Search Results
Search this site
419 results found with an empty search
- Kawaski Trawick’s family & electeds deliver letter to mayor and call for firing of officers
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Monday, May 15, 2023 MEDIA CONTACTS Kristine Mikkelsen, kmikkelsen@spitfirestrategies.com Eliel Cruz, press@justicecommittee.org New York - Today, just days after the discipline trial of the officers who killed their son concluded, the family of Kawaski Trawick was joined by elected officials and groups at a press conference to discuss the trial and call on Mayor Eric Adams to ensure the officers who killed Mr. Trawick are fired swiftly. The outcome of the trial will determine whether Officers Brendan Thompson and Herbert Davis will face any discipline penalties, including employment termination, for killing Mr. Trawick in his own home on the night of April 14, 2019. Following the press conference, the Trawicks entered City Hall and delivered a letter to Mayor Adams that urges him to, “act quickly and decisively to fire Thompson and Davis to make clear that the life of our Black, gay son mattered and to ensure the safety of New Yorkers”. They were escorted by Council Members Pierina Sanchez, Althea Steves, Alexa Aviles, and Tiffany Caban, the Trawick family's attorney, Royce Russell, Justice Committee Executive Director Loyda Colon and NYC Anti-Violence Project Executive Director, Beverly Tillery. “Last week you mentioned your son when you spoke about Jordan Neely. Since you’ve been Mayor, we’ve never heard you say Kawaski’s name in public,” the letter states. “Kawaski was our son and he was loving and kind. He was just cooking in his apartment when Thompson and Davis used a baton to break the chain holding his door, tased him when he asked why they were in his home, then shot at him four times – all in 112 seconds. They didn’t check on him or try to save his life, they let him bleed out and die. Thompson and Davis created an unnecessary crisis and escalated it, disregarding NYPD training and procedures. Thompson and Davis are a danger to New Yorkers and should be fired.”. Now that the trial has concluded, Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado, the NYPD trial judge, will submit and report to NYPD Commissioner Keechant Sewell, who has the authority to choose whether to discipline the officers or not. There is no deadline for this decision. The Trawick’s letter raises concerns about lies and inconsistencies in Officers Thompson and Davis’ stories, the NYPD’s faulty investigation into the case, and the series of NYPD delays and roadblocks the discipline process has faced. “The trial made it even more clear that these officers should be fired but we don’t have faith in the NYPD to be fair,” the letter states. “We expect that they’ll want to continue their cover-up, and sweep this case under the rug…We’re asking for you to act in your capacity as Mayor to correct what has been wrong, end the cover-up and obstruction - and ensure that Thompson and Davis are fired within the coming weeks.” “The only fair outcome is for Thompson and Davis to be fired, without good guy letters and without the NYPD and administration covering for them,” the letter concludes. The full letter to Mayor Eric Adams from Ellen and Rickie Trawick, parents of Kawaski Trawick, can be downloaded here. Background: On April 14, 2019, Kawaski Trawick locked himself out of his apartment while he was cooking. The fire department let Mr. Trawick back into his apartment without incident. Mr. Trawick was cooking in his home after the situation had been resolved when NYPD Officers Thompson and Davis illegally entered Mr. Trawick’s apartment by using a baton to break the chain on his door, and killed him in 112 seconds. After tasing and shooting Mr. Trawick, neither of the officers attempted to administer emergency medical aid. They closed the door to Kawaski’s apartment, then stood outside, leaving Mr. Trawick to bleed out on the floor. Over the past four years, through two mayoral administrations and three police commissioners, there’s been a series of cover-ups, delays and obstruction, preventing the public from knowing about Kawaski Trawick and to shield the officers from being fired. The family and advocates are demanding that Mayor Adams and NYPD Commissioner Sewell fire both Thompson and Davis as soon as possible, and not drag out the decision-making for months. Mr. Trawick was a Black gay man, a son, and a brother pursuing his dreams as a dancer in New York City before that dream and his life was cut short at the hands of NYPD Officers Thompson and Davis. ### About the Justice Committee: Since the 1980s, the Justice Committee (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice. Justice Committee is a Communities United for Police Reform member organization. About Communities United for Police Reform: Communities United for Police Reform (CPR) is an unprecedented campaign to end discriminatory and abusive policing practices in New York, and to build a lasting movement that promotes public safety and reduces reliance on policing. CPR runs coalitions of over 200 local, statewide and national organizations, bringing together a movement of community members, lawyers, researchers and activists to work for change. The partners in this campaign come from all 5 boroughs, from all walks of life and represent many of those most unfairly targeted by the NYPD. ###
- In shock decision, judge in police killing trial moves to block oral closing arguments
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Thursday, May 11, 2023 MEDIA CONTACTS Kristine Mikkelsen, kmikkelsen@spitfirestrategies.com Eliel Cruz, press@justicecommittee.org New York - Tonight, the first day of testimony after a two-week adjournment of the discipline trial against NYPD Officers Brendan Thompson and Herbert Davis for the killing of Kawaski Trawick, the trial judge ruled that she would not allow oral closing summations - and would only accept written summations to be submitted privately to her, weeks after the trial is concluded. The shock decision comes after a cascade of judicial decisions that appear to rush the trial and block the full investigation from being heard. The trial outcome will determine whether the officers will face any discipline penalties, including employment termination, for killing Mr. Trawick in his home while he was cooking, on the night of April 14, 2019. "This is unbelievable - her decision to not allow oral closing arguments came out of left field and is another roadblock to the truth coming out, just as the truth is starting to see sunlight,” said Ellen and Rickie Trawick, parents of Kawaski Trawick. “Today's testimony was damning - the head of the NYPD investigation had to admit that they didn't ask any follow-up questions when Thompson and Davis' lies contradicted the video in their interviews. It seems like the judge is trying to help the NYPD hide their wrongdoing - I feel like we're watching an NYPD cover-up in real-time. We traveled here with Kawaski's sisters, our daughters, to be at the trial and we're finally getting at some facts with the testimony but it seems like this judge is trying to protect Thompson and Davis when what's happening in the trial room is showing they need to be fired." On April 14, 2019, Kawaski Trawick locked himself out of his apartment while he was cooking. The fire department let Mr. Trawick back into his apartment without incident. Mr. Trawick was cooking in his home after the situation had been resolved when NYPD Officers Thompson and Davis illegally entered Mr. Trawick’s apartment by using a baton to break the chain on his door and killed him in 112 seconds. After tasing and shooting Mr. Trawick, neither of the officers attempted to administer emergency medical aid. They held the door to Kawaski’s apartment closed, and waited before checking on him, leaving Mr. Trawick to bleed out on the floor for several minutes before medical personnel arrived. The NYPD investigation into Kawaski’s killing and the subsequent trial process has been mired in years of cover-ups, delays and obstruction. Today’s decision by Rosemarie Maldonado, the NYPD judge presiding over the case is yet another example of the obstacles Kawaski’s family has had to face in their pursuit of basic accountability for their son. "Not allowing oral closing arguments is another way to prevent closure for this family," said Royce Russell, attorney for the Trawicks. "Once again, the NYPD is working in a vacuum and acting like they aren't accountable to anyone. This lack of humanity must stop." Just today, a ProPublica investigative piece detailed the lengths to which the officers and the NYPD went to hide misconduct and protect themselves from any sort of accountability. The piece and the newly-revealed investigative files make clear that both officers were interviewed for only 30 minutes each during the course of the NYPD’s almost-two year investigation and were not questioned about their clear violations of NYPD protocol, false and misleading statements they made in their interviews or statements made that contradicted video evidence. NYPD body camera video shows that Officer Herbert Davis used his baton to break the chain on Kawaski Trawick’s door within seconds of their arrival, gaining illegal entry to his apartment. Files released today by ProPublica show that Davis and Thompson were never questioned about this act in NYPD's interviews of them. "It's been four years of obstruction and cover-ups and this latest decision by the judge is another slap in the face to Kawaski's family and New Yorkers,” said Loyda Colon, Executive Director of the Justice Committee and member of Communities United for Police Reform. “Today we heard the head of the investigation get questioned about why the NYPD's interviews of Thompson and Davis didn't ask basic questions, why false statements weren't contradicted or challenged during their official interviews and why there was no mention in the official report of instances where their actions were against their training and NYPD protocol - and he had no answers. We also heard from a former assistant chief of police who testified that Thompson and Davis acted outside of their training and against NYPD and police procedures. This was all damning and the NYPD is once again trying to bury the truth - the fact that the NYPD judge made the decision tonight to side with the cops' lawyers and block the CCRB from being able to summarize all of the misconduct and reasons these officers should be fired in oral closing arguments is about shielding not only Thompson and Davis from consequences, but the NYPD overall - it's hard to see this as anything other than part of an ongoing cover-up. The Trawicks deserve better and so do New Yorkers. The judge and NYPD should reverse this decision and allow oral closing arguments in addition to written summations as she said she would do last week." The Adams administration has continued with de Blasio-era delays and obstruction. At a pre-trial conference last month, the NYPD changed the dates of the trial because Deputy Chief Kevin M. Maloney, an NYPD official who wasn’t a witness to the killing, but will testify on the officer’s behalf, scheduled vacation during the original trial dates -- even though the dates were confirmed last year. As a result, the trial was interrupted by a two-week adjournment after the majority of the prosecution’s case - giving the defense more time to prepare. At the same hearing, the CCRB reported that the NYPD still hadn’t turned all requested files over. Last month, on the four-year anniversary of Kawaski’s killing, Rosemarie Maldonado, the NYPD judge presiding over the case, unilaterally initiated consideration of a last-minute, pre-trial dismissal of one of multiple misconduct charges substantiated in 2021. Maldonado set a deadline of the following business day for written filings and rejected CCRB’s request for oral arguments and then took the unprecedented move to dismiss the illegal entry charge, just days before the trial - but was forced to walk that back when the trial started because of her lack of authority to dismiss a CCRB charge. The illegal entry charge is formally still part of the trial. If found guilty of the misconduct charges, the officers may face disciplinary penalties up to, and including termination due to the seriousness of the misconduct. Mr. Trawick was a Black gay man, a son, and a brother pursuing his dreams as a dancer, aerobics, and fitness instructor in New York City before those dreams and his life was cut short at the hands of NYPD Officers Thompson and Davis. Judge Maldonado has signaled that regardless of how much time might be required for testimony, the trial will conclude tomorrow. ###
- Under Adams & Sewell, CCRB Unable to Investigate NYPD Racial Profiling Complaints
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE - Thursday May 11, 2023 MEDIA CONTACTS Eliel Cruz, press@justicecommittee.org In response to the Civilian Complaint Review Board’s announcement that Mayor Adams’ proposed FY24 budget will force them to refer their racial profiling cases back to the NYPD, the Justice Committee released the following statement from Executive Director Loyda Colon: The Mayor’s proposal to further defund the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB), after imposing crippling cuts last year, is yet another egregious example of his administration protecting abusive officers from discipline at the expense of safety and well-being for New Yorkers. The possibility that this will result in the referral of over 100 racial profiling and bias-based policing cases back to the NYPD is a slap in the face to the City Council, which voted to give the CCRB jurisdiction over such cases in 2021. If it is allowed to occur, it will further erode the already inadequate methods New Yorkers have to hold the NYPD accountable, opening the door to increased profiling and abuse. Between 2014 and 2021, before the CCRB had this jurisdiction, the NYPD investigated 3,480 bias and profiling complaints and substantiated a mere four of them. Currently - in a flagrant attempt to shield racist officers - the NYPD is actively impeding CCRB profiling investigations by withholding essential information. If the cases currently being investigated by the CCRB are referred back to the NYPD, they will go there and die. In the interest of public safety, the City Council must not approve an FY24 budget that forces profiling complaints back into the hands of the NYPD. Background: In 2021, the New York City Council voted to give the Civilian Complaint Review Board the power to investigate and prosecute civilian complaints of racial profiling and bias by NYPD officers, an expansion of their jurisdiction that went into effect last year. The CCRB’s FY23 budget is approximately 0.2% of the NYPD’s. Mayor Adams is proposing to cut this by another 2.3% for FY24*. The CCRB is currently investigating over 100 profiling complaints, but the investigations are stalled due to a lack of resources and because the NYPD refuses to provide comparative information regarding subject officers’ histories and patterns within their commands. *See: https://www.nyc.gov/assets/omb/downloads/pdf/erc4-23.pdf
- Charge Tossed in Case Against Cops Who Broke into Kawaski Trawick's Home & Killed Him
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE- Wednesday, April 20, 2023 MEDIA CONTACTS Kristine Mikkelsen, kmikkelsen@spitfirestrategies.com Eliel Cruz, press@justicecommittee.org Days Before Hearing Begins, Charge Tossed in Disciplinary Case Against NYPD Officers Who Broke into Home of Black Gay New Yorker and Killed Him With Latest Procedural Maneuver, NYPD Attempts to Evade Accountability in Kawaski Trawick Killing New York, NY – Yesterday – just days before the disciplinary hearing of two NYPD officers who killed a Black gay New Yorker in his own home is set to begin – an NYPD-appointed judge has tossed one of the charges. Despite a letter from 50 New York elected officials earlier this week urging the charges to stand and the hearing to be unimpeded, NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Trials, Rosemarie Maldonado – who is overseeing the discipline trial for NYPD Officers Brendan Thompson and Herbert Davis – took the unprecedented move of dismissing an illegal entry misconduct charge against both officers, days before the trial is set to begin. The illegal entry charge, one of multiple misconduct charges against Thompson and Davis related to their killing of Kawaski Trawick, was substantiated two years ago by the Civilian Complaint Review Board. All other misconduct charges, including those related to use of force, abuse of authority and failure to render medical aid continue to stand against the officers and will be heard during the discipline trial, scheduled to begin at 10 am on Monday, April 24, 2023, at 1 Police Plaza. If found guilty of the remaining misconduct charges, the officers may face disciplinary penalties up to, and including termination due to the seriousness of the misconduct. There is substantial doubt that Maldonado has the authority for the unprecedented move to dismiss the illegal entry charges in a CCRB-prosecuted case, days before the discipline trial’s start. Based on a 2012 Memorandum of Understanding between the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) and the NYPD, which governs discipline proceedings prosecuted by the CCRB, only the Police Commissioner can take such an action, and only in particular circumstances which do not apply in this case: “Such instances shall be limited to such cases in which there are parallel or related criminal investigations, or when, in the case of an officer with no disciplinary history or prior substantiated CCRB complaints, based on such officer’s record and disciplinary history the interests of justice would not be served.” Further, the MOU requires Police Commissioner Sewell to notify the CCRB of such action in writing and then give the CCRB five business days to respond. No such notification has been made by the NYPD Commissioner and the MOU process appears to have been violated. Loyda Colon, the Executive Director of Justice Committee and a member of Communities United for Police Reform stated: “NYPD administrative judges have much more leeway to make these kinds of calls in proceedings that aren’t prosecuted by CCRB - Maldonado had no such authority here and what she did was a clear violation of the MOU between CCRB and NYPD. It’s possible that Maldonado doesn’t even realize she’s violating the process because it’s so rare for NYPD officers to face administrative trials for killing New Yorkers, and even rarer for CCRB to be the prosecuting party. No matter what, the NYPD Commissioner will have the final say after the trial on what discipline Thompson and Davis will face, so the least they can do is let the trial proceed with all of the substantiated charges. Mayor Adams should immediately correct this miscarriage of justice and order the NYPD to allow the illegal misconduct charge to be heard during the trial that starts on Monday.” Colon worked closely with the mothers of Eric Garner and Ramarley Graham to help navigate the NYPD’s opaque disciplinary process and lead the campaigns to fire the officers who killed their sons. After hearing yesterday that the NYPD was planning to drop one of the charges, Kawaski Trawick’s mother released the following statement: “I’m disgusted and heartbroken that once again the NYPD has put up another roadblock to accountability for my son,” said Ellen Trawick, mother of Kawaski Trawick. “They act like this is a game, but I feel like they’re murdering Kawaski all over again. This doesn't even make any sense that they would toss charges that have been standing for two years, just days before the trial is supposed to begin. They're trying to say our eyes are lying but the video is clear – Kawaski was cooking in his home when Davis used his baton to break the chain holding Kawaski’s door to illegally enter, and then they murdered my son in 112 seconds. Maldonado, the NYPD and Mayor Adams should be ashamed and should correct this miscarriage of justice immediately. We won't stop fighting until Brendan Thompson & Herbert Davis are fired and they're no longer a threat to the city Kawaski loved." ###
- DAY 1: #FireThompsonAndDavis for Kawaski Trawick Trial
Trial Summary 04/24/23 Discipline trial of NYPD Officers Brendan Thompson and Herbert Davis for their 2019 killing of Kawaski Trawick [1] 1 Police Plaza, New York Monday April 24th 2023 was the first day of the discipline trial for Offers Brendan Thompson (Case #23558) and Herbert Davis (Case #23559). Thompson and Davis are being prosecuted by the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) for multiple charges of misconduct in their killing of Kawaski Trawick on April 14, 2019. The judge for the case is NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado. CCRB attorneys were: Andre Applewhite and Brian Arthur. Officer Thompson is represented by police union attorney Michael Martinez and Officer Davis is represented by Richard Murray. Day 1 of the trial included a procedural matter, opening statements and submission of exhibits into evidence. SUMMARY In attendance : Kawaski Trawick’s parents, Ellen and Rickie Trawick , were joined by supporters inside the trial room - including Gwen Carr , the mother of Eric Garner who was killed by NYPD in 2014; Iris Baez, the mother of Anthony Baez, who was killed by NYPD Officer Francis Livoti’s chokehold in 1994; Trawick family attorney Royce Russell and organizations that helped to pack the court included: Justice Committee, VOCAL-NY, Showing Up for Racial Justice (SURJ) and others. Procedural matter: The CCRB attorneys raised and objected to Judge Maldonado’s unilateral and improper decision last week to try to dismiss the illegal entry charge from the case. Despite a heated exchange in the first half-hour of the trial between Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado and the CCRB regarding Maldonado’s last-minute attempt at a pre-trial dismissal of one of multiple misconduct charges, all charges against the officers will be heard. Judge Maldonado initiated an exchange related to the statute of limitations for most formal disciplinary charges, stating that they had expired on 10/14/20, the extended statute of limitations (due to COVID-19) expired on 5/31/21, and that the CCRB voted on whether to file charges on 6/9/21. Thompson and Davis were served on 10/20/21 by the NYPD [2] . Judge Maldonado stated that “The statute of limitations had already expired before the CCRB decided to file charges in this case” and that a “crime exception” is needed because the statute of limitations ran out. Judge Maldonado and the CCRB lawyer went back-and-forth on this topic, and the judge called a break. Following a prolonged recess after the courtroom tensions, the Deputy Commissioner made clear that she intends to recommend dismissal of an illegal entry charge over the CCRB’s objections, in spite of the fact that no evidence had yet been entered into the record. Maldonado stated she would no longer be reading her motion to dismiss into the record as she had planned to do before the recess, and based on CCRB’s request stated on the record that CCRB had requested body camera footage in June 2019 but the NYPD did not turn video over to CCRB until January 2021. Following this, the CCRB and the lawyers for Thompson and Davis presented oral arguments. Opening Statements: CCRB argued that Thompson and Davis ignored their training in de-escalation, provoked Mr. Trawick by trespassing and assaulting him, and then neglected to provide medical aid. The CCRB lawyers told the story of what happened that day in April 2019, and said that the crimes included unlawful entry, assault with gun and taser (none of which can be called self-defense), reckless endangerment in not providing Kawaski Trawick with any aid, and violating the patrol guide. The PBA lawyer for Thompson argued that Thompson has already been exonerated, after fully being investigated by the Bronx DA who is the ruling authority on the criminal aspect. “If he weren’t here, he’d be on trial - excuse me - he’d be on patrol.” The lawyer stated that this is a “political prosecution” and that Kawaski was “cunning” in calling 911 to gain entry to his apartment. The lawyer for Thompson also falsely claimed that Thompson was in fear for his life and that Kawaski threatened to kill him, and that it was an “unfortunate experience” that doesn’t rise to the level of administrative or criminal misconduct. Murray, the lawyer for Davis argued that Davis lives in the Bronx, and that no aid could be provided because a fatal shot was fired [3] . He also argued that EMS was in the building (stating first that they came within two minutes, then within “roughly four”). He also argued that this was “only a police patrol guide violation” and the criminal exception for the statute of limitations has to be based on the underlying misconduct. CCRB Case: The CCRB then began its case by submitting exhibits 1-18: body-worn camera footage, surveillance camera footage, a video created by Bronx DA, OME autopsy report, photos of bullet wounds and taser prong, NYPD force investigation report, audio of radio transmission on 4/14/19, transcript of audio, Thompson and Davis’ training transcripts, modules, and certification records. They also played the video made by the Bronx DA in its entirety, the body-worn camera footage of Thompson, and the audio. The trial was adjourned to tomorrow (Tuesday April 25th), when the medical examiner is expected to testify. Press availability The Trawicks are holding daily mid-day availabilities with the press for the duration of the trial. Today’s availability was MCed by Justice Committee’s executive director, Loyda Colon. In addition to the Trawicks, other speakers included: Gwen Carr, the mother of Eric Garner; Council Member Pierina Sanchez; Royce Russell, the Trawick family’s attorney. Others in attendance included: Iris Baez, mother of Anthony Baez; Joshua Lopez, nephew of John Collado; Council Member Tiffany Caban; Housing Works; VOCAL-NY; Equality for Flatbush; Anti-Violence Project; and SURJ. [1] Although NYPD had the authority to charge and prosecute Thompson and Davis (as they do with all officers), they did not. This trial of Thompson and Davis would not be happening if CCRB had not substantiated misconduct charges and if community groups and the Trawicks hadn’t kept organizing for the firing of these officers. NYPD Commissioner Keechant Sewell’s decision regarding what Thompson and Davis’ discipline will be (if any discipline) will happen after the disciplinary trial – and could take days to months. Sewell’s decision could be to implement what Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado recommends, or she can make the penalty less or more than recommended. [2] NYPD regularly delays serving formal misconduct charges on officers whose charges are substantiated by the NYPD, as was the case here. [3] There is no way officers would have known that the shots were fatal. Thompson and Davis made no attempt to provide any aid after shooting Kawaski Trawick. ###
- DAY 2: #FireThompsonAndDavis for Kawaski Trawick Trial
Trial Summary: Tuesday April 25, 2023 1 Police Plaza, New York CCRB disciplinary prosecution of Officers Brendan Thompson and Herbert Davis for their killing of Kawaski Trawick[1] Tuesday April 25 was the second day of the NYPD disciplinary trial of Officers Brendan Thompson and Herbert Davis, related to charges substantiated by the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) for their killing of Kawaski Trawick on April 14, 2019. The NYPD refused to substantiate misconduct and hid the full video from the public until 20 months after the killing. CCRB substantiated multiple charges against the officers in 2021; NYPD delayed formal “serving” of those charges until late 2021. In spite of four years of cover-ups, obstruction and delays[2], the discipline trial began on Monday April 24, 2023 – more than 4 years after Kawaski was killed. Day 2 of the trial included 1 witness, called by CCRB: Dr. Terra A. Cederroth, Deputy Chief Medical Examiner, who oversees Manhattan and parts of the Bronx for the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner and performed the autopsy of Kawaski Trawick. Highlights from witness testimony and cross examination Brian Arthur (CCRB prosecutor) took testimony from Dr. Cederroth, including: Dr. Cederroth reported Trawick’s cause of death as gunshot wounds to the torso. One bullet entered from Kawaski’s upper left back, fracturing ribs, lunch ang heart. A second bullet entered from the right side of Kawaski’s chest, fracturing ribs and grazing the right lung and diaphragm, going through the liver and lodged in the back. The wound in his upper left back was more significant because the bullet hit both the heart and the lung. There were scrapes on the inside of the upper right arm, aligned with scrapes on the right torso at the same level of the chest entrance wound, indicating that Trawick’s right arm was held close to his body when he was shot. (This also indicates that he was not a threat to officers when shot.) When asked, Dr. Cederroth stated that Trawick’s chance of survival could have been increased if chest compressions or other medical assistance had been performed. Dr. Cederroth also described the impact of a taser on the human body: it delivers 50,000 volts of electricity to the body and causes uncontrollable muscle contractions, causing a person to fall. There was a small amount of methamphetamine in Trawick’s body when he died. Richard Murray, attorney for Officer Herbert Davis cross-examined Dr. Cederroth. Mr. Murray asked Dr. Cederroth about the severity of the gunshot wounds, their ability to cause death and at what rate, and Trawick’s chances of survival without surgical intervention. Dr. Cederroth stated her opinion that Trawick could have died within minutes even with surgical intervention. Following questioning of the medical examiner, court was adjourned until Thursday May 11th.[3] In attendance, Day 2 Kawaski Trawick’s parents, Ellen and Rickie Trawick, were joined by supporters inside the trial room - including Iris Baez, the mother of Anthony Baez, who was killed by NYPD Officer Francis Livoti’s chokehold in 1994. Livoti was fired by the NYPD and prosecuted by the federal Department of Justice for violating Anthony’s civil rights. Livoti was convicted and sentenced on federal charges for the killing of Anthony Baez – and is the only NYPD officer in the past several decades who was prosecuted or convicted by DOJ. Organizations that came out to support included: Justice Committee, Showing Up for Racial Justice (SURJ) and others. Press availability The Trawicks are holding daily mid-day availabilities with the press for the duration of the trial. Today’s availability was MCd by Justice Committee’s executive director, Loyda Colon. In addition to the Trawicks, other speakers included: Royce Russell, the Trawick family’s attorney; Iris Baez, mother of Anthony Baez; and Council Member Tiffany Caban. [1] Although NYPD had the authority to charge and prosecute Thompson and Davis (as they do with all officers), they did not. This trial of Thompson and Davis would not be happening if CCRB had not substantiated misconduct charges and if community groups and the Trawicks hadn’t kept organizing for the firing of these officers. NYPD Commissioner Keechant Sewell’s decision regarding what Thompson and Davis’ discipline will be (if any discipline) will happen after the disciplinary trial – and could take days to months. Sewell’s decision could be to implement what Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado recommends, or she can make the penalty less or more than recommended. [2] Over the past four years, through two mayoral administrations and three police commissioners, there’s been a series of cover-ups, delays and obstruction, preventing the public from knowing about Kawaski Trawick and to shield the officers from being fired. This includes: when Kawaski was first killed, the de Blasio administration refused to immediately release the names of officers; Kawaski Trawick was killed before COVID but the NYPD didn’t release footage for 20 months only after being forced to by a lawsuit – this was well into the second year of the pandemic and after national protests for the killing of George Floyd. [3] The Adams administration has continued with de Blasio-era delays and obstruction. At a pre-trial conference this month, the NYPD changed the dates of the trial because an NYPD official who wasn’t a witness to the killing, but will testify on the officer’s behalf, will be on vacation during the original trial dates -- in spite of the dates being confirmed since last year. As a result, the trial will be interrupted by a two-week adjournment after the majority of the prosecution’s case - giving the defense more time to prepare and disadvantaging the CCRB’s prosecution. ###
- [The City] Cops Who Killed Kawaski Trawick Should be Fired, His Parents Say Before Trial
Ahead of the disciplinary trial of two NYPD officers who shot and killed a 32-year-old man in his own apartment four years ago, the parents of victim Kawaski Trawick on Wednesday called on city leaders to terminate the cops. Trawick was in his own apartment within a supportive housing building in The Bronx on April 14, 2019, when one of the officers fired a Taser at him before shooting four times — all within two minutes of pushing the front door open to gain entry. “[Officers] Brendan Thompson and Herbert Davis took Kawaski away from me — they murdered him,” said Kawaski’s mother, Ellen Trawick, during a news conference outside police headquarters in Lower Manhattan. She was joined by Ricky Trawick, his father. “We need Mayor Adams and Commissioner Sewell to fire these two officers.” The Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) is prosecuting the administrative trial of the two officers, which begins April 24 at One Police Plaza. If found guilty, the cops could face disciplinary measures ranging from a loss of vacation days to termination. Read More
- [Gay City News] Trawick family blasts reports of dropped charge against officers before disciplinary
One of the misconduct charges against the officers involved in the fatal 2019 police shooting of 32-year-old gay man Kawaski Trawick was dropped just days before the beginning of a disciplinary trial in the case. Trawick’s parents — who traveled to New York fr0m Georgia last week to rally at NYPD headquarters — said they learned through the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) that NYPD deputy commissioner of trials Rosemarie Maldonado dropped the charge related to illegal entry, though other charges remain. The NYPD did not respond to Gay City News’ request for comment on April 20 — just four days before both officers are slated to begin their respective trials on April 24. In a written statement to Gay City News, the CCRB criticized the dropped charge. “We strongly disagree with the decision,” a CCRB spokesperson said. “Deputy Commissioner Maldonado overstepped her authority and we are exploring all our options.” New York City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams responded to the news by describing the dropped charge as “an outrageous subversion of civilian oversight for police misconduct” that “bypasses and undermines the established process of a scheduled disciplinary trial for actions that led to the killing of a New Yorker.” .............. Justice Committee, an organization supporting the family, suggested in a press release that a 2012 Memorandum of Understanding involving the CCRB and NYPD stipulates that decisions to drop charges should come from the police commissioner except in “cases in which there are parallel or related criminal investigations, or when, in the case of an officer with no disciplinary history or prior substantiated CCRB complaints, based on such officer’s record and disciplinary history the interests of justice would not be served.” Read More
- [City Limits] The NYPD’s Abuse of Sealed Arrest Records Jeopardizes All New Yorkers
In 2012, co-author Natasha Duncan’s sister, Shantel Davis, was shot to death by the NYPD. As Natasha’s family roiled in shock and tried to grieve this devastating loss, the NYPD illegally leaked information about Shantel’s arrest history—much of which was sealed—in a transparent attempt to turn the public against her. In life and in death, the NYPD found ways to illegally target and violate Shantel. Natasha’s experience is not unusual; the NYPD routinely gives the press sealed information when it suits their political purposes. Last August, the city held a press conference about a report that included the sealed records information of 10 New Yorkers in violation of a court order. The Court later ruled it was a violation of the law, but the damage was already done. It is high time that the NYPD be required to change. Its unlawful use of these records has primarily harmed Black and brown New Yorkers who bear the brunt of the NYPD’s over-policing of low-income communities of color. Read More
- [News 12] New Yorkers demand more details on how NYPD chooses who to stop
New Yorkers rallied outside of City Hall Monday to call on the City Council to pass a new legislation that would require the NYPD to provide more transparency in its stopping practices. Advocates and supporters of the How Many Stops Act say that the two bills would make the NYPD’s process of who they choose to stop and why they choose to stop more accessible to the average New Yorker. The parents of the late Antonio Williams, who was killed in September 2019 during a confrontation that also led to the death of Officer Brian Mulkeen, joined advocates at today’s rally. “So many times people are killed by the police… and it’s their word against nobody, because nobody is speaking for the victim,” said Shawn Williams, father of Antonio. Investigators say that Antonio Williams was stopped by plainclothes officers who believed he was suspicious, leading to the altercation. Williams’ parents say their son would still be alive if the laws being supported today were in place back then. Read More
- Discipline trial begins against NYPD officers who killed Black gay man in his own home
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE- Monday, April 24, 2023 MEDIA CONTACTS Kristine Mikkelsen, kmikkelsen@spitfirestrategies.com Eliel Cruz, press@justicecommittee.org, On Monday, April 24, the discipline trial against NYPD Officers Brendan Thompson and Herbert Davis for the killing of Kawaski Trawick began. The trial will determine whether the officers will face any discipline penalties, including employment termination, for killing Mr. Trawick in his home while he was cooking, on the night of April 14, 2019. Despite a heated exchange in the first half-hour of the trial between Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado and the Civilian Complaint Review Board regarding a last-minute attempt initiated by Maldonado for a pre-trial dismissal of one of multiple misconduct charges, all charges against the officers will be heard. Following a prolonged recess after the courtroom tensions, the Deputy Commissioner made clear that she intends to recommend dismissal of an illegal entry charge over the CCRB’s objections and before any evidence was entered into the record. Maldonado stated she would no longer be reading her motion to dismiss into the record as she had planned to do before the recess, and based on CCRB’s request stated on the record that CCRB had requested body camera footage in 2019 but the NYPD did not turn video over to CCRB until 2021. Following this, the CCRB and the lawyers for Thompson and Davis presented oral arguments. "Today we heard Thompson and Davis' lawyers spew Disney-level fantasies contradicted by the video and common sense," said Loyda Colon, Executive Director of the Justice Committee and member of Communities United for Police Reform. "The facts are clear - Thompson and Davis illegally entered Kawaski's home, tased and shot him four times without justification - all within 112 seconds and made no attempt to help save his life. It's good that the CCRB made clear today that the NYPD trial judge doesn't have the authority to try to toss the charge at this stage but it's outrageous that at every turn the NYPD has tried to obstruct accountability." "My son Kawaski was never a threat and the video shows that Thompson and Davis created a crisis and murdered my son," said Ellen Trawick, mother of Kawaski Trawick. "I'm very concerned that the NYPD judge is acting like she's a lawyer for the police who murdered my son - she basically said she was going to recommend the illegal entry charge be dismissed even before any evidence was introduced in the trial today. The video shows Herbert Davis use his baton to break the chain on Kawaski's door - that was an illegal entry that anyone can see." On April 14, 2019, Kawaski Trawick locked himself out of his apartment while he was cooking. The fire department let Mr. Trawick back into his apartment without incident. Mr. Trawick was cooking in his home after the situation had been resolved when NYPD Officers Thompson and Davis illegally entered Mr. Trawick’s apartment by using a baton to break the chain on his door, and killed him in 112 seconds. After tasing and shooting Mr. Trawick, neither of the officers attempted to administer emergency medical aid. They closed the door to Kawaski’s apartment, then stood outside, leaving Mr. Trawick to bleed out on the floor. "Thompson and Davis should have been fired four years ago," said Rickie Trawick, father of Kawaski Trawick. "It was very hard to listen to lies from Thompson and Davis' lawyers, it's almost like they're trying to murder my son all over again." When Kawaski was first killed, the de Blasio administration refused to immediately release the names of officers. Kawaski Trawick was killed before COVID but the NYPD didn’t release footage for 20 months - well into the second year of the pandemic, only after being forced to by a lawsuit. While the NYPD refused to substantiate misconduct charges against the officers, the Civilian Complaint Review Board substantiated multiple charges against both Thompson and Davis in June of 2021. The NYPD formally served the CCRB charges on the officers in October 2021. The Adams administration has continued with de Blasio-era delays and obstruction. At a pre-trial conference this month, the NYPD changed the dates of the trial because an NYPD official who wasn’t a witness to the killing, but will testify on the officer’s behalf, will be on vacation during the original trial dates -- even though the dates were confirmed last year. As a result, the trial will be interrupted by a two-week adjournment after the majority of the prosecution’s case - giving the defense more time to prepare. At the same hearing, the CCRB reported that the NYPD still hadn’t turned all requested files over. A week ago, on the four-year anniversary of Kawaski’s killing, the NYPD decided they wanted to consider a last-minute, pre-trial dismissal of one of multiple misconduct charges substantiated in 2021. NYPD set a deadline of the following business day for written filings and rejected CCRB’s request for oral arguments. Despite this legal maneuvering, all substantiated charges will currently be heard. Mr. Trawick was a Black gay man, a son, and a brother pursuing his dreams as a dancer, aerobics, and fitness instructor in New York City before those dreams and his life was cut short at the hands of NYPD Officers Thompson and Davis.







![[The City] Cops Who Killed Kawaski Trawick Should be Fired, His Parents Say Before Trial](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/f8a96d_e5d2c7796d344769a07570dad8ad9d47~mv2.webp/v1/fit/w_176,h_124,q_80,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,blur_3,enc_auto/f8a96d_e5d2c7796d344769a07570dad8ad9d47~mv2.webp)
![[Gay City News] Trawick family blasts reports of dropped charge against officers before disciplinary](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/f8a96d_b0fa83b289ca42bbbef5ac33cb392032~mv2.jpg/v1/fit/w_176,h_124,q_80,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,blur_3,enc_auto/f8a96d_b0fa83b289ca42bbbef5ac33cb392032~mv2.jpg)
![[City Limits] The NYPD’s Abuse of Sealed Arrest Records Jeopardizes All New Yorkers](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/f8a96d_0eb5dbf4e78d4f56923e8ab926b710e5~mv2.jpg/v1/fit/w_176,h_124,q_80,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,blur_3,enc_auto/f8a96d_0eb5dbf4e78d4f56923e8ab926b710e5~mv2.jpg)
![[News 12] New Yorkers demand more details on how NYPD chooses who to stop](https://static.wixstatic.com/media/f8a96d_0976499feec8412488edacd5ba21c977~mv2.jpg/v1/fit/w_176,h_124,q_80,usm_0.66_1.00_0.01,blur_3,enc_auto/f8a96d_0976499feec8412488edacd5ba21c977~mv2.jpg)