Search Results
Search this site
419 results found with an empty search
- Justice Committee Responds to Mayor Mamdani’s SRG Plan
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Monday, November 16, 2026 New York, NY - In response to this morning’s news of Mayor Mamdani’s plans to phase out the NYPD’s Strategic Response Group (SRG) and restructure the city’s response to protests, the Justice Committee released the following statement from Executive Director, Loyda Colón (they/them): “We applaud the mayor for endorsing and adopting elements of the CURB Act to limit some of the violent tactics the NYPD has used to brutalize protesters. These are good first steps; however, we have serious questions and concerns related to whether what’s being called ‘disbanding the SRG’ may turn out to be rebranding and reshuffling SRG officers and functions. The history of NYPD units and the policing of protests has repeatedly shown that when units are created with special functions related to interacting with the public – like the new patrol support division that’s being created to handle arrests at protests, or the so-called “anti-crime” units of the past and present – the NYPD expands the scope, budget, and headcount of these units, and they function with impunity, violence and abuse, regardless of training. The NYPD routinely refuses to fire cops who kill, brutalize, or otherwise abuse New Yorkers. New Yorkers need to see this administration fire officers swiftly in such instances, and the Mayor should require regular public reporting by the NYPD to ensure that patrol support division cops aren’t primarily deployed to public gatherings – or the legacy of phasing out the SRG will be a reshuffling of NYPD violence through the creation of a new specialized unit. “We also have concerns about the new civilian unit announced within the Office of Community Safety. The intent to reduce police involvement is good, but not all police functions should be replicated. The devil is in the details – and there are too few details. Regardless of intent, this experiment of creating an OCS unit poised to function as an NYPD co-response team for protests can undermine the administration’s ambitions and the movement’s goals of building non-police community safety infrastructure, especially at this early stage of OCS’ development. We urge the administration to rethink whether this unit should be created at all, and move away from experiments that civilianize unnecessary policing roles, expand policing functions beyond the NYPD, and risk turning OCS into an arm of policing.”
- 45 Organizations to Mamdani: Prohibit NYPD Purchase & Use of AI-enhanced Cell-Site Simulators
Dear Mayor Mamdani, The undersigned 45 organizations write to express our strong opposition to the NYPD’s plans to procure portable cell-site simulators with artificial intelligence capabilities. Since December 2025, the NYPD has been in negotiations to enter into a no-bid contract with the Israeli surveillance technology company Cognyte for their FalcoNet mobile cell-simulator technology. Although the City has since walked back the no-bid contract after public outcry, Cognyte and other vendors still have the ability to bid on a contract for portable AI-equipped cell-site simulators. Regardless of the vendor, another mass surveillance tool in the hands of the NYPD will not make New Yorkers safer. We urge you to exercise your power and authority as mayor to: Prohibit the solicitation, procurement and/or utilization of AI-enhanced portable cell-site simulators by the NYPD and any other city agency, including use of such technology purchased by a non-NYC entity (e.g. federal or state government or private entity, such as the NYC Police Foundation). Prohibit any new or renewal contracts between any city agencies (including the NYPD) and corporate entities like Cognyte that have been linked to civil and human rights abuses. Prohibit further solicitation, procurement and warrantless utilization of digital surveillance technologies by the NYPD and any other city agency. Cognyte and its original parent company, Verint, have been linked to human rights abuses in Azerbaijan, Indonesia, Myanmar, South Sudan, and more. Their cell-site simulator technology has been used by authoritarian governments to target members of the LGBTQ+ community, monitor and surveil human rights activists and journalists, and imprison and torture political dissidents. In the United States, FalcoNet has already been used to identify and target immigrants at US borders and surveil immigrant communities, including Haitians in Florida. It is alarming that the City sought to contract with a company well-known for facilitating human rights violations, particularly because this technology would be deployed by the NYPD—an agency that has a long-documented history of misconduct and consistent disregard for the law. Beyond Cognyte, we are deeply concerned about the expanded mass surveillance capabilities that technologies such as FalcoNet offer. Cell-site simulators operate by mimicking a cell tower and gathering data on all nearby cellular devices, which can allow law enforcement to identify individual devices and their general locations. Portable cell-site simulators can be mounted in NYPD vehicles, attached to drones, or carried in a backpack. Coupled with AI capacities, the possibilities for highly intrusive, dragnet surveillance extend even further. The technology’s behavioral analysis AI capabilities, which are entirely undisclosed, compound these privacy risks and the potential for human and civil rights violations. The City takes on considerable risks by contracting with unaccountable and intentionally opaque surveillance technology companies. These risks pose a threat not only to New Yorkers’ safety and rights, but also expose the City to liability for resulting civil rights and privacy violations, which could negatively impact the City’s financial standing and ability to financially resource key initiatives. The NYPD’s use of cell-site simulators, even without these new capabilities, has long been cause for concern and demanding of more rigorous oversight. Records from 2008 to 2016 show that the NYPD deployed cell-site simulators over 1,000 times, largely without a warrant. The NYPD’s long history of overbroad surveillance and misconduct demonstrate that the agency cannot be trusted to responsibly deploy such powerful and intrusive technology. We call on you to ensure that no solicitation, procurement, new contract or warrantless utilization process moves forward for portable cell-site simulators—or other digital surveillance technologies—by the NYPD or any other NYC agency. New Yorkers do not need yet another mass surveillance tool tracking their every move. Sincerely, Justice Committee Center for Constitutional Rights Drug Policy Alliance DRUM - Desis Rising Up & Moving Jewish Voice for Peace - New York City Jews For Racial & Economic Justice (JFREJ) Legal Aid Society Make the Road New York New York Civil Liberties Union Allan Feliz Foundation Amadou Diallo Foundation The Action Lab The Arc of Justice The Bronx Defenders Center for Advancing Innovative Policy The Center for Anti-Violence Education The Distributed AI Research Institute E.R.I.C. Initiative Foundation Equality for Flatbush Fight for the Future Freedom Agenda Gender Liberation Movement Girls for Gender Equity Housing Works Immigrant Defense Project Jim Owles Liberal Democratic Club Just Futures Law Justice & Beyond Katal Center for Equity, Health, and Justice LatinoJustice PRLDEF Malcolm X Grassroots Movement MediaJustice Mijente MomsRising Neighborhood Defender Service of Harlem New York Communities for Change NYC Democratic Socialists of America NYU Peace Research and Education Program, Innovation Pillar Our Bronx SALAM SURJ NYC Surveillance Technology Oversight Project Transgender Law Center Upturn We Build the Block cc: NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch NYC Public Advocate Jumaane Williams NYC Comptroller Mark Levine NYC Department of Investigation Commissioner Nadia Shihata Chair and Commissioner of the New York City Commission on Human Rights Christine Clarke NYC Council Black, Latino and Asian Caucus NYC Council Progressive Caucus
- Over 40 Rights Groups Urge Mamdani to Block NYPD From Buying & Using AI-Equipped Mass Surveillance Tool
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE November 12, 2026 Over 40 Rights Groups Urge Mamdani to Block NYPD From Buying & Using AI-Equipped Mass Surveillance Tool Following voters’ rejection of government and corporate surveillance, NYC Mayor must block advanced cell-site simulators New York, NY – A coalition of 45 advocacy and legal organizations today called on Mayor Zohran Mamdani to prohibit the NYPD from procuring or utilizing AI-equipped cell-site simulators, citing the threat they pose to the safety and constitutional rights of New Yorkers. Two weeks ago, in response to public outcry, the city scrapped plans to acquire this technology through a no-bid contract with the Israeli company Cognyte, but the NYPD still intends to buy the AI-powered surveillance technology through an open bidding process that Cognyte can participate in. In the letter to Mayor Mamdani, Justice Committee, Center for Constitutional Rights, Desis Rising Up and Moving, Drug Policy Alliance, Jews For Racial & Economic Justice (JFREJ), Jewish Voice for Peace, Legal Aid Society, Make the Road New York, New York Civil Liberties Union, and other national and local organizations detail the problems with mobile AI-enhanced cell site simulators, which can be mounted on a drone or simply carried in a backpack. Their behavior analysis capabilities, which are entirely undisclosed, compound the threats to privacy and other rights. In addition to demanding that the mayor block their use, the organizations urge him to prohibit the NYPD and other agencies from contracting with companies complicit in human rights abuses and from using all digital surveillance technologies without a warrant. “The NYPD has a long history of racist policing and abusing surveillance technologies - and this particular technology is AI-turbocharged, making it even more intrusive and dangerous. If this moves forward, we should expect that it will be used as a hyper-drive dragnet to violate the rights of immigrants, Black and brown communities, LGBTQ people, those exercising their first amendment rights, and other New Yorkers,” said Loyda Colón, Executive Director of Justice Committee. “It’s good that the administration walked back the original sole-source contract with Cognyte, and we hope the Mayor seizes the opportunity to slam the door on the NYPD getting and using more unnecessary surveillance toys that advance an Orwellian police state instead of making New Yorkers safer.” Cell site simulators, also called stingrays, mimic cell towers and capture data from every nearby device. Cognyte’s AI-equipped version, FalcoNet, has reportedly been used by Florida officials to spy on Haitian immigrants, and governments around the world have used it to persecute dissidents, journalists, and LGBTQIA+ people. The over 40 groups believe this technology would be a dangerous weapon in the hands of the NYPD, which has a long history of racist policing, secrecy, and abuses against the New Yorkers. “The NYPD’s plans to buy and deploy portable AI-equipped cell-site simulators raise grave concerns about the Department’s commitment to transparency and to New Yorkers’ privacy,” said Medha Raman, Policy Counsel at the NYCLU. “Cell-site stimulators are highly intrusive dragnet surveillance that require a warrant. The NYPD’s flirtation with Cognyte, which prompted blowback because of the tech’s secret AI capabilities, should not continue through an open bidding process. For the NYPD to even consider deploying such dangerous technology that’s tied to scores of human rights violations is reckless and puts New Yorkers’ rights at risk.” Between 2008 and 2016, the NYPD deployed cell site simulators more than 1000 times, usually without a warrant. A 2017 Brooklyn state court ruled that the NYPD’s warrantless use of stingrays was unconstitutional, and department guidelines now say investigators must obtain a warrant “in most cases.” "Cell-site simulators can sweep up information from phones belonging to everyone in an area, including people suspected of no wrongdoing. They can also interfere with the cellular service of any devices within their range," said Jerome Greco, Director of the Digital Forensics Unit at The Legal Aid Society. "Adding undisclosed AI capabilities would deepen that surveillance while making it harder to understand or challenge how the technology is used. Given the NYPD’s previous history of warrantless deployments, the City should stop this procurement and prohibit any future attempts at obtaining any similar technology." “The NYPD has demonstrated again and again that it cannot be trusted to protect the civil rights of New Yorkers,” said Sophie Ellman-Golan, Director of Strategic Communications at JFREJ. “In 2016, the NYPD's own Inspector General found that the agency routinely broke the law and its guidelines when conducting surveillance. This technology can only supercharge this pattern of lawlessness, at a considerable financial cost. New York cannot be the vibrant, open society we all take pride in while also expanding the surveillance state and militarizing the NYPD. We are grateful that the Mamdani Administration halted Cognyte’s no-bid contract, and we urge the administration to further protect New Yorkers’ rights by barring the NYPD from using AI-equipped cell-site simulators.” The issue arises in New York as the use of AI-enhanced surveillance tools is sparking widespread opposition nationwide, as evidenced by the many lawsuits and laws opposing Flock cameras. Mayor Mamdani has, in other contexts, spoken out against such tools; he supports, for example, a bill to prohibit biometric data collection in public spaces. “It is disturbing but not unexpected that the NYPD sought to utilize no-bid procurement exceptions to expand their dangerous digital surveillance capacity,” said Brad Parker, associate director of policy at the Center for Constitutional Rights. “After 13 years of stop-and-frisk monitoring, the data shows the NYPD would rather perpetuate systemic violence than address abusive practices and hold officers accountable for illegal racial profiling. Commissioner Tisch must abandon this effort to enhance NYPD’s ability to violate New Yorkers’ constitutional and human rights.” “We don’t need safeguards for this technology. We need to reject it altogether,” said Anthony Feliciano, VP of Community Mobilization at Housing Works. “The history of policing tells us who will bear the consequences when government gains new powers to watch and track people. New Yorkers should not be paying for our own surveillance. Invest in housing. Invest in healthcare. Invest in our communities. Not one penny for technology designed to watch us.” Additional Quotes “It’s not just Cognyte: NYPD should never use cell-site simulators from any company, at any price,” said Surveillance Technology Oversight Project Advocacy & Community Engagement Manager Corinne Worthington. “These tools make it all too easy for police to embed into protests and scoop up the data not only of participants, but any passerby. NYPD is still bidding on our civil rights, and the Mamdani administration must go further to stop them.” “A surveillance state is not something that happens overnight. It is built one intrusion at a time, often in the name of public safety,” said Allen Roskoff, President of Jim Owles Liberal Democratic Club. “New Yorkers should not have to surrender their privacy and constitutional rights simply because they walk down the street carrying a phone.”
- [Gothamist] NYPD officer faces disciplinary trial 10 years after killing Delrawn Small
By Ben Feuerherd - published Oct. 21, 2026 The NYPD officer who shot and killed a man during a traffic dispute in Brooklyn more than a decade ago will face a departmental trial early next year, members of the slain man’s family said Wednesday. Officer Wayne Isaacs will go on trial in January on a charge that he used improper force when he shot and killed Delrawn Small in East New York in July 2016. The case against Isaacs was brought by the Civilian Complaint Review Board, the NYPD oversight agency that has authority to investigate police abuses against New Yorkers, including fatal shootings. For members of Small’s family, the departmental trial is the latest legal twist in a decadelong fight to hold Isaacs accountable for killing Small. The state attorney general brought murder and manslaughter charges against Isaacs, but a jury acquitted him of all counts. Small’s family also sued him in federal civil court and won a settlement from the city. “Everyone’s been asking me, ‘How do you feel?’ I still don’t know how to answer that,” Small’s brother, Victor Dempsey, told reporters Wednesday after meeting with officials from the CCRB. “The reason I can’t answer that is because our family has been fighting for 10 years.” In a statement, Patrick Hendry, the president of the union that represents Isaacs, said the oversight agency is unfairly pursuing the case. “It defies belief that this case is still ongoing. This police officer was tried and acquitted by a jury. He was already cleared by the NYPD under previous administrations. An NYPD trial commissioner has already ruled twice that the case should not proceed,” Hendry said. “CCRB is continuing to push this case without a single shred of new evidence, and their real goal is clear: they want to expand their power and erase any remaining due process protections for police officers,” he added. Dakota Gardner, a spokesperson for the Civilian Complaint Review Board, did not respond to Hendry's statements, but said board members are confident about the case they brought against Isaacs. “We are pleased that [NYPD] Commissioner [Jessica] Tisch recognizes the importance of a trial in this case. CCRB prosecutors are confident in the strength of the evidence and look forward to arguing their case early next year.” The shooting Isaacs shot Small three times in the early hours of July 4, 2016, not long after he got off duty from his job as a police officer in Brooklyn’s 79th Precinct. Both men had been driving in East New York. After some sort of incident on the road, Small got out of his car and walked over to the driver-side window of Isaacs’ car. Isaacs has maintained that he opened fire only after Small punched him multiple times through his open driver-side window. But video published after the shooting shows Small dropping and falling to the street almost immediately after walking up to the car window. The NYPD fully reinstated Isaacs after he was cleared of criminal charges. He’s currently assigned to the office of Chief of Special Operations, according to NYPD records. On Wednesday, Dempsey said the only fair outcome from the departmental trial would be for Isaacs to be fired. “I’m calling on Mayor Mamdani to pay attention to this. How is your administration going to operate?” he said. ‘Police action’ A year ago, the case was scheduled to go to departmental trial but hit another legal snag. Attorneys for Isaacs argued in filings that the NYPD’s trial board lacked jurisdiction because he was off duty at the time of the shooting. The NYPD judge presiding over the case, Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado, agreed with the arguments and issued a final recommendation that the case be dismissed due to lack of jurisdiction. Tisch, who has final authority on disciplinary matters in the department, overturned that decision in August. In a letter issued in August, Tisch wrote that Isaacs has argued in the case that he was taking “police action” when he shot Small because he was defending himself against violent crime. “[Isaacs’] position is that he was taking police action, but that nevertheless CCRB lacks jurisdiction over an allegation of excessive force arising from that police action. That is untenable,” Tisch wrote.
- Discipline Trial Finally Rescheduled for Officer Wayne Isaacs for Killing Delrawn Small Over a Decade Ago
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Wednesday, October 21, 2026 Family and supporters “deeply concerned” about continued NYPD obstruction, potential bias of presiding NYPD deputy commissioner - and urge Mayor Mamdani to ensure a fair process with no additional obstruction New York, NY –– Today, following a meeting with the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB), the brother of Delrawn Small and the Justice Committee announced that a discipline trial for NYPD Officer Wayne Isaacs, who killed Delrawn in 2016, is finally scheduled to take place, starting on January 13th, 2027. Mr. Dempsey was joined by the Justice Committee, which has been working closely with Mr. Small’s family since Isaacs killed him, and Public Advocate Jumaane Williams. “After over a decade of struggling to overcome legal games and delays, I’m relieved that a date for Isaacs’s disciplinary trial has finally been set, but I’m under no illusion that my family’s fight is over,” said Victor Dempsey, the brother of Delrawn Small. “We’re now on our third mayoral administration and seventh police commissioner since Officer Wayne Isaacs shot and killed my brother in front of his four-month-old son, and Isaacs has been shielded from discipline every step of the way. I am deeply concerned that this pattern will continue, but I will not stop fighting until he is fired without a pension or a ‘good guy letter’ that would allow him to keep his gun.” Delrawn’s family’s campaign for Isaacs to be fired finally appeared to be nearing its end last year, when his discipline trial was scheduled for November 2025. However, just weeks before it was set to begin, it was abruptly canceled after Isaacs’s police union attorneys filed a motion to dismiss the case, claiming that the CCRB lacks jurisdiction because Isaacs was not acting as a police officer when he killed Delrawn, and NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado sided with them, recommending all charges against Isaacs be dismissed. The CCRB, Delrawn’s family, and supporters have repeatedly highlighted the contradiction between this argument and the opposite argument Isaacs’s lawyers used to defend him in civil and criminal proceedings. The case remained stalled throughout most of Mamdani’s first year, pending a final decision from Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch. Although the discipline trial is now set to move forward, the family is concerned about the fairness of the proceedings, as Maldonado—who had recommended dismissing Isaacs’s misconduct charges based on Isaacs’ police union attorneys self-contradicted claim related to whether he was acting as a police officer when he killed Delrawn —is expected to preside over the disciplinary trial. “How can Delrawn’s family and New Yorkers have confidence in the process when the official overseeing the trial has already recommended throwing out the charges and we’ve been through more than a decade of obstruction & delays by the NYPD and police unions in this case alone?” said Justice Committee Executive Director Loyda Colón (they/them). “Deputy Commissioner Maldonado already sided with Isaacs’ attorneys’ bogus jurisdictional argument, even though they established that he acted in his police capacity when they defended Isaacs in both the criminal and civil cases - and the NYPD treated Isaacs as an officer after the killing. It’s outrageous that we and Delrawn’s family have to fight for a fair process on top of everything else they’ve endured to get this far. We urge Mayor Mamdani and his administration to take concrete steps to address our concerns and ensure that Isaacs’ trial moves forward without further delay, without further NYPD obstruction and without bias. Ultimately, the mayor and Commissioner Tisch must do what should have been done ten years ago and fire Wayne Isaacs. The fact that Isaacs is still paid by NYC taxpayers is a disgrace.” “Delrawn Smalls’ family has been fighting for justice for over a decade,” said Council Member Sandy Nurse. “Meanwhile, Officer Wayne Isaacs has kept his job and faced no accountability for killing Delrawn. I stand with Delrawn’s family in their struggle for disciplinary actions against him and call on Mayor Mamdani and Commissioner Tisch to act swiftly to bring this family some sense of justice.” BACKGROUND: On July 4, 2016 NYPD Officer Wayne Isaacs shot and killed Delrawn Small in front of his four-month-old son, step-daughter and girlfriend. Isaacs, who was off duty, had been driving erratically down Atlantic Avenue and cut Delrawn’s car off several times. When Delrawn approached Isaacs’ car, Isaacs rolled down his window, shot Delrawn three times and then left him to bleed out in the street without offering aid. Delrawn was unarmed. The NYS Attorney General’s Office prosecuted Isaacs for murder in the first case that went to trial after Governor Andrew Cuomo's 2015 executive order authorizing the AG to investigate police killings. The Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) substantiated fireable misconduct charges against Isaacs in October 2020, but the NYPD delayed serving the misconduct charges on Isaacs for almost a year. Isaacs and his police union attorneys have subsequently pursued multiple tactics to obstruct the discipline process, including filing an unsuccessful Article 78 lawsuit, attempted to convince multiple NYPD Commissioners to block the CCRB’s prosecution, and they successfully appeal the court’s decision to unseal Isaacs’s criminal case records, creating an additional obstacle to the discipline prosecution. Isaacs’s discipline trial was originally scheduled to begin on November 19, 2025. His police union attorneys filed a last-minute motion to dismiss, claiming the CCRB lacked jurisdiction because Isaacs was not acting in the capacity of a police officer when he killed Delrawn. Isaacs’s jurisdictional argument contradicts positions his attorneys took in the civil and criminal cases, in which they argued that he was acting as a police officer. In spite of the obvious contradiction, NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado recommended all charges be dismissed and the trial was removed from the calendar just weeks before it was set to begin. The final decision to either dismiss the charges or allow the trial to proceed had been stalled for almost a year with NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch. Isaacs killed Delrawn one day before Louisiana police killed Alton Sterling and two days before Philando Castile was killed by police in Minnesota. The officer who killed Philando Castile was fired in less than a year after the killing, one of the officers who killed Alton Sterling was fired within 2 years. More than thirteen years after Isaacs shot and killed Mr. Small, he is still employed as an officer with the NYPD. ###
- Mayor’s Police Reforms Will Not Address NYPD’s Culture of Violence and Impunity
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Monday, October 12, 2026 Justice Committee: Mayor’s Police Reforms Will Not Address NYPD’s Culture of Violence and Impunity New York, NY — Earlier today, Mayor Zohran Mamdani released a slate of police reforms in response to last week’s revelation that the NYPD allowed Officer Salvatore Alongi, who killed 19-year-old Win Rozario in March 2024, to retire with a disability pension while awaiting a departmental trial, without proper notification to the CCRB and without reporting for state decertification. Mamdani’s Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch, who chairs the police pension board that approved Alongi’s disability retirement, dismissed the scandal as the “human error” of a single civilian employee. In response to Mayor Mamdani’s proposed reforms, Loyda Colón (they/them), Executive Director of Justice Committee, issued the following statement: “While we appreciate Mayor Mamdani’s intent behind these reforms, they fall far short of what New Yorkers, including Win Rozario’s family, need and deserve. The problem is not that the NYPD needs more training or to revise its policies, but that the Department consistently evades oversight, transparency and meaningful change, violates the law and its own rules to do so, and shields officers who harm and kill New Yorkers from facing discipline. Alongi’s retirement with an enhanced pension and the NYPD’s failure to notify the CCRB and report him for decertification is a glaring example of this. Previously administrations tried to require the NYPD to review and adjust its own policies and it has never worked. Some immediate steps the administration should take include: 1. Appointing an Inspector General who is not afraid of holding the NYPD accountable and who has a track record of collaborating with organizations working to end police violence (in addition to increasing funding for the Office of the Inspector General); 2. Compelling the NYPD to comply with the Police STAT Act’s requirement to report all police killings and deaths in custody, which it has refused to do since the law was passed in 2020; 3. Ensuring that, within 24 hours after someone is killed or seriously injured, the officer(s)’s name, rank, post at the time of the incident, and whether or not they have been transferred, put on modified duty or suspended without pay is made public; 4. Making public if officers who have harmed New Yorkers are given NYPD retired ID cards, a “good guy” letter to maintain their service firearm, or other benefits, upon leaving the Department; and 5. Ensuring Commissioner Tisch and the NYPD do not create a loophole for officers to file for disability retirement while the CCRB is kept in the dark for months, as the NYPD’s comments last week appear to indicate. The CCRB must be notified as soon as an officer with pending misconduct cases applies for retirement —not months later, when it may be too late to move a CCRB prosecution forward. Requiring the NYPD to "formalize" its process of reporting officers who leave with pending discipline charges for decertification is redundant when state law already requires this. And it is insufficient to make Force Investigation Division reports available to families after someone is killed, given that, since its inception FID has largely served as a tool to shield officers and the Department from accountability. FID would need a full overhaul in order to be useful, and, more importantly, the entire NYPD discipline process needs to be transformed to ensure that officers who kill and harm New Yorkers are fired. From Alongi’s retirement to the violent repression of protests against ICE raids, New Yorkers are outraged by the NYPD’s ongoing brutality and impunity. It has been days since Win’s family exposed the scandal of Alongi’s retirement and the administration still has not responded to their demands for transparency about what happened and for Officer Cianfrocco, Win’s other killer, to be fired. Instead of releasing a slate of reforms that largely treat the problem as administrative issues for the Department to tweak, the Mamdani administration must work with directly impacted New Yorkers and the organizations accountable to them to dismantle the NYPD’s culture of violence and impunity."
- Parents of Win Rozario & Justice Committee Respond to Commissioner Tisch’s “Human Error” Statement
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Friday, October 9, 2026 Parents of Win Rozario & Justice Committee Respond to Commissioner Tisch’s “Human Error” Statement New York, NY — Following yesterday’s reveal that NYPD Officer Salvatore Alongi was allowed to retire in May while awaiting a departmental trial for the 2024 killing of Bangladeshi teen Win Rozario and that the NYPD still hasn’t submitted Alongi for state decertification in spite of state law requiring it, Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch released a short statement that only addressed the question of why the NYPD didn’t notify the civilian review board of Alongi’s retirement, claiming it e was a “mistake” of “human error”. The commissioner’s statement also revealed that Alongi received a disability pension, which is significantly higher than the amount of normal NYPD pensions. In response, Notan Eva Costa and Francis Rozario, the parents of Win Rozario, issued the following statement: “We’re disgusted by Commissioner Tisch’s response to our family exposing that the NYPD let Alongi retire with a full pension, without standing trial for murdering Win. She’s trying to make it seem like our family’s pain doesn’t matter by claiming some unnamed employee made one “mistake” when she should be apologizing for her own actions as Commissioner that have caused our family pain and allowed Alongi to avoid being fired. We’ve been fighting for nearly three years to fire these officers – and Tisch helped one of them secure his pension. Tisch is the chair of the police pension fund - she could have personally tabled a decision on Alongi’s retirement when it came up in May of this year, but instead, she approved it. Alongi filed for retirement in August of 2025 and Tisch personally ordered the NYPD to deliver the CCRB’s charges on him in September - why didn’t she tell us then that Alongi had already filed for retirement? The NYPD refused to substantiate misconduct against Alongi and Cianfrocco directly - and under Tisch there are ZERO cases where the NYPD has substantiated misconduct against any police that kill. She’s the boss of the NYPD so why are we still in the dark about whether the NYPD investigated the other misconduct that CCRB referred to them last September? The fact is, Tisch has the power to fire cops who kill, but she’s never fired any cop who has killed and in the examples we just named about Alongi & Cianfrocco, she’s either colluded with or allowed the NYPD to block fairness as we fight for Win. We demand that she make public how it’s possible Alongi retired with a disability pension and we want to know when he claimed his supposed “accident” happened because he was transferred and wasn’t supposed to be on the streets after he murdered Win. This is corruption and not only should Cianfrocco be fired, Jessica Tisch should be fired.” Loyda Colón (they/them), Executive Director of Justice Committee, issued the following response: “Tisch’s 3-sentence statement yesterday, responding to the Justice Committee and Win’s family exposing that the NYPD let Alongi retire without facing a discipline trial, is a slap in the face to Win’s family and every New Yorker who cares about fairness. Yesterday, Win’s family shared some of why they think this reflects a cover-up and high-level NYPD corruption. Tisch’s statement helps make their case and raises even more questions that point to possible corruption and cover-up. Tisch said Alongi was approved for disability retirement - which means his pension is much more than normal NYPD pensions. She’s the chair of the board that approves NYPD disability retirements - and she did nothing to delay or block the approval so that the discipline trial against Alongi could be expedited. We stand with Win’s family in demanding full transparency about Alongi’s retirement. New Yorkers deserve to know what “accident” he claimed he had and when it occurred, when different NYPD officials were notified about his retirement application and more. Instead of trying to downplay the current scandal and trying to minimize Win’s family’s pain, Tisch should explain why for almost half a year, the NYPD has continued to violate state law by not putting Alongi on the state’s police decertification list, she should ensure that Officer Matthew Cianfrocco is fired as soon as possible, and she should be making sure the NYPD substantiates the other misconduct referred to them by CCRB in the murder of Win.“
- NYPD Let Killer Cop Retire Amidst Pending Discipline Proceedings in Killing of Bangladeshi Teen Win Rozario
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Thursday, October 8, 2026 NYPD Let Killer Cop Retire Amidst Pending Discipline Proceedings in Killing of Bangladeshi Teen Win Rozario Family calls NYPD “corrupt,” says they feel “betrayed” by Mayor Mamdani and issues list of demands, including firing of second officer responsible for teen’s death New York, NY — Today, the family of Win Rozario held a press conference exposing that the NYPD let former Officer Salvatore Alongi, one of the two officers who killed their son in March 2024, retire in May with his pension and without notifying the civilian review board that was charged with prosecuting him in a pending discipline trial. In spite of city policy requiring that the NYPD notify the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) of retirement applications, the CCRB was never informed of a pending application, removing the possibility of an expedited discipline trial. In September 2025, multiple misconduct charges against Officer Alongi and his partner, Officer Matthew Cianfrocco, were substantiated by the CCRB, clearing the way for preparation towards a disciplinary trial. Joined by elected officials, the Justice Committee, other organizations and New Yorkers, Win Rozario’s parents and younger brother each spoke of their individual reactions and anger upon learning of Alongi’s retirement, months after he had already left the NYPD. Following their individual statements, the following joint family statement was shared, from Notan Eva Costa (mother of Win Rozario), Francis Rozario (father of Win Rozario), and Utsho Rozario (brother of Win Rozario): “All three of us have spoken about how outrageous it is that the NYPD let Alongi retire and avoid being fired for murdering Win. We’re disgusted that we weren’t even informed that he had retired until August - months after he had already left with his pension, which we as taxpayers are paying for. We want to make clear that we believe this is part of a major cover-up and corruption involving the top leaders of the NYPD, including Jessica Tisch, who should be fired. We feel betrayed by the mayor, who came to our home and talked with us when he was campaigning, after Win was murdered. He said he would be a different kind of mayor but it doesn’t seem like it when it comes to the NYPD. At this point we demand that the administration: Schedule the Cianfrocco discipline trial and fire him as soon as possible. March will mark three years since Win was killed. Don’t force us to continue to be fighting to fire Cianfrocco when we should be commemorating 3 years after Win was stolen from us. End NYPD obstruction and make sure Alongi is officially put on the state decertification list so that he can’t work as an officer ever again. Make all information related to Alongi’s retirement public. Whether through a DOI investigation or another independent process we demand for us and the public to know: the facts and full timeline about how Alongi was allowed to retire; the terms of Alongi’s retirement, including what his retirement and exit package included and didn’t; who at the NYPD knew what about Alongi’s retirement and when they knew it, and anything else that will help the public and us understand the cover-up, so that this situation never happens again in the future. Make sure that NYPD higher ups face serious consequences for letting this outrage happen, as well as for other obstruction the NYPD has engaged in, including the Force Investigation Division and senior NYPD officials who are responsible for overseeing FID and DAO. This includes firing Jessica Tisch. Remove police from all mental health response, including replacing BHEARD with a model that works and that would have resulted in Win getting care and not being killed by the NYPD.” While Alongi was allowed to escape discipline consequences through his retirement, Officer Matthew Cianfrocco remains on the force, pending the outcome of a pending discipline trial. Win’s family’s demands for the NYC Department of Investigations (DOI) to investigate Alongi’s retirement, follows a recently released report on concerns related to an aspect of the NYC Police Pension Fund’s retirement program. DOI has specific oversight authority over all city agencies. New York state law requires that if “an officer has resigned or retired subsequent to, or in connection with, allegations of misconduct” as Alongi did, the relevant police department is responsible for reporting them to the state for decertification. According to public state records, the NYPD still hasn’t reported Alongi for decertification. Loyda Colón (they/them), Executive Director of the Justice Committee, and a key organizer who works closely with Win’s family stated: “The NYPD let a killer cop retire almost half a year ago, protecting him from being fired – and according to public records, the NYPD still hasn’t even reported him for state decertification which means he could easily be hired as a cop in another jurisdiction. The NYPD never informed the CCRB that Alongi retired, robbing Win’s family of the chance to see him stand trial and be fired. Making matters worse, Win’s family was kept in the dark for months about Alongi’s retirement – while they continued to plan their campaign and fight to fire both cops. Both Alongi and Cianfrocco should have already been fired, but the NYPD has been allowed to continue to use dirty tricks to help cops who kill, brutalize and abuse New Yorkers keep their jobs or retire with benefits. The mayor and this administration has the opportunity and obligation to end this cycle of NYPD abuse, obstruction and cover-ups that families and police violence survivors are regularly subjected to by ensuring that Cianfrocco is fired as soon as possible and that the family’s other demands are agreed to.” Elected officials who came out to support Win, included Public Advocate Jumaane Williams and Council Members Shahana Hanif, Alexa Avilés, Sandy Nurse, Pierina Sanchez, and Carmen De La Rosa. Organizations included: Justice Committee, Desis Rising Up and Moving, Freedom Agenda, Make the Road New York, and Showing Up for Racial Justice. Additional quotes “This is yet another example of NYPD completely betraying our public trust,” said Council Member Alexa Avilés. “Every time we show up to discuss this case, my heart gets more broken—for Win Rosario’s family, his community, and our city. This is not public safety, it is public harm, and the circumvention of true justice. We need resources and programs that improve the lives of New Yorkers, and I’m sickened by the public funds that are instead used for violence. We must expect better from our city.” BACKGROUND On March 27, 2024, 19-year old teenager Win Rozario was killed in front of his mother and younger brother in his family’s Ozone Park apartment by NYPD Officers Salvatore Alongi and Matthew Cianfrocco. Officers Alongi and Cianfrocco recklessly shot Win at least five times in less than two minutes of entering the apartment, as his mother pleaded for the officers not to shoot. Alongi & Cianfrocco violated numerous NYPD protocols, including when they tased Win without warning while he was standing still with nothing in his hands, chaotically escalating the crisis that they had created without properly taking NYPD-required steps to de-escalate in spite of sufficient time to do so, and shooting Win while his mother and younger brother were nearby, endangering their lives. Immediately following the shooting, NYPD officers forced Win’s mother and younger brother to go to the precinct to be interrogated, refusing to allow them to accompany Win to the hospital. Ms. Costa was questioned at length without counsel before being told her son had died, and Win’s 17-year-old brother was also interrogated alone. The NYPD blocked re-entry to the Rozario family’s home for more than two days, refusing the family’s requests to retrieve belongings, access medications, or even to have someone feed their cat. For over a month after Win Rozario was killed, the NYPD blocked transparency, including refusing to release the names of the officers involved. Alongi and Cianfrocco’s names were first publicly identified by the Attorney General’s Office when they released officer body camera footage on May 3, 2024. After being questioned by reporters, Mayor Adams falsely claimed that he had reached out to the family after the incident and that discipline would have to wait until after the Attorney General’s investigation concluded with a determination, which has never been accurate. For the past two and a half years, Win Rozario’s family, along with the Justice Committee, Desis Rising Up & Moving and other organizations have called for the NYPD to fire NYPD officers Alongi and Cianfrocco. Win’s family is also calling for police to be removed from the city’s mental health response systems. Win Rozario’s mother wrote about the first year since Win was killed and the NYPD’s mistreatment of her family in a March 2025 Daily News Op-Ed. On September 12, 2025, the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) substantiated eight misconduct charges against officers Alongi and Cianfrocco, including excessive force and abuse of authority, and filed “charges and specifications,” the highest class of discipline against officers. The NYPD was pushed to serve the charges within the week, and a departmental discipline trial is pending. ### About the Justice Committee: Since the 1980s, the Justice Committee (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice.
- NYPD Still Severely Underreports Stop-and-Frisks, Despite Court Oversight
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Tuesday, September 29, 2026 NYPD Still Severely Underreports Stop-and-Frisks, Despite Court Oversight 13 years after landmark Floyd decision, NYPD continues illegal racial profiling with impunity New York, NY – In response to the newest court-appointed monitor’s report showing that NYPD is still severely underreporting stops, Justice Committee Executive Director Loyda Colón (they/them) released the following statement: “It’s been thirteen years since New Yorkers put the NYPD on trial for their unconstitutional stop-and-frisk practices and won, securing a federal ruling that the NYPD’s program was unconstitutional and that directly-impacted communities need to be part of developing solutions to end these daily, abusive and discriminatory violations of our rights. In spite of this, cops have continued illegal practices at high rates, and the NYPD as an institution has continued to show a blatant disregard of the law by refusing to discipline officers, supervisors, and commanders for non-compliance with the law and the Floyd court. Yesterday’s report demonstrates that the NYPD constantly finds new ways to skirt the law: under-reporting stops, failing to activate body cameras when required, recategorizing encounters to escape audits, and more. We’re now on our fourth mayor and seventh police commissioner since the Floyd ruling, and the NYPD is no closer to following the law than in 2013. The question now is whether this mayor will finally require the NYPD to finally stop their illegal racial profiling and abusive violence against Black, Latine, and other communities of color, or whether Jessica Tisch, the NYPD, and individual officers will continue to get a pass when they break the law.” ### About Justice Committee: Since the 1980s, the Justice Committee (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice.
- Rest in Power, Iris Baez 🕊️
Iris was THE OG—the matriarch to families whose loved ones were murdered by police, not just in NYC but across the country and around the world. For over 3 decades, she never gave up the fight against police violence and brutality. While this is devastating news, we know she's being welcomed by the ancestors. Iris’s son #AnthonyBaez was killed by NYPD Officer Francis Livot in 1994 with an already-banned chokehold – 20 years before #EricGarner was killed in the same way. Anthony’s murder catapulted Iris into the streets, and she became a force like no other. Iris fought tirelessly for her son, and she co-founded Parents Against Police Brutality with Margarita Rosario (the mother of Anthony Rosario & aunt of Hilton Vega, who were killed by NYPD) to fight with other families against police violence. When another family lost a loved one, Iris was always there, providing a shoulder to cry on, a word of advice, or inspiration to fight. In her son’s memory, she founded the Anthony Baez Foundation to do just that. Iris was featured in PBS’s award-winning documentary ‘Every Mother’s Son’ alongside the mom of Amadou Diallo and Gidone Busch, documenting her fight for her son & her leadership in the movement. As a long-time leader in Justice Committee and the ultimate GOAT, Iris was at the forefront of many wins: forcing Cuomo to sign an executive order for a special prosecutor (and later winning legislation on that), passing the Community Safety Act & Right to Know Act, repealing 50-A, calling for defunding NYPD, and standing in solidarity with families at the discipline trials of cops who killed their loved ones. She engaged in civil disobedience, and staged a takeover of the Bronx DA office. If there was a righteous action, you bet Iris was there. Iris was an inspiration and co-conspirator to so many of us. She never gave up, and never lost her kindness and ferocity. She remained an active leader of JC even while facing severe health struggles, joining meetings up until the moment that her body would not let her anymore. Her mentorship, wisdom, tenacity and power left its mark on so many of us - we are her legacy. Rest in Power, Iris. We love you. !Pa’lante!
- The Moment We’re In - and How We Got Here
Part of the Meeting the Moment compilation, curated by Building Beyond Policing and Democratizing Justice Initiative. Read the entire issue: As the United States careens toward authoritarianism, the role of law enforcement as an enforcer of a specific political agenda — backed by ever-expanding powers, funding, militarization, and surveillance infrastructure — has never been clearer. But this ominous trend is not limited to federal law enforcement under the Trump regime; it mirrors the trajectory of the New York Police Department, which has long embodied authoritarian tendencies. This critical moment demands a clear assessment of what is (and isn’t) new, how we got here, and the interconnected nature of our struggles, and it necessitates organized and coordinated interventions across multiple fronts. The United States was built through settler colonialism, ethnic cleansing, and the stolen labor of enslaved people. To maintain power and continue to extract profit, the state has always used violence and coercion, from slave patrols and forced Indigenous boarding schools to Jim Crow laws and voter suppression, to today’s regime of mass incarceration, detention, and deportation. Under the thinly veiled guise of “safety,” law enforcement was created to carry out the state’s will, even (and often) at the expense of people’s freedom and well-being. The decades-long normalization of state violence has helped lay the foundation for the MAGA authoritarian takeover we are currently struggling to resist. While there are ways in which Trump’s anti-immigrant agenda can be understood as the newest versions of the United States’ practiced systems of exploitation, oppression, punishment, and social control under racial capitalism, we feel in our bones that things are different: more accelerated, more terrifying, more out of control. Part of what distinguishes this moment is that those in power now have the technology to automate social control and profit from it faster than ever before. The state can map out, with a few clicks, who you know, track your location, and evaluate if even your thoughts — let alone your actions — are “acceptable.” Suppressing dissent is a pillar of authoritarianism, necessary for controlling the narrative and eliminating opposition in order to keep the path clear to further exploit people and the land for profit. When people resist, they face repression, which too often turns deadly, as in the cases of Tortuguita, Renee Good, and Alexi Pretti. The same technology being used to surveil us is also livestreaming these images of people being kidnapped, beaten, bombed, and killed. Far from incidental, these spectacles of violence serve as constant reminders of the very real threats we face if we dissent, hold certain identities, or simply end up in the wrong place at the wrong time. They reveal just how disposable we are in a system increasingly dominated by apocalyptic billionaires, far-right populists, and Christian nationalists, and they are organized to ensure the elite few have the most possible as the world falls apart. Through this rapidly accelerating surveillance and misinformation machine, the Trump regime and its plutocratic associates are amassing massive wealth: private companies profit from detention, tech companies get rich off our data, and this wealth accumulation circles back to feed the flywheel of social control, as evidenced by the gutting of journalism by billionaires. While most of us struggle to meet our basic needs, the same elites investing in surveillance, detention, and border militarization insulate themselves from the crises their policies help produce. In this worldview, crisis is not something to solve collectively but something to weaponize — a justification for repression, exclusion, and the concentration of power in the hands of those who claim they alone can protect “the deserving” from everyone else. Technology is not the only force defining this moment. The consolidation of white nationalist populism, while not new, has renewed vigor and influence and is cohering into fascist governance. The current Trump regime has coupled its technical and military resources with an all-out attack on democratic institutions, gutting multiple agencies and replacing even minor opponents with powerful allies. Combined with the isolation of the 21st century and growing wealth gap, the unabashed othering of Black, brown, poor, trans and nonbinary, and other marginalized folks projects a zero-sum world — one where survival for some is premised on the disposability of others. The omnipresent threat of punishment, or even the fear of it, perpetuates division and prevents us from pursuing the solidarity organizing that could lead to meaningful change. In this end-times framework, fragmentation is not incidental but essential: it ensures that collective resistance is weakened precisely when it is most necessary. Where are we headed if we don't organize? This era of social media-length attention spans makes it all the more likely that we will settle for ahistorical interpretations of the present. That’s how you get the same people who were in the streets in 2020 demanding to defund the police now buying into liberal narratives like “ICE isn’t law enforcement” and that we need local departments to “police ICE.” In reality, the evidence that local law enforcement serves national agendas is right in front of our faces. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) has always depended on local policing to make people more deportable through arrests, convictions, and the steady flow of information. Even in a “sanctuary city,” since the U.S. Department of Homeland Security’s creation, the NYPD has been feeding the deportation machine through its broken windows targeting of immigrant communities and regular collaboration with federal agencies. Today, that collaboration is even more visible. The NYPD and federal agencies operate joint task forces and share intelligence, creating channels for federal authorities to directly access local police operations. The NYPD violently cracks down on anti-ICE protestors and clears the way for ICE to make arrests. The NYPD’s expansive surveillance systems — including license plate readers, facial recognition, and gang databases — collect and circulate vast amounts of data that can be accessed and manipulated by federal authorities. In practice, a single police encounter — a stop, summons, arrest, or entrance into a database — can trigger a chain of information sharing that exposes someone to ICE regardless of formal sanctuary policies. On top of this, the NYPD’s rising misconduct rates, abusive quality-of-life policing practices (e.g., stop-and-frisk), and culture of impunity normalize blatant attacks on community members and create a culture of fear, violence, and powerlessness against the state. In authoritarian consolidation, local and federal law enforcement coverage is in overdrive. If we allow the MAGA project to continue down the path it’s on without intervention, the likely outcome is bleak: the seamless integration of all law enforcement as the repressive arm of a fascist regime. The prison-industrial and deportation-industrial complexes will not only persist under these conditions, but they will expand and thrive, and we will reach unfettered levels of social control, with mass surveillance, policing, and punishment even more deeply embedded into the fabric of everyday life. While there may be moments along the way when local and federal law enforcement appear to be at odds as states feebly attempt to resist federal overreach, this will not erase the reality that the big-picture purpose of all law enforcement is the same: to serve state and elite interests. Even if the current MAGA regime implodes of its own volition — which it might — without urgent action grounded in astute analysis, we will still end up living with the institutionalized remains of authoritarianism. We’ll be faced with further normalization and empowerment of draconian local and federal law enforcement and increased criminalization of our communities. The predictable demobilization of the left, which will come with the sigh of relief that “at least Trump is gone,” will leave the door wide open for compounded police power and the silencing of anyone who objects. What do we do? So, in these terrifying times, what do we do? As the Trump regime deports more and more people, at times to certain death, and accelerates its brand of imperialism — from Gaza, to Venezuela, to Cuba to Iran — how do we build the power necessary to resist? First, we must ground ourselves in a clear analysis: Policing, immigration enforcement, and the broader carceral system are tools used to maintain racial capitalism and the U.S. imperial project. The further militarization and integration of policing systems has paved the way for and reinforced the authoritarian takeover, and efforts that focus on reforming and retraining these systems lead us woefully in circles. Whether we’re fighting MAGA or a more “liberal” regime, we must consistently focus on organizing that reduces the power and scope of policing and the broader carceral state. Second, we must regroup and recommit to real grassroots organizing. This is more than just public education, one-off rallies, or disconnected mutual aid and rapid response. All of these are worthwhile tactics, but they must be woven into a coherent strategy to be effective in transforming our material conditions. As prolific activist and Justice Committee co-founder Richie Perez often said, we need “any and all tactics” — not just in the sense of using every tool available to us, but in strategically integrating them toward clear goals. Organizing is the sustained work of developing and centering the leadership of directly impacted people, building collective strategy, and waging campaigns with clear targets and demands that build power and shift conditions. Mass mobilization can be an important tool in organizers’ box of tactics, but simply calling for “justice” or marching under broad slogans like “no kings,” without identifying who holds power and what must change, and then strategically escalating pressure, does little to force concrete outcomes. For example, in New York in 2020, we were able to channel the momentum of the uprisings into real power building and tangible victories, because the Justice Committee and dozens of allies had already spent years building alignment and cross-sector coordination through Communities United for Police Reform. With the unwavering leadership of families whose loved ones were killed by the NYPD, we waged disciplined campaigns that combined mass mobilization, direct action, public education, advocacy, strategic communications, and legal tactics to win the repeal of the “police secrecy law” (CRL 50-a), the passage of special prosecutor legislation, and the reduction of the NYPD budget by close to $350 million for FY 2021, among other victories. While imperfect, these victories set the stage for future organizing. For example, the repeal of CRL 50-a is how we know that the officer who killed Allan Feliz has a history of 40 misconduct allegations, a fact that has been instrumental in the campaign to ensure he is fired. Similarly, today we see how sustained, multifaceted, community-led resistance to immigration raids in Minnesota helped force the withdrawal of some ICE agents. In these fraught times, this foundation of disciplined organizing also requires heightened attention to security and self-determination. As the state expands its surveillance capacity and proves itself unwilling (or unable) to ensure our safety, more people are recognizing that our security must come from each other. To that end, people are increasingly building networks outside of formal institutions, using encrypted communications, conducting Know Your Rights trainings, and developing rapid-response infrastructure to protect their hyperlocal communities. This shift is not incidental; it is a necessary adaptation to an environment where “public safety” institutions function as instruments of control rather than protection. Third, we must build cross-sector solidarity and collaboration. “Criminal” and immigration enforcement are deeply intertwined, and attempts to portray local police as “real” or “good” law enforcement in contrast to ICE and CBP are misguided and dangerous. Our demands should aim to simultaneously reduce federal and local law enforcement power and collaboration. Now is the moment to de-silo our movements; align analyses, strategies, and narratives; and recognize that our struggles are interconnected. Part of this means not letting local officials and police departments off the hook. Rather than futilely calling on local police to save us from ICE, we should be demanding a stop to joint task forces, data and resource sharing, and other collaborations that empower local law enforcement agencies to further criminalize and punish immigrants. Even as we confront federal overreach, cities and states like New York continue to expand police budgets, surveillance infrastructure, criminalization, and the suppression of dissent under the guise of “public safety.” In New York, this means fighting to remove the NYPD from mental health response, schools, and other social service roles, ensuring real investments in noncarceral mental health care and crisis response, and challenging the police commissioner’s unchecked authority over police discipline, which fuels the NYPD’s violence with impunity. This work requires us to reckon with the severity of state violence and how the long-lasting trauma of living under its thumb impacts our day-to-day lives, and to foster a culture of mutual care in its wake. Building on this foundation, it means harnessing community power to mobilize coordinated, strategic militant resistance that transforms oppressive systems, using any and all tactics to bring us closer to liberation. No one person in this movement stands alone, and in acting together, what we sow now will be reaped for many generations to come. By combining militant, organized resistance with rigorous political education, we can transform individual outrage into collective action and power. This is how movements threaten the system and can, with sustained resistance, dismantle it. This is how we win. Conceived of and authored by Justice Committee staff & members: Aubergine Yuen Christine Henson David Galarza Henna Kaur Jon McFarlane Susan Hadley Tess Weiner, Communications Coordinator Yul-san Liem
- [Gothamist] Advocates say Mayor Mamdani's NYPD isn't curbing broken-windows policing
By Ben Feuerherd in Gothamist Aug 13, 2026 Elected officials and police reform advocates on Thursday called on Mayor Zohran Mamdani to rein in what they call a continuation of broken windows policing under his administration, after they watched criminal court arraignments across the city over several days this week. City Councilmember Sandy Nurse joined the advocates in front of Manhattan Supreme Court on Centre Street, and said she would keep the pressure on City Hall to enact policies that keep New Yorkers out of jail. “ We're gonna keep holding this administration accountable,” Nurse said. “We love an allied mayor … but we have to continue to hold everybody accountable.” The outcry comes as Mamdani has faced repeated criticism from progressive advocates over how he has governed the city on public safety. When he was running for office, Mamdani said a top priority of his administration would be to create a Department of Community Safety that would shift some responsibilities away from NYPD officers to allow them to focus on solving the most serious crimes committed in the city. Since taking office, Mamdani has announced a pared-down version of the department, but has also said it will eventually scale up. The mayor has also repeatedly distanced himself from his past statements that called for defunding the NYPD — including as recently as this week. And as mayor, he also kept Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch, an Eric Adams appointee who critics say has continued quality-of-life policing in the same manner as seen throughout Adams’ administration. Gothamist previously reported that criminal summonses that include quality-of-life infractions like public drinking jumped 29% in the first three months of 2026 compared to the same period in 2025. Last year, the number of New Yorkers arrested for taking up more than one seat on the subway jumped 3,000% — a trend that continued in the first months of the Mamdani administration. An NYPD spokesperson said the department has made significant efforts to reduce the amount of low-level arrests over the course of about 15 years. From 2010 through 2018, there’s been a 50% decrease in misdemeanor arrests, the spokesperson said. But since the end of the pandemic, the amount of misdemeanor arrests has held steady at levels seen in 2018, according to the spokesperson. At an unrelated press conference Thursday, Mamdani defended Tisch’s management of the NYPD and said he looked forward to reviewing the findings of the advocates who watched arraignments this week. “I would not have someone serving our city if I was not confident in what they were doing,” Mamdani said of Tisch. City Hall, asked for comment, referred to the mayor’s public statements. At the press conference in front of the courthouse, advocates from organizations including Vocal-NY, the Justice Committee, and the Legal Aid Society joined elected officials, including Councilmembers Lincoln Restler and Crystal Hudson as well as Queens Borough President Donovan Richards. While sitting in courtrooms across the five boroughs this week, the advocates said they witnessed more than 360 arraignments, and 57% of them were for misdemeanor charges. Only 83 of the arraignments they witnessed were for felonies that could not be settled through desk appearance tickets, they said. The cases they saw included crimes like stealing hygiene products from convenience stores and drug possession. Samy Feliz — a police reform advocate and the brother of Allan Feliz, who was shot and killed by an NYPD officer amid a struggle during a traffic stop in 2019 — said those arrests amount to criminalizing poverty in the city. The Feliz family is suing the city over Tisch’s decision not to fire Lt. Jonathan Rivera for the shooting. Rivera testified in an NYPD trial that he shot Allan Feliz because Rivera feared Allan Feliz could run over another officer with his car, but the judge who oversaw the trial said the evidence disproved that assertion. “ What New Yorkers saw in courtrooms this week was not a new approach to public safety that Mayor Mamdani promised during his campaign,” Samy Feliz said. It is not focusing on police resources on serious crime. It is the same aggressive, racially discriminatory enforcement of low-level offenses that we saw under Eric Adams.”

![[Gothamist] NYPD officer faces disciplinary trial 10 years after killing Delrawn Small](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/f8a96d_76f293609b3149c49670b7b2bd2429d6~mv2.png/v1/fit/w_176,h_124,q_85,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,blur_3,enc_auto/f8a96d_76f293609b3149c49670b7b2bd2429d6~mv2.png)






![[Gothamist] Advocates say Mayor Mamdani's NYPD isn't curbing broken-windows policing](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/f8a96d_e5a890261e884bc0951e8a6cef489e58~mv2.png/v1/fit/w_176,h_124,q_85,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,blur_3,enc_auto/f8a96d_e5a890261e884bc0951e8a6cef489e58~mv2.png)