top of page

Search Results

Search this site

419 results found with an empty search

  • Justice Committee Statement on Delivery of 33,000 Signed Petitions to the DOJ for Ramarley Graham

    The Justice Committee is honored to stand by Constance Malcolm and Franclot Graham, Ramarley Graham’s parents, as they continue their struggle for justice and accountability for the NYPD killing of their son. Today we supported Ramarley’s family as they delivered over 33,000 signed petitions demanding the Department of Justice (DOJ) launch a full investigation into this case.  These signatures represent an outpouring of sentiment from New Yorkers and others across the country that the DOJ must step up and do its job. It has been over two years since Ramarley was killed by NYPD Officer Richard Haste in his own home and over a year since the DOJ said it was reviewing the case.  There is still no indication that an investigation is underway.  Like so many other families who have lost loved ones to police brutality, Ramarley’s family has been given no information about what’s going on. Today we sent a clear message. Attorney General Eric Holder and U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara have been put on notice: Ramarley’s family should have to wait no longer for justice and accountability. The DOJ must thoroughly investigate and convene a grand jury to indict Richard Haste on federal civil rights charges.  This will not only be a step toward justice for Ramarley's family, it will send a message that the lives of Black and brown youth matter and that police brutality will not be tolerated any longer.  We also call on U.S. Attorney Preet Bharara to schedule a meeting with Ramarley’s parents no later that Sept. 19, 2014. Click here to sign petition Listen to the audio of the press conference here. ###

  • Gov. of Missouri calls in state law enforcement after protestors clash with Ferguson

    Pix 11 NEW YORK (PIX11) – Body armor. Tear gas. Rubber bullets. This is not Iraq, but these scenes prompted Missouri’s governor to call the town of Ferguson a war zone following demonstrator’s Wednesday night clash with police. It was not a flattering scene, and when the dust settled, the local police department found itself no longer in charge of security. Read More

  • [CNN] "Are Police Getting Away with Murder?" Says Iris Baez, mother of Anthony Baez

    Although details are still emerging in this most recent tragedy, we know an officer repeatedly shot and killed an unarmed 18-year-old black man, Michael Brown, in a St. Louis suburb last weekend -- less than two days before he was scheduled to attend college. Last month, Eric Garner, another unarmed black man, died from an illegal police chokehold during an encounter on Staten Island, New York. Nearly 20 years ago, my son Anthony Baez also died in an illegal police chokehold. Anthony was playing football in the street with his brother when their ball accidentally hit a police car. Instead of addressing real public safety issues, a New York police officer chose to harass my sons brutally. These cases and many more reveal our country's systemic criminalization and devaluing of black and brown lives. The list is long. Twelve years after Anthony was killed, New York police officers fired at an unarmed Sean Bell 50 times and killed him the night before his wedding. The detectives who were responsible were acquitted of criminal charges. Just three years later, a BART police officer in Oakland, California,shot and killed 22-year-old Oscar Grant while he was facedown on a subway platform, posing no threat. It inspired a movie, "Fruitville Station." The transit police officer who shot him was convicted of a lesser charge of involuntary manslaughter and spent 11 months in prison. Two years ago, unarmed National Guardsman Noel Polanco was fatally shot by a New York police detective during a highway traffic stop. The detective was not indicted. Also two years ago, unarmed 18-year-old Ramarley Graham was shot and killed by a New York police officer who unlawfully entered his home and killed him in front of his grandmother and 6-year-old brother. A judge threw out the first indictment against Officer Richard Haste, who fatally shot Graham, and a second grand jury failed to re-indict him. Just this January, an off-duty Houston police officer shot and killed 26-year-old Jordan Baker, a father and college student who worked part time, at a strip mall. The investigation is still pending. These are just some of the dozens of police killings of unarmed Americans by law enforcement over the last decades. These tragedies and injustices happen year after year, and people of color -- primarily black and Latino -- are usually the victims. Sadly, our communities in New York and elsewhere are almost conditioned to expect these incidents -- the loss of our children, siblings and spouses to excessive violence by those whose job it is to protect us. New York Police Commissioner Bill Bratton's recent commentdismissing that race was a factor in Garner's death is a slap in the face to those of us who've lost our children, and it is part of the problem that allows such unjust killings to continue. In addition to the pain families experience from losing their loved ones, we are also forced to endure additional injustices, when again and again government and the criminal justice system fail to hold officers accountable, and instead the victims are criminalized. Similar to the response in Garner's case, the New York Police Department attempted to blame my son for his death by saying that he and his brother resisted arrest. But what were they under arrest for? Playing football in the street? Even if we hypothetically assumed the officers' allegations were true -- although they were not and a federal court found the officer guilty -- how does that justify killing someone? With Bratton as police commissioner then and today, we see a similar response. In many of these unjust killings, New York police detailed victims' past involvement with the criminal justice system to the media, as if that justified their lives being taken by the police. We've seen it with Garner, and we saw it with Anthony Rosario, Hilton Vega, Patrick Dorismond and many others. Also, district attorneys fail to convene a grand jury or secure a conviction. We must question the closeness of district attorneys to police departments, given their interdependence. In only a handful of these cases, including my son's, the federal government stepped in to provide some limited accountability. In Michael Brown's killing, the FBI will conduct a parallel investigation to one already under way by the St. Louis County, Missouri, police. Like it did with my son, the FBI review will focus on possible civil rights violations in his killing. That is the only way my son got justice -- when the federal government found the police officer who killed my son violated his civil rights. Where is the justice for families like those of Ramarley Graham? It's been two years since his death and a year since the Justice Department said it was reviewing the case but still nothing. The family doesn't even know whether the officer responsible for killing him in cold blood has been disciplined or still walks around with a gun and shield. Those with a badge who unjustly kill and brutalize should be stripped of their badge, their gun, their job and their pension because they have violated the public trust. A systemic lack of accountability and inadequate discipline allows these incidents to continue to happen. And now, in the wake of Garner's death, Bratton and the New York Police Department are responding in the same way they always have -- pledges of more training. It's not training that will prevent this from happening again. We need accountability for all officers involved that sends a message that this type of brutality is unacceptable and the lives of people of color are equally valued. Systemic cultural and substantive policy changes in police departments -- particularly in New York -- are needed to ensure black and brown communities are not targeted with overly aggressive, discriminatory "broken windows policing" and "stop and frisk" policies that promote brutality and violence. Officers should work to understand the communities they work in, not criminalize them. Police-community relations can only start to improve when individual officers who abuse civilians' rights are held accountable with a zero-tolerance policy for police brutality. Anything less is just rhetoric, and I fear that these unjust deaths will continue with more families and communities suffering the same pain. View Original Piece Editor's note: Iris Baez is a member of the Justice Committee in New York, a longtime activist for accountability and justice in police brutality cases, and the mother of Anthony Baez, who was killed by a New York Police Department officer's use of a chokehold in 1994.

  • [El Diario] “Lo único que nos va a parar es un balazo”

    Van casi dos décadas desde que los hijos de Iris Báez y Margarita Rosario murieron en manos de oficiales del NYPD. El hijo de Iris, Anthony Báez, falleció en diciembre de 1984 cuando un policía lo sometió a una llave de estrangulamiento, pensando que pertenecía a una pandilla. El hijo de Margarita, Anthony Rosario murió sólo un mes después, cuando oficiales dispararon 22 tiros contra él, alegando defensa personal. Sin embargo, testigos han dicho que Rosario no tenía armas al momento del tiroteo y que, además, estaba contra el piso por petición de los policías. Ninguno de los involucrados ha pagado cárcel por homicidio. Esto no significa que estas madres de hierro, como las ha llamado El Diario, hayan dejado de luchar. ¿Han visto cambios en el Departamento de Policía desde hace veinte años hasta el día de hoy? Margarita: Hemos presenciado la visibilización de nuestros casos dentro de la sociedad y del sistema judicial. Antes de que las madres afectadas nos juntáramos, a través del Comité de Justicia y otras organizaciones, teníamos que pelear solas y pasar el dolor solas.Teníamos que ir a las cortes sin compañía, con un cuerpo de policías esperándonos para agredirnos, para intimidarnos. ¿Qué información dejaron de darles las autoridades sobre sus casos? Iris: Las dos tuvimos que contratar médicos forenses diferentes al oficial, porque nos daban respuestas que no tenían sentido. A mí me dijeron que mi hijo murió por asma cuando ni siquiera sufría de esa enfermedad. También lo quisieron tildar de delincuente. Mi hijo ayudaba a pequeños a darle sentido a sus vidas a través de campamentos de verano. Tengo que agregar, ninguno de los policías cumplieron penas por homicidio. ¿Cómo han cambiado desde hace dos décadas? ¿Qué tipo de mujeres eran ustedes antes de la muerte de sus hijos? Iris: Con esto te lo digo, yo sólo iba de la Iglesia a mi casa, de mi casa al trabajo y para atrás. Desde que pasó lo de mi hijo, nada me para, me hago escuchar. Lo único que nos va a parar es un balazo, ¿no, Margarita? Margarita: Yo sí estaba mucho más interesada en los casos de discriminación por parte de las autoridades. Recuerdo que, desde pequeña, veía los discursos de Martin Luther King y me sentía inspirada. Cuando murió mi hijo, los primeros días, no podía caminar ni comer ni salir a la calle. Era un dolor terrible. Sin embargo, saqué coraje de aquellos discursos de King y empecé a protestar, a salir a la calle con pancartas, a buscar ayuda. Cuando vi a mi hijo en el ataúd, le prometí que iba a luchar por su causa. ¿Qué le recomiendan a los jóvenes que se ven involucrados con la Policía? Iris: Antes de darle consejos a los hijos, le doy consejos a los padres: tienen que conocer sus derechos, y cuando tengan un problema parecido al nuestro, deben acudir a un abogado. No pueden detenerse por miedo, es necesario tomar acciones. A los jóvenes: dejarse llevar, no poner problemas. Los resultados pueden ser peores si uno busca defenderse. ¿Creen que habrá un antes y un después en las prácticas de la Policía debido al caso de Garner? Margarita: Sí, sobre todo porque existe un video. En nuestros tiempos, no habían pruebas así de fehacientes por Daniella Sánchez El Diario View Original Piece

  • [Huffington Post] Ramarley Graham Killed by the NYPD Over Two Years Ago, and Nothing Has Happened

    It’s been two and a half years since NYPD officers barged into the Bronx home of Ramarley Graham without a warrant, fatally shooting the unarmed teen in front of his grandmother and 6-year-old brother. It’s been a little over two years since officers cheered fellow cop Richard Haste after he pleaded not guilty to manslaughter charges for killing Graham, as Graham’s parents sobbed. It’s been a little over a year since a judge tossed out the indictment against Haste because of a technicality, and it's been exactly one year since another grand jurydeclined to indict Haste. Friday also marks the one-year anniversary of when the Department of Justiceannounced it would investigate Graham’s death. The DOJ has remained silent on the investigation since then, and declined to comment on its status for this story. And it marks another year that Graham’s mother, Constance Malcolm, says her family has gone without justice. “Richard Haste -- I just want to see him pay the price for what he did to my child,” Malcolm says while sitting by her son’s grave in a video posted to YouTube on Thursday by the Justice Committee, a police reform advocacy group. “Richard Haste is free, working, collecting a paycheck, while I’m here waiting to see if the Department of Justice is going to take the case." “We are fed up and we are sick and we are tired," Malcolm says. "There are too many mothers out there crying for justice that didn’t get justice.” She mentions a petition at Color of Change, which already has over 32,000 signatures, that calls on the Justice Department to prosecute Haste. Malcolm, who's also filed a civil suit against the city, plans to deliver the petition to the Justice Department in person on Aug. 20 at noon. She and five other mothers whose sons were killed by police met with NYPD Inspector General Philip Eure on Wednesday. They asked Eure to investigate the department’s use of force, especially in incidences leading to death. Malcolm told HuffPost outside the meeting that the past few weeks have been particularly trying for her, as the death of Eric Garner brought back a flood of memories from when her son was killed. Garner died three weeks ago after NYPD officer Daniel Pantaleo put him into a chokehold during an arrest on Staten Island for selling untaxed cigarettes. The city medical examiner has ruled Garner’s death a homicide. Malcolm said she “broke down” while watching the viral video of the chokehold that ended Garner’s life. “I sat there and watched that man cry ‘I can’t breathe! I can’t breathe!’ And that officer had a chokehold on him, sticking his head in the concrete without any remorse! What kind of animal could do that?” she said. She also expressed anger at statements made by the city’s police unions this week. Pat Lynch, the president of the Patrolmen’s Benevolent Association, defended the cops involved in Garner’s death at a press conference Wednesday. He denied that the officers used a chokehold, and said the use of force was necessary. He also referred to the medical examiner’s report, which ruled Garner’s death a homicide, as “political” and a “press release.” “[Lynch] tells us to give police the benefit of the doubt,” Malcolm said. “The cops don’t give us the benefit of the doubt! Automatically we are criminal. My son was in his home! They broke into his home and killed him! They didn’t give him the benefit of the doubt!” Cops kicked in the door to Graham's apartment on Feb. 2, 2012, and confronted him in a bathroom. Haste -- who later said he heard on a police radio that Graham was armed -- shot Graham once in the chest. No weapon was found, only a small bag of marijuana. Malcolm worries about her younger son, Chinnor Campbell, who witnessed his older half-brother get killed. She said the boy, now 9, watched the video of Garner’s death. “He sees it and he goes, ‘Mommy, there they go again. They kill somebody. When are they going to stop? They killed Ramarley for no reason,’” Malcolm said, choking back tears. “I have to sit there and explain it to him. ‘It’s going to be OK, it’s going to be OK.’ But in the back of my head, I don’t think it’s going to be OK, because it keeps happening." by Christopher Mathias Huffington Post View Original Piece

  • [MSNBC] A dark shadow on Bill de Blasio’s NYPD

    The scene was eerily reminiscent of New York City’s bad old days, when the streets were boiling over with racial strife, tension and violence. A black man is surrounded by a group of NYPD officers. One throws an arm around the black man’s neck from behind. The man is wrestled to the ground. His shouts of “I can’t breathe” are ignored. Then, minutes later, he is dead. The apparent chokehold death of Eric Garner, who was accused of selling loose, untaxed cigarettes on a Staten Island sidewalk just moments before being accosted by police last month, has reignited a decades-old debate over the NYPD’s so-called “Broken Windows” policing, in which officers aggressively attack minor offenses with the aim of suppressing other crimes. New York’s Democratic Mayor Bill de Blasio was elected on a campaign that rejected controversial police tactics like stop and frisk, an outgrowth of Broken Windows policing that flourished under the previous administration. The tactic disproportionately targeted young black and Latino men for random stops and searches. De Blasio’s commitment to undoing stop and frisk helped to solidify his support among black and brown voters – many felt he offered hope of a paradigm shift in the way the city’s poorer communities would be policed. They all but carried him into City Hall on their shoulders. In the short time since his inauguration, though, the mayor has been an ardent defender of Broken Windows and his police commissioner Bill Bratton. In the early 1990s, on the tail end of the crack-era, Bratton served as police commissioner under then-mayor Rudy Giuliani. He helped to shape the department’s robust push into communities of color via Broken Windows. Supporters credit the crackdown with driving down crime in the city, though the connection remains foggy at best, since crime has gone down across the country during the same time period in cities that did not employ similar tactics. But in light of Garner’s death — which began with the paltry offense of selling 50-cent cigarettes on a city street — and all of the controversy kicked up around it, questions have arisen as to how this administration’s policing of communities of color will differ from those that came before it. “The mayor has made no bones [about] where he is coming from and where his values are in terms of policing. He has an African-American son. He knows what the challenges are for an African-American and a mixed family. He campaigned like he gets it,” said Donna Lieberman, executive director of the New York Civil Liberties Union. “But I think that this issue of Broken Windows policing is something that is a serious problem and we have yet to hear from the mayor that he sees, that he believes, that it carries with it enormous danger and a lack of benefit.” Lieberman called the administration’s continued practice of Broken Windows policing as “continuing the distrust and the tale of two cities that was the narrative of the prior administration.” Last week, the city’s medical examiner ruled Garner’s death a homicide. The officer who appeared to place Garner in a chokehold shortly before his death has since been stripped of his badge and gun. Chokehold maneuvers have been banned by the NYPD since 1993. The Staten Island District Attorney’s Office has said prosecutors are still reviewing evidence in the case. Had Garner not been killed, he likely would have landed on the city’s massive roll of petty violators, the vast majority of whom are black and Hispanic. A recent report by the New York Civil Liberties Union compiled more than a decade’s worth of police data , and it illustrates a stark disparity in exactly who the police have targeted for minor infractions. According to the NYCLU report and an analysis by the New York Daily News, 81% of the 7.3 million people slapped with low-level summonses between 2001 and 2013 were black and Hispanic. The data includes summonses spanning the whole of Michael Bloomberg’s mayoral term, a period when New York City ramped up an aggressive police campaign in poor, mostly minority communities. Critics of Broken Windows say that countless millions of dollars have been spent on targeting minority and low-income neighborhoods for petty crimes — even while crime by many measures is at an all-time low. Garner’s death, which was captured by a witness on cellphone video, and a slew of other alleged police abuses in recent weeks have put de Blasio and Bratton under growing scrutiny. De Blasio has defended Broken Windows, saying that unlike random stops, those stopped for minor infractions are suspected of breaking the law. Yul-san Liem, co-director of the Justice Committee, said the mayor’s rhetoric and what’s actually happening on the ground differ broadly. “The issue is that this kind of policing is not being applied consistently across the board, that the orientation of the department is to go into specific communities and low income communities of color,” Liem said. “White folk from affluent neighborhoods are not getting stopped and beaten up for jay walking. There’s something disjointed about what the mayor says and what is actually happening.” Liem said that, while stop and frisk has decreased, recent data suggests that police stops for summonses and misdemeanors are having a similar and disparate impact on minority residents. Over the last decade, as murder and other major crimes including aggravated assault, rape and robbery have all dropped significantly, summonses for petty crimes and misdemeanor arrests including marijuana possession, traffic infractions and noncriminal offenses are way up. The upswing has largely been driven by people caught in possession of a small amount of marijuana, who disproportionately happen to be young men of color. “This kind of policing, as we’ve seen with the Eric Garner case and the many cases of brutality that have surfaced, this kind of policy can have brutal and fatal consequences,” she said. “The mayor would be keeping with his campaign platform if he were to turn away from it.” Repeated requests for comment from the mayor’s spokesmen about the issue were not returned by Thursday afternoon. Per the NYCLU/Daily News reporting around the racial implications behind the issuance of summonses, the number of summonses have skyrocketed since the implementation of Broken Windows policing in the early 1990s. In 1993 there were 160,000 issued compared to a peak of 648,638 in 2005. The number fell to 431,217 last year and continues to trickle downward. But according to the Daily News, writing out summonses for low-level violations make up the majority of police activity, even more than felony and misdemeanor arrests combined. Last week, the NYCLU sent a letter to Bratton, the chairman of the New York City Civilian Complaint Board, and the city’s Inspector General calling for reforms in the police department. The letter states that beyond the circumstances of Eric Garner’s death, the incident raises a number of other critical issues, including the use of force by police in enforcement of low-level offenses, use of force training within the department, and the NYPD’s lack of responsiveness to substantiated complaints of misconduct. The NYCLU mined the NYPD’s comprehensive stop-and-frisk database to cobble together a picture of the number and frequency of stops that escalated into use of force by police. During a 10-year span between 2003 and 2013, police officers self-reported 1,381,843 acts of force in 4,984,393 stops. Analysis of stop and frisk has indicated just how ineffective the tactic has been. According to a report by the State Attorney General’s Office, just 1.5% of all stop-and-frisk arrests resulted in a jail or prison sentence. Just one in 50 stop-and-frisk arrests, 0.1%, led to a conviction for a violent crime or possession of a weapon. Close to half of all stop-and-frisk arrests did not result in a conviction. “This extraordinary number of acts of force reported by officers themselves is particularly alarming when one considers that nearly 90% of stops during this period were of innocent people,” the NYCLU’s letter, stated. Glenn E. Martin, founder of JustLeadershipUSA, an advocacy group that aims to reduce the prison population, said the aggressive policing of poor communities of color works hand in hand with the prison industrial complex and that it fuels the cycle of poverty and incarceration. “That the pattern continues to persist and materialize in ostensibly benign tactics of policing in New York City underscores this reality as more rule than aberration,” Martin said. “As evidenced by the recent reform and consequent maintenance of stop and frisk, the mayor’s declaration to improve the NYPD’s Broken Windows tactics will only allow the policy to become more deeply entrenched and intractable.” He said the lopsided application of “quality-of-life” offenses in communities of color allows mostly harmless individual behaviors to justify collective suspicion and surveillance. “When a community’s quality of life is compromised the last thing that community needs is heightened police aggression and enforcement mechanisms, inevitably capturing and trapping even more folks in the cycles of incarceration and poverty that give rise to those offenses in the first place,” he said. Studies show, particularly with young people, that involvement with police on any level increases the likelihood that you’ll end up in the criminal justice system. Those concerns are obvious, but perhaps particularly problematic in New York City. A recent report by the Justice Department found rampant and systemic abuses at Rikers Island. The DOJ’s inquiry cited a “culture of violence” particularly aimed at teenage inmates at the jail, the country’s second largest. “The state should be acting in cooperation with communities to repair broken windows and improve quality of life instead of criminalizing the people who survive the persistence of both,” Martin said. Despite the latest controversy and calls for the NYPD to reevaluate its use-of-force policy and more broadly its Broken Windows style of policing, some long-time community activists say the relationship between the police and the community under the de Blasio administration is a far-cry from that of previous administrations. Tony Herbert, a Brooklyn-based community activist, said the department has extended its hand to community groups in ways administrations haven’t in the past. Anti-violence activists have been invited to speak before police roll-calls. The NYPD’s community affairs officers have been more visible and responsive. There have been several community events sponsored by the department in which residents have been invited and there seems to be greater access to police commanders. “There are a lot of aggressive police officers out there and a number of them need to be retrained as it relates to community interaction,” Herbert, head of the Brooklyn East chapter of the Rev. Al Sharpton’s National Action Network. “Some are just totally ignorant to the fact that a little bit of compassion goes a long way. But there are also a lot of great cops out here.” Herbert said that the quality-of-life issues the department has cracked down on, including public drinking and public urination, for instance, are real issues that led residents to complain to the police. “People are complaining about certain things but sometimes people have to be careful what they ask for,” Herbert said. “Because when they start cracking down the good can get caught up with the bad.” by Trymaine Lee MSNBC View Original Piece

  • [Daily News] Families angry over police brutality meet with NYPD Inspector General

    New Yorkers fed up with police brutality and still mourning the deaths of their loved ones at the hands of cops met with the NYPD Inspector General Wednesday to say “enough!” “There’s no accountability for an officer who breaks the law, and they keep breaking the law over and over every day,” said Constance Malcolm of the Bronx. Malcolm’s unarmed 18-year-old son, Ramarley Graham, was shot to death inside her Bronx home in 2012 by NYPD Officer Richard Haste. The cop was indicted for killing Graham, but the case was tossed by a Bronx Supreme Court judge on a technicality. “We have to fight for justice. That’s why we’re here today,” Malcolm said. The 2 1/2-hour meeting with Eure was organized by the Justice Committee, a police watchdog organization. The group told Eure there is a pattern of primarily black and Latinos New Yorkers being “unjustly” killed by NYPD cops and called for an investigation into the department’s use of deadly force. “The city consistently pays out settlements to resolve civil suits around these cases and the toll these deaths take on families and communities is incredibly high,” the group said in a statement. Eric Garner died when a cop used a chokehold while trying to arrest him July 17. “In spite of this, neither the NYPD nor any mayoral administration has taken meaningful steps to address the root causes of the repeated killings. The officers responsible are almost never held accountable by the criminal justice system or the NYPD.” NYPD brass declined to comment about the meeting. Margarita Rosario — whose son, Anthony, 18, and nephew, Hilton Vega, 21, were killed in 1995 when two NYPD detectives fired a barrage of 28 bullets inside a Bronx apartment — said the meeting “went really well.” “We were able to speak individually about our stories,” said Rosario, who shared a $1.1 million settlement in 2009 with Vega’s family. “We made a lot of recommendations, so hopefully those recommendations will be taken seriously,” Rosario said. The family members who met with Eure represented 10 loved ones who died because of alleged police brutality or in questionable cop shootings dating back 20 years. Iris Baez of the Bronx — whose 29-year-old son, Anthony, was killed in 1994 when a cop put him in a chokehold — said Eure promised to examine all of their cases. “Everyone told him what they wanted and how they didn’t get justice,” Baez said. “We’ll have to see what (Commissioner Bill) Bratton does with his (Eure’s) recommendations and how the police department is going to change.” By Chelsia Rose Marcius & Bill Hutchinson New York Daily News View Original Piece

  • Justice Committee Statement on the Families' Meeting with the NYPD Inspector General

    Last night family members who have lost loved ones to the NYPD over the last twenty years had an important and substantive meeting with the new Inspector General, Philip Eure.  During the meeting, these families, all of whom are Black or Latino, described the ways in which the officers who killed their relatives broke protocol and/or the law, the problematic departmental investigations that followed, and the lack of accountability and discipline of those responsible for the killings. We and the families we work with feel strongly that the IG should investigate the NYPD's use of excessive and deadly force and its disciplinary procedures - or lack there of - in these cases.  The IG told us his office is currently assessing priorities and he could not say definitively whether such a review would be conducted at this time.  However, he did say his office is looking into some excessive force issues.  The families felt the meeting was productive and hope to continue a open dialogue with the IG's office moving forward.  It is our strong hope that the IG will prioritize an investigation into NYPD killings, as we believe a report on findings from it would shed light on why the NYPD continues to unjustly kill Black and Latino New Yorkers, as well as the dire need for real systemic change in the Department. ###

  • [DNAinfo] Relatives of Those Killed by Police Ask NYPD Watchdog to Probe Use of Force

    When she heard about the confrontation with police that left Staten Island manEric Garner dead,Constance Malcolm, mother of Ramarley Graham, the unarmed Bronx teen fatally shot in his own home by NYPD Officer Richard Haste in 2012, says she couldn't watch the viral video of the incident. That changed Wednesday when the video of Officer Daniel Pantaleo dragging Garner to the ground in what appears to be a chokehold was shown at a meeting of clergy, labor leaders and community activists at SEIU 1199 headquarters. "I broke down. I never watched that video before today and to see what really happened is horrible," said Malcolm. "It brings a lot of memories back for me." Malcolm is one of several people whose family members died after confrontations with police who met with the NYPD's new inspector general to ask for an investigation into the use of deadly force. Among them were Iris Baez, the mother of 29-year-old Anthony Baez, who died when police put him in a chokehold in 1994 after a football he was throwing around with friends on Thanksgiving Day hit a police cruiser. The group also included Valerie Bell, the mother of Sean Bell, who died on his wedding day in 2006 after police fired 50 shots at his car as he and his friends left a bachelor party. "When these killings happen all it does is open old wounds that have only been patched up," said Bell's fiancee Nicole Paultre Bell, who is currently raising two daughters she had with Bell. "We need accountability. Accountability hasn't changed. With each family that suffers we are only giving permission for these things to violate our community." The relatives were set to meet with Inspector General Philip Eure, who formerly served as the executive director of the District of Columbia’s Office of Police Complaints. He was appointed in March after the City Council passed a law creating the watchdog position following the debate and lawsuits over the police practice of stop-and-frisk. Relatives said they want to see more consequences for officers who administer deadly force, adding that the majority of officers have not been convicted in the deaths. Without consequences, they say, the use of force will continue. "I'm here today to find out why all these officers are breaking protocol yet nothing is happening," said Natasha Duncan, sister of 23-year-old Shantel Davis outside of the inspector general's offices in lower Manhattan. Davis was allegedly shot and killed by an officer after a car chase in East Flatbush. "I'm here today to ask for justice," said Hawa Bah, mother Mohamed Bah, described as an emotionally disturbed man who was shot and killed by police on Sept. 25, 2012 after Hawa Bah called police because her son was naked and wielding a foot-long knife in his Morningside Heights apartment. "Mohamed was a wonderful boy who would never commit any crimes," said Bah who added that police need better training to deal with the emotionally disturbed. Baez's mother said officers need to be held accountable. "When I heard this happened again I said: 'No, we cannot continue to let this happen...The police are supposed to protect us, not abuse us," she said. Margarita Rosario, the mother of Anthony Rosario and aunt of Hilton Vega, who were killed in a Bronx apartment in 1995 when police investigating a burglary fired 28 shots at the pair, many of which struck both men in the back, was overcome with emotion. "For 19 years I've been coming out here and saying when are we going to do something? When are we going to train these police officers....to stop killing our children. Our community can't take it anymore," she said. In Graham's case, Haste was indicted for manslaughter but that indictment was tossed out after a judge ruled that the Bronx District Attorney's office did not properly instruct the grand jury. A new grand jury declined to indict Haste. The Justice Department promised to look into the case almost a year ago. "I've been saying for two years if there is no jail time for Haste, it will happen again and here we go with Eric Garner. If Richard Haste had gone to jail it would have sent a clear message we are not going to tolerate this," Malcolm said. The three detectives charged in Bell's shooting were acquitted of criminal charges, but were later ousted from the NYPD for violating departmental guidelines. The Justice Department declined to charge the officers with civil rights violations. The Staten Island District Attorney is currently looking into Garner's case after the city's medical examiner ruled the death was a homicide caused by compression of the 43-year-old's neck and chest. The head of the Patrolmen's Benevolent Association and Sergeants Benevolent Association said the officer did not use a chokehold and accused Mayor Bill de Blasio of rushing to judgment in the case. "Sometimes the use of force is necessary. But it's never pretty to watch," PBA President Patrick Lynch said Tuesday about the Garner case. Mayor Bill de Blasio has said he takes the allegations very seriously but the investigations over Garner's death must run their course. Activists including the Rev. Al Sharpton are planning to march across the Verrazano-Narrows Bridge which connects Brooklyn and Staten Island on Aug. 23. Loyda Colon of the Justice Committee said the meeting was requested and confirmed two months before Garner's death but the participants represent "two decades of families" affected by alleged police brutality. Colon said the new inspector general has promised only to listen and to learn what the families are going through, but the group is still hoping for a historic outcome in the form of an investigation into the police use of force that leads to death. "My daughters are growing up without their fathers," said Paultre Bell. "We won't be satisfied until no more men, innocent, are killed by police officers." by Jeff Mays DNAinfo View Original Piece

  • Justice Committee Statement on Medical Examiner’s Garner Homicide Ruling and the Mayor’s Response

    Given the clear video documentation – which shows multiple officers brutally forcing Eric Garner to the ground, one of them putting him in a chokehold and all of them and EMS workers failing to administer CPR – we are not surprised at the New York City Medical Examiner’s ruling that Mr. Garner’s death was caused by homicide.  The ME’s findings coupled with the footage constitute overwhelming evidence of unnecessary brutality and criminal activity. All officers involved in the incident should be arrested and charged.  The Staten Island District Attorney must move forward with a swift and thorough investigation, convene a grand jury and fully prosecute these officers. Mayor De Blasio’s responses to the Eric Garner case and the many instances of brutality that have surfaced since as well as his defense of the NYPD’s aggressive, selective enforcement of low-level offenses are unacceptable. What the mayor calls “decades of mistrust” that “we all have a responsibility to work together to heal” in his response to the ME’s findings are, in reality, decades of abuse. It is premature to discuss how to better police-community relations while the philosophy guiding the NYPD’s practices – Broken Windows theory – criminalizes entire communities, and while there is no accountability for officers who unjustly kill New Yorkers. In the context of the NYPD’s long history and on-going practice of violence and abuse towards our communities, to say “we must all work together to heal” police-community relations is like saying, "try to get along with your abuser." Mayor De Blasio must not hide behind the band-aid solution of revisiting NYPD training, which will result in no accountability for officers who use excessive and deadly force, and he must stop acting like the problem of discriminatory abusive policing has been fixed. He has only to listen to people of color directly impacted by police violence in NYC and watch the videos to see that New Yorkers are suffering an epidemic of police violence right now, under his administration. ###

  • [Rejoice Magazine] Electeds, Civil Rights Orgs Join Family of Ramarley Graham to Call on DOJ to Act

    Black, Latino & Asian caucuses of NYS Legislature and NYC Council request DOJ consider convening grand jury, national civil rights group ColorofChange launches nationwide petition effort to members. ***View ColorOfChange Petition Here*** New York, NY – Just days after Ramarley Graham would have celebrated his 21st birthday, family members of Graham were joined by elected officials and civil rights groups to demand that the U.S. Department of Justice conduct a formal and thorough investigation into his shooting death by the NYPD. Graham, an 18-year-old Bronx resident, was shot and killed by NYPD Officer Richard Haste in the bathroom of his family’s home in front of his grandmother and 6-year-old brother after Haste unlawfully busted into the house in February 2012. After the Office of the Bronx District Attorney failed to indict, the U.S. Department of Justice indicated it was reviewing the case, but there have been no indications that it has opened a full investigation. “I was unable to celebrate Ramarley’s 21st birthday last Saturday or his last two birthdays, and instead have been forced to memorialize his life,” said Constance Malcolm, the mother of Ramarley Graham. “All I want is justice for the murder of my son and the Department of Justice is truly the only level of our justice system left that can provide accountability for the violation of Ramarley’s civil rights. They must act and provide a sense of basic equality that demonstrates our country equally respects the rights and lives of young men of color.” The chairs and members of the New York State Black, Puerto Rican, Hispanic & Asian Legislative Caucus and the New York City Council Black, Latino & Asian Caucus stood with the family to announce that they had sent letters to Attorney General Eric Holder requesting an official investigation by the Department of Justice into the death of Ramarley Graham. “The fact that there has not been a thorough and exhaustive investigation into the death of Ramarley Graham compounds the tragedy this family has faced,” said Assemblyman Karim Camara, chair of the Black, Puerto Rican, Hispanic & Asian Legislative Caucus. “From an alleged gun that was never discovered to the callous manner in which this family alleges they were treated by NYPD–there are too many unanswered questions. Not only must we ensure the circumstances surrounding his tragic death are not forgotten, but we must also send a strong message to young men of color that we value their lives and we will fight to protect their civil rights. It is my hope that the Department of Justice acts promptly as it is abundantly clear that this case necessitates further investigation.” “As we reflect on the young life of Ramarley Graham, who would have celebrated his 21th birthday this past Saturday, we can only speculate what contributions he would have made to society. We can only reflect on a young life that will never know a full life. We ask the question: Will there be justice for the unarmed teenager shot by police? We’re asking the Justice Department to evaluate the case of Officer Richard Haste vs. Ramarley Graham so that justice and fairness can be served,” said 12th District Council Member Andy King, co-chair of the City Council’s Black, Latino and Asian Caucus. National civil rights organization ColorofChange – the nation’s largest civil rights online advocacy organization that has mobilized Black Americans across the country on various racial and social justice issues – announced that it launched a nationwide petition demanding that the U.S. Department of Justice conduct a thorough investigation and bring charges against NYPD officer Richard Haste, who shot and killed Graham. “The petitions signed by ColorOfChange members represent the voices and stories of thousands of everyday people who want to trust our law enforcement officials, and who want to believe that justice will be served regardless of the color of one’s skin or the amount of money in one’s pocket,” said Rashad Robinson, Executive Director of ColorOfChange.org. “Ramarley’s family, Bronx community and supporters across the city have organized for more than two years to ensure that the local officials are fairly and thoroughly investigating the killing of an unarmed 18-year-old. The Department of Justice has a duty to protect our community against violent policing, racial profiling and to make sure that the justice system is working to equally protect Black youth, especially when local and state officials fail to do so.” Four months after the 2012 shooting, a Bronx grand jury indicted Haste on two counts of manslaughter; the first indictment of an NYPD officer for killing a civilian since 2007. But in May 2013, Judge Steven Barrett dismissed the indictment due to a technical error made by an assistant district attorney. A second grand jury decided not to re-indict Haste, but the U.S. Justice Department indicated it was reviewing the case. “The U.S. justice system must not continue to utterly fail the families of those who have unjustly lost their lives to the NYPD,” said Loyda Colon, Co-Director of Justice Committee. “Ramarley Graham, Sean Bell and Noel Polanco are just a few of those who have been killed by the NYPD without any justification and despite being unarmed. The U.S. Department of Justice has a choice to make:  it can fail to provide equal justice or it can send a message to the nation that the justice system values the lives of young people of color by bringing federal civil rights charges against officers responsible for the killing of Ramarley Graham.” The family was also joined in support by State Senators Adriano Espaillat, Ruth Hassell-Thompson and Bill Perkins, Assembly Members Walter T. Mosley, Félix Ortiz, Keith L.T. Wright, and New York City Council Black, Latino & Asian Caucus co-chair Rosie Mendez, Council Member Jumaane Williams, and Pastor Que English. “We’re here today because, more than two years after Ramarley Graham was killed, New York has failed to provide any meaningful accountability,” said New York Civil Liberties Executive Director Donna Lieberman. “When a child gets killed by a police officer in the bathroom of his family’s house, something has gone terribly wrong. And yet no one has provided any answers to explain how this tragedy occurred, or to prescribe remedies to ensure that no family ever has to suffer again in the way that the Graham family has. If New York City and New York State refuse to investigate, then that means it’s time for the Department of Justice to do so. We’re here talking about a child’s life. The stakes are too high to allow this tragedy to go unanswered.” The renewed push comes just months after the two year anniversary of Ramarley’s death, when the family was joined by 1199SEIU President George Gresham, community supporters, and the family members of several New Yorkers killed by NYPD officers over the past 20 years at a memorial service. Graham’s mother, Constance, is a member of 1199SEIU United Healthcare Workers East, which has supported the family’s struggle for justice. “There is no way to ever fill the deep void left by the loss of a child. But it is our strong hope that the Department of Justice fully investigates the killing of Ramarley Graham so that justice can be served and we can prevent these types of deplorable shootings in the future,” said George Gresham, President of 1199SEIU United Healthcare Workers East, the largest union in New York and the largest healthcare union in the nation. “The number of young people of color killed with impunity in this country is an ongoing moral outrage. We will continue to organize with Ramarley’s family and our allies to put an end to these killings, advance policies that will safeguard the lives of our youth, and demand that justice be done.” Ramarley Graham would have turned 21 on April 12, 2014. by Rejoice Magazine Staff Rejoice Magazine

bottom of page