learned from Jabez’s family, is that immediately following the shooting, officers demanded family members’ phones and threatened them into compliance. NYPD officers also asked invasive immigration-related questions in violation of NYPD protocol and local law and created barriers to them visiting Jabez in the hospital . Even in their most vulnerable moments, Jabez and his loved ones were treated as suspects, not a family seeking care. The fact that Mayor Mamdani was either unwilling or unable to get the NYPD to grant the Jabez’s family’s request to view the unedited footage with their support team prior to its public release calls into question the Mayor’s accountability to New Yorkers and understanding of his power over the NYPD. We demand that the Chakraborty family and their support team be allowed to view the full, unedited body camera footage and other any other video evidence collected by the NYPD, for the cuffs to be removed from Jabez while he recovers from multiple gunshot wounds, and for Queens District Attorney Katz not to seek charges against Jabez. Further, we call on the Mayor and NYPD to fire Officer White for needlessly choosing to shoot Jabez and to fire the other NYPD officers who violated the Chakrabortys’ rights by taking their phones by threat and asking immigration-related questions. Mayor Mamdani’s immediate response to this incident was a dangerous continuation of his predecessors' pattern of excusing and even applauding officers who harm New Yorkers. Days later, Mamdani’s follow-up statement expressed a vision for a mental health system in which officers do not respond to “such crises alone”: an apparent endorsement of NYPD co-response, a misguided approach that will continue to send police to respond to and further criminalize and kill New Yorkers who need medical or mental health care. Without careful planning in consultation with a range of stakeholders, including those directly impacted by police violence and their loved ones as well as advocates and mental health experts, and without state legislative changes, Mamdani’s Department of Community Safety (DCS) can only reduce NYPD interaction, not stop their involvement. As it stands, the DCS runs the risk of entrenching the NYPD as default responders and continuing to unnecessarily threaten and take New Yorkers’ lives. If the Mayor is serious about removing NYPD from mental health, as he campaigned for, he must stop defending police-led and co-response models, and instead invest in community-based, non-police crisis response and preventative and post-crisis care.
- ICE is Law Enforcement: JC Responds to Recent State Violence
We are all witnessing escalating state violence in Minneapolis and across the country. As stunned as we may feel, it’s not enough to watch in silence. The astounding organizing in Minneapolis and its growing national impact show us what’s possible when we unite, hold each other in grief, and, most importantly, organize toward the future we want, need, and deserve. At JC, we are processing the immense state violence in this first month of 2026: at least 8 killings carried out by federal immigration enforcement across the country as well as 3 NYPD shootings here at home that have taken two lives and left another hospitalized. In this context, we are preparing for the fight ahead. Geraldo Lunas Campos, Parody La, Heber Sanchez Domínguez, Victor Manuel Diaz, Luis Beltran Yanez-Cruz, Luis Gustavo Nunez Caceres, Renee Nicole Good, and Alex Pretti. These are the names of those killed by ICE + CBP so far this year. And the list of those killed does not begin to capture the countless others who have been brutalized, caged, and terrorized—both in detention and on the streets. It’s important to name that the violence we are witnessing from ICE, while horrifying and escalating at a terrifying pace, is not new. It is part of an unbroken history of state violence against people of color, immigrants, poor and working-class communities, and those who dare to dissent that far predates Trump. Equally important to state is that ICE, Customs and Border Protection (CBP), and other federal immigration agencies are law enforcement —full stop. Claims to the contrary are dangerous and misleading. Like all law enforcement institutions, ICE enforces the (often biased and unjust) law through force, cages, and violence. Like local police departments, ICE has a well-documented record of racial profiling and excessive force —targeting people based on appearance, accent, or ethnicity, and killing with impunity. Again and again, we see these agencies bend (and break ) the law to their will, protected and empowered by the highest levels of government. And just like local police, ICE relies on the same excuses to justify their violence. After ICEWatcher Alex Pretti was killed, Border Patrol agents claimed “he had a gun.” After ICE agent Jonathan Ross shot Renee Nicole Good , he said he “feared for his life.” We have heard this before. Minnesota officer Jeronimo Yanez killed Philando Castile after Philando calmly disclosed that he was legally carrying a firearm. NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera killed Allan Feliz because he claims he believed Allan’s vehicle was threatening officers’ lives. These are not coincidences—they are patterns. While we may see moments in which local and federal law enforcement appear to be at odds as state and city governments grapple with Trump’s fascist power grab, we must remember: ultimately, they serve the same function – to protect state power and elite interests, not human life. To create true community safety, we must intensify our fight to chip away at the scope and power of law enforcement. That includes the urgent demand to abolish ICE. JC stands in fierce solidarity with the resistance in Minneapolis and with our immigrant neighbors here in New York City. Let our grief and rage be a source of power and let our love for our communities move us to action: Use tools like 5calls.org to contact your representatives and demand that they vote against any increase in ICE funding . (The Senate will be voting this week.) Continue #ICEWatch and #CopWatch to deter, de-escalate, and document law enforcement violence. Join JC and our allies in HandsOfNYC to rally in Foley Square this Friday, January 30 , at 4pm as part of nationwide shut down called for by Minnesota organizers. We keep each other alive. We fight because we love.
- [Capital B] Delrawn Small’s Family Still Seeks Accountability 9 Years After NYPD Killing
Officer Wayne Isaacs was acquitted on murder and manslaughter charges in 2016. by Christina Carrega BROOKLYN, New York — In a neighborhood just miles from where his father was shot and killed by an off-duty police officer nine years ago, Zaiden Small sat on a couch, kicking and dangling his feet as he listened to stories about a man he never knew. He was a protector, a provider, and a man who had turned his life around. “I wish he would be right here. He’d just teleport right here,” the fourth grader said with an innocent grin as the room filled with laughter. On the night of the fatal shooting, Zaiden was just 4 months old, strapped into a car seat two lanes away. Saying Delrawn Small’s name in front of his three children is sometimes met with smiles as they share memories of the 37-year-old. Frustration then sets in about how the homicide case has dragged on for too long. Then a somber pause — but someone eventually breaks the silence with laughter. Two days after a long-promised New York Police Departmental trial was delayed again, the family still gathered in a rented space 3 miles away from the East New York shooting a week before this past Thanksgiving. Some traveled from as far as Georgia, while others commuted from upstate New York or the city’s neighboring boroughs to ensure no one forgets Small’s story. In the early hours of July 4, 2016, off-duty NYPD officer Wayne Isaacs shot and killed Small as he approached Isaacs’ car. The two men stopped at a red light after witnesses said Isaacs was driving erratically. Isaacs testified in his own defense at the November 2017 trial that he shot Small after he was punched in the face. Footage reviewed by prosecutors and investigators did not corroborate that claim. Despite Isaacs’ unfounded testimony to jurors, the criminal prosecution resulted in an acquittal on charges of second-degree murder and first-degree manslaughter, a lawsuit settled, and an unfulfilled promise of a departmental trial. Isaacs is still employed by the NYPD, and Small’s family said their loss has been pushed to the margins of the police reform debate. “For the last nine years, something significant has happened with this case around the holidays,” Small’s brother, Victor Dempsey, told Capital B. “Every year. We can go the whole year with normalcy and then the holidays, something drastic happens to remind you of it again.” The departmental trial for Isaacs was scheduled for this past November, but has been stalled indefinitely. Small’s killing not only became an early test of New York state’s efforts to prosecute civilian deaths involving law enforcement, but a test of a family’s resolve. “This is the last road,” said Dempsey, a community organizer with the NAACP Legal Defense Fund who has turned his grief into purpose. He was set to open a restaurant that was put on hold following his big brother’s death. Despite the frustration, Dempsey and other family members are still hopeful that they’re in the final round of a nearly decadelong fight for accountability. A year before Small was killed in 2016, then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo signed an executive order giving the state attorney general authority to investigate and press charges against officers accused of killing an individual found not to be armed with a weapon. The move followed ongoing criticism that local prosecutors were too closely aligned with police to hold officers accountable through their own investigation or grand jury proceedings — a legally secretive process — particularly after the 2014 death of Eric Garner at the hands of an NYPD officer in Staten Island. The delay of the departmental trial for Isaacs followed a recommendation by an NYPD administrative judge to the NYPD’s commissioner, Jessica Tisch, to dismiss the disciplinary charges against Isaacs, concluding he acted as a private citizen in the killing of Small. That conclusion conflicts with the city’s 2021 decision to settle a wrongful-death lawsuit with Zaquanna Albert, Small’s girlfriend, even after Isaacs was acquitted in criminal court, the family, advocates, and local elected officials said . The $125,000 settlement was far lower than comparable police‑involved wrongful-death settlements that year . The encounter was initially described by law enforcement as a road‑rage incident. It occurred at a stoplight between two Black men — one’s death left his family having to rely on one another for support without victim compensation funds , the other having law enforcement and taxpayer-funded resources for his defense. Since 2016, seven NYPD commissioners haven’t made a decision on Isaacs’ future employment with the department. In 2020, the department’s Civilian Complaint Review Board, an independent agency tasked with investigating complaints of misconduct made against NYPD employees, recommended firing Isaacs. Tisch was appointed in November 2024. She will remain in the role under new Mayor Zohran Mamdani, and she will retain the authority to decide whether Isaacs’ departmental trial will proceed. Capital B reached out to the NYPD for comment. A spokesperson said the “disciplinary process remains ongoing.” Isaacs, 47, earned more than $155,000 in 2025, which is a drop from his previous year’s earnings of $218,327, according to online records. Weeks prior to shooting Small, Isaacs was accused of using excessive force against a 27-year-old woman for a traffic violation. The June 27, 2016, incident was closed months later when the motorist allegedly did not cooperate with the CCRB’s investigation, according to online police misconduct records . “He was stolen from us” All Zaiden knows of his dad are photographs, videos, and stories of his protection — lessons he wishes he could learn firsthand, like how to drive when he’s old enough. Small provided structure within his immediate family that they didn’t appreciate until he was gone. “I got to experience him as a father more than my brother did,” said his now 23-year-old stepdaughter, who asked not to be named. “I wish I could get a father-figure for my brother.” Belly laughs over stories from the moments leading up to the day that changed their lives forever brought tears to some eyes. Loved ones wove in accounts of the challenges they have faced with law enforcement, the public, and themselves ever since. The laughter eventually gave way to grief, as Dempsey reminded them how much Small disliked driving — especially on a holiday marked by heightened concerns about impaired drivers. As fireworks lit the sky on July 4, 2016, Small was driving Albert’s sister’s car to bring Albert and her then-14-year-old daughter home, with newborn Zaiden strapped into a car seat in the back. Coming from Queens, Small drove along Atlantic Avenue. Isaacs was allegedly seen weaving his car between the three lanes of traffic. The two men later stopped at the same red light at Bradford Street. When Small stepped out of his car and approached Isaacs’ vehicle, three shots rang out, according to trial testimony. Isaacs was off duty when the shooting occurred. Even if he had been on duty, there wouldn’t be any police body camera footage because the NYPD didn’t complete the rollout of the devices until April 2017 . As a result, investigators relied solely on eyewitness statements, footage from nearby businesses and street cameras to reconstruct the events. Those eyewitnesses were among Small’s closest loved ones, who said they were questioned by investigators while planning his funeral and remain traumatized by the shooting. His then-teenage stepdaughter sat in the backseat and called 911, unaware the bullets came from an officer heading home after a shift at the 79th Precinct in Bedford-Stuyvesant. “When he was stolen from us, it was in a moment where he was identifying his path in life and making some adjustments for himself,” Dempsey, 39, told Capital B as Small’s toddler grandson sat nearby. Dempsey giggled at the memory of Small’s enjoyment in his Manhattan janitorial job and his eagerness to learn in school, embracing higher education after a late start in life. Shondell Small, 24, remembers her father as “one of a kind” — someone she wishes her son had known. “We didn’t want that … failure” As phone technology advanced over the past decade, everyday people gained the ability to record alleged misconduct in their communities — bringing visual proof to stories of police brutality that people of color had reported for decades but were often not believed, even when backed by statistics . The footage fueled public outrage and, in response, pushed some law enforcement agencies to adopt body camera policies aimed at increasing transparency and accountability following protests, criminal investigations, and lawsuits. In the case of Small’s death, his family said his case isn’t recognized like other higher-profile cases. Their tragedy, they said, has been overshadowed by bystander-recorded videos of on-duty police brutality that have made national news headlines. Small’s name rarely appears in lists about victims of police brutality. “I just felt like he didn’t get the recognition that he deserved, or even the family deserves,” Albert told Capital B. The 45-year-old mom, who works in health care, tugged at the scarf draped across her chest, steadying herself as she fought back tears while recalling Small’s death and the steady stream of headlines chronicling the loss of over 1,000 Black lives since, according to the Mapping Police Violence database that tracks the number of fatal police encounters since 2013. Less than 24 hours after Small was killed, a bystander in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, captured 37-year-old Alton Sterling being shot and killed by two police officers. Yet no federal or state charges were filed. The following day in St. Paul, Minnesota, 32-year-old Philando Castile , a licensed gun owner, was fatally shot during a traffic stop, his girlfriend broadcasting the shooting live on Facebook. The officer involved, Jeronimo Yanez, was acquitted of all state charges in 2017. It’s incidents like those that sparked change at least in Ramsey County, Minnesota, where its local prosecutor implemented a policy in 2021 declining to prosecute non-public safety traffic crimes such as a broken tail light in honor of Castile. The 2015 executive order in New York came in response to the disproportionate number of people of color, particularly Black individuals, killed by law enforcement each year. It also sought to address the imbalance in criminal convictions and civil protections, where qualified immunity often shielded officers from financial accountability. Isaacs’ acquittal raised questions about the executive order’s effectiveness in securing accountability on the state level. The Brooklyn district attorney’s office, which would have prosecuted Small’s case, has since indicted current and former law enforcement officers in the borough on charges beyond homicide, including assault , bribery , perjury , and official misconduct . Without second-guessing the criminal case, Dempsey said he believes pursuing a federal investigation or filing a federal civil lawsuit — during the first Trump administration or now — is a lost cause. “We didn’t want that to be a failure,” he said. Pattern and practice investigations reserved to investigate police departments with allegations of misconduct were frozen until Joe Biden was president. By that point, having the NYPD’s Civilian Complaint Review Board’s recommendation to fire Isaacs in 2020 and a departmental hearing pending, the family gambled on that. “And now Trump is back in office — again,” Dempsey said. “The federal route is just not an option for us at this time.” But for Albert, she awaits that “happy” feeling she once had when the television cameras went away after the verdict. She felt relief not having to answer questions from strangers, clients, and co-workers after returning to work from maternity leave. “People just want to know … and have their opinions,” Albert said with a shrug. “I felt I had to explain all those things, when the trial started, people were like ‘Oh, I’ve seen this,’ but my director [supervisor at work] put a pause to that.” She said her focus has always been — and will remain — on her family’s well-being as they navigate grief, growing increasingly weary of the next legal hurdle that is sure to make headlines. “Time does not heal,” Albert said. Her composure broke after two hours of conversation as tears welled in her eyes. “Raising a child who lost their father is the hardest thing — explaining it, trying to fill that void, being careful.” She wiped her eyes with her scarf and paused. “Delrawn — he was a real one,” she said. Dempsey, Shondell Small, and Kyree Small nodded and hummed in agreement, with a “yup” from Shondell in the background. “I will not find anyone like that,” Albert said. Still, the Small family clings to hope. They know Rosemarie Maldonado, the NYPD disciplinary judge who oversaw the 2019 departmental trial and recommended firing Daniel Pantaleo — the officer never criminally charged in Eric Garner’s 2014 death — is assigned to Isaacs’ hearing. “I just remember saying ‘Damn, they killed another Black man,’ never knowing that it would come to our footsteps,” Dempsey admitted. “But when it did … I remember going online saying ‘This can happen to you,’ and ‘I don’t hate police, I hate bad cops.’” It took six years before an NYPD commissioner moved to fire Pantaleo . For Dempsey, the emotional preparation has taken a deeper toll than any strategic planning for justice. “I felt like my brother was murdered twice with the acquittal,” Dempsey said. “I don’t know how I would do it a third time — having to tell my family if the commissioner doesn’t grant a hearing — and not feel like I let them down.”
- [City & State] Opinion: A new low for the NYPD
The cop who killed Delrawn Small now claims he wasn’t acting as a cop to avoid discipline. By Jumaane Williams and Julia Salazar When is a cop not a cop? Whenever it’s convenient, it turns out. We both vividly remember the sweltering day in July 2016 when an NYPD officer killed Delrawn Small, unarmed Black father. One of us was interning at a community organization; the other was already years into fighting the effects of abusive police violence on the streets as an activist and inside City Hall as a New York City Council member – but we both watched the same horrifying video of Officer Wayne Isaacs gunning down Delrawn Small within seconds, all while his baby, teenage stepdaughter and girlfriend looked on. We couldn’t have known that nearly a decade later, we would still be fighting for a discipline trial to begin, while the NYPD tries to claim Officer Isaacs was not acting as a police officer when he took Delrawn’s life. For me, Julia, standing with Delrawn’s family has meant witnessing a decade of their trauma, struggle and courage. I sat with the Small family through Isaacs’ entire murder trial in 2017. I watched Delrawn’s son and nephew grow up in the shadow of rallies, hearings and endless courtrooms. I’ve kept every notebook from those years, but I don’t need to reread a single page to recall how Isaacs’ defense argued he was acting in his capacity as an officer and using his training. For me, Jumaane, Delrawn’s case was – and still is – a jarring confirmation of what I had long observed: how casually and callously the NYPD will distort, delay and deny the truth. A decade of delay before even getting to a discipline trial is beyond unacceptable – and now even that is in question. Also in question – at least according to the NYPD – is whether Isaacs was a police officer when he shot Delrawn. According to Isaacs and his attorneys, when he was defending himself against potential criminal charges, he was an officer. But now, when he faces consequences as an officer, Isaacs and his legal team are arguing he was merely a private citizen when he killed a man in the street. When the NYPD finally scheduled Isaacs’ long-overdue discipline trial for this past November, we allowed ourselves a measure of cautious optimism. But at the eleventh hour, Isaacs and his lawyers filed a motion to dismiss the charges and derailed it. The audacity of their argument cannot go unchallenged. For years, Isaacs and his attorneys insisted he was acting “under color of law” – meaning, as an officer – to defend him in the criminal case and secure indemnification in the civil case, an argument that forced the city to pay out the settlement with taxpayer dollars. Now, in a ridiculous pivot, they claim Isaacs was not acting as an officer, in an attempt to shut down the discipline process. Even more inexplicably, NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado bought into this hypocrisy and recommended that Isaacs’ charges be dismissed – even though the NYPD clearly believed Isaacs was acting as an officer when it served the fireable misconduct charges to him over four years ago. But we, along with 31 of our fellow elected officials , know exactly what her recommendation represents: another clear example of how the NYPD’s discipline process fails New Yorkers and damages public safety. Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch must end this pattern by upholding the charges and ensuring the discipline trial moves forward without further delay. Delrawn’s life mattered. Over the near-decade without him, his family has been forced to relive their trauma through every legal maneuver and institutional failure. Delrawn’s son, who was only four months old when he witnessed his father’s murder, is now in 4th grade – and still, not even the bare minimum of accountability has been served. Delrawn deserved better. His family deserves better, and New Yorkers deserve better. Tisch now has the opportunity, and the obligation, to do better. What happens in Delrawn Small’s case will reverberate beyond one officer or one family. For decades, we have watched a familiar and devastating pattern repeat itself: when an NYPD officer kills a New Yorker, the department delays, deflects and protects its own. Every case without consequences makes another police shooting more likely. Every day that Officer Wayne Isaacs remains employed without facing discipline is proof that the NYPD operates above the law, accountable only to itself – not to the New Yorkers it allegedly “serves and protects.” This is a defining moment for Delrawn Small’s case and a defining test for Tisch. At the start of a new mayoral administration and a new era for New York City, we are calling for change. Denying accountability in the face of clear wrongdoing undermines the ongoing work we should all be dedicated to: the co-production of public safety in and with communities. Tisch must stop denying grieving families justice to protect abusive cops. She must take this basic step towards accountability for Isaacs by upholding the charges and allowing the discipline trial to move forward. Officer Isaacs was a cop the day that he shot Delrawn Small. But he shouldn’t continue to be one – and a trial will show it.
- Mayor Adams’ Promotion of Pat Smith Sabotages Oversight and Guarantees More Harm
Justice Committee blasts the last-minute appointment In response to Mayor Eric Adams appointment of Pat Smith as interim chair of the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB), Justice Committee Deputy Director Yul-san Liem (she/her) issued the following statement: “Mayor Adams’ decision to quietly elevate Pat Smith – a current CCRB board member who has persistently undermined accountability and weakened the board’s authority – is a greenlight for unchecked NYPD abuse. Smith has long positioned himself as an adversary of oversight. He has repeatedly discouraged New Yorkers from filing complaints, even when they’ve faced serious NYPD abuses, reinforcing a system that is structured to shield abusive officers and making the already biased process even more hostile to New Yorkers who have experienced police misconduct. Even more alarming is Smith’s pattern of ignoring evidence, disregarding investigators’ findings, and tossing out CCRB cases at extraordinarily high rates. This includes voting not to substantiate charges against Officers Salvatore Alongi and Matthew Cianfrocco for killing Win Rozario, shortly after he attempted to block Win’s family’s supporters from giving public comment at a board meeting. Putting Smith in charge of the over-burdened and under-resourced agency guarantees more harm to the communities most targeted by NYPD and even less accountability for the abuses they endure. New Yorkers deserve a leader of the CCRB who is committed to truth, transparency, and justice. Mayor-Elect Mamdani must replace Pat Smith as Interim CCRB Board Chair as soon as he takes office.”




![[Capital B] Delrawn Small’s Family Still Seeks Accountability 9 Years After NYPD Killing](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/f8a96d_f552995bebe646039b7d6446e1589a07~mv2.webp/v1/fit/w_176,h_124,q_80,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,blur_3,enc_auto/f8a96d_f552995bebe646039b7d6446e1589a07~mv2.webp)
![[City & State] Opinion: A new low for the NYPD](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/f8a96d_c15cac7c72cf4a5f8e601a0ff18adfc2~mv2.jpg/v1/fit/w_176,h_124,q_80,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,blur_3,enc_auto/f8a96d_c15cac7c72cf4a5f8e601a0ff18adfc2~mv2.jpg)
