top of page

Search Results

Search this site

419 results found with an empty search

  • A Letter from NYS + NYC Electeds to Commissioner Tisch & Mayor Adams: Serve CCRB-Substantiated Charges on Officers who Killed Win Rozario "Without Delay or Obstruction"

    September 18, 2025 Mayor Eric Adams City Hall New York, NY 10007 NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch 1 Police Plaza New York, NY 10038 RE: Discipline Proceedings Against Officers Alongi & Cianfrocco for Killing Win Rozario Dear Commissioner Tisch and Mayor Adams, This coming September 27, 2025 will mark 18 months since NYPD Officers Salvatore Alongi & Matthew Cianfrocco killed Bangladeshi teenager Win Rozario in his home, in front of his mother and younger brother. While the officers acted chaotically, Win’s mother tried to protect him from the officers, pleading “don’t shoot” in spite of her limited English proficiency. Alongi & Cianfrocco killed Win in less than two minutes of their arrival to the family’s apartment. Instead of following their training and NYPD protocols, Alongi & Cianfrocco repeatedly exacerbated the crisis they created. They recklessly shot Win five times and tased him multiple times – including when he had nothing in his hands -- while endangering the lives of Win’s mother and younger brother in the process. Following the shooting, the NYPD refused to let Win’s mother and younger brother accompany him to the hospital – forcing them to be interrogated without counsel, instead of being by Win’s side. Following the interrogations, Win’s parents and brother were forced to find somewhere to stay while the NYPD blocked them from being able to retrieve medications, clothes or their cat from their home. Win’s family was not allowed to return to their home for days and the NYPD refused to even allow someone to feed their cat during this time.** **More information about the incident and mistreatment of Win’s family can be found in the letter  Win’s family sent to you both in June and Win’s mother’s Daily News op-ed . Last week, the board of the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) substantiated misconduct against both officers and recommended “charges and specifications” – the highest class of discipline against officers, reflecting the seriousness of misconduct. The CCRB has filed the relevant charges and specifications with the NYPD. It is now incumbent on the NYPD to serve the CCRB’s charges on the officers, in order to formally commence disciplinary proceedings. As elected officials who are committed to safety and justice, we urge you to ensure that there is no obstruction or delay in serving the CCRB’s charges on Officers Alongi & Cianfrocco. We ask that you ensure that the CCRB-substantiated charges are served on Alongi & Cianfrocco by Friday, September 26, 2025 so that they are served within the 18-month statute of limitations (SOL) deadline, as outlined in section 75 of NYS civil service law. – and so that the CCRB can move forward with the discipline proceeding against the officers. While it is possible to serve “charges and specifications” on officers after 18 months under section 75’s “crime exception”, such delays create unnecessary and unfair hurdles for pursuing fair accountability of police misconduct. The NYPD has a notorious history of delaying and obstructing discipline against officers who kill New Yorkers, including in the cases of Eric Garner, Kawaski Trawick and Allan Feliz. This has included the NYPD delaying the conclusion of NYPD force investigation division’s (FID) investigations, delaying service of charges on officers for months and sometimes even over a year, threatening to take over CCRB-investigated cases, and most recently overturning the NYPD’s own trial judge’s determination to fire the officer who killed Allan Feliz. We hope that the NYPD refrains from further delays and obstruction with respect to the officers who killed Win Rozario. We are disappointed that for the 18 months since he was killed, Win’s family says they have received no updates on the FID investigation – in spite of the fact that Mayor Adams has previously proclaimed that NYPD investigations regarding police killings would conclude within six months. For over a month after Win Rozario was killed, the NYPD blocked transparency, refusing to release the names of the officers involved. Alongi and Cianfrocco’s names were first publicly identified by the Attorney General’s Office when they released officer body camera footage on May 3, 2024. Mayor Adams’ first and only public statements regarding the killing were issued only after the AG released body camera footage, over five weeks after Win was killed, when he was questioned by press. At this time, Mayor Adams falsely claimed that he had reached out to the family after the incident. We know that Commissioner Tisch was not the NYPD commissioner when Win was killed, however we’re concerned that the family has not heard any substantive response to their June 2025 letter inquiring about the FID investigation, in spite of multiple attempts to follow-up. While the family has no idea whether the FID ever completed their investigation, they do know that the CCRB did and that the CCRB’s board followed the facts to substantiate eight allegations of misconduct (four against each officer, including excessive force and abuse of authority) that have since been filed with the NYPD. Our request is simple: Since the CCRB was able to complete their investigation and their board substantiated charges with sufficient time for the NYPD to serve CCRB’s charges on the officers within the 18-month timeframe, we respectfully request that you ensure that the CCRB’s charges are served on time, without delay or obstruction – by Friday September 26, 2025. We know that the NYPD has the ability to serve charges on officers within 1-2 days of filing. There is no reasonable justification to fail to serve the CCRB-substantiated charges on Alongi and Cianfrocco by September 26th. The NYPD Commissioner still has the power to make the final decision on disciplinary outcomes. We urge you to not play politics to unfairly shield officers from disciplinary proceedings. We call on you to allow the CCRB disciplinary prosecution of these officers to move forward without delay or obstruction , so that New Yorkers and Win’s family do not have to wait another year for closure and action. Sincerely, New York City Public Advocate Jumaane Williams New York City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams Queens Borough President Donovan Richards Brooklyn Borough President Antonio Reynoso Senator Jabari Brisport, Senate District 25 Senator Cordell Cleare, Senate District 30 Senator Natalia Fernandez, Senate District 34 Senator Kristen Gonzalez, Senate District 59 Senator Brad Hoylman-Sigal, Senate District 47 Senator Robert Jackson, Senate District 31 Senator John Liu, Senate District 16 Senator Gustavo Rivera, Senate District 33 Senator Julia Salazar, Senate District 18 Assembly Member Harvey Epstein, Assembly District 74 Assembly Member Jessica González-Rojas, Assembly District 34 Assembly Member Steven Raga, Assembly District 30 Assembly Member Karines Reyes, Assembly District 87 Assembly Member Claire Valdez, Assembly District 37 Council Member Alexa Avilés, Council District 38 Council Member Chris Banks, Council District 42 Council Member Selvena Brooks-Powers, Council District 31 Council Member Tiffany Cabán, Council District 22 Council Member Carmen de la Rosa, Council District 10, co-vice chair of Progressive Caucus Council Member Jennifer Gutierrez, Council District 34, co-vice chair of Progressive Caucus Council Member Shahana Hanif, Council District 39, co-chair of Progressive Caucus Council Member Crystal Hudson, Council District 35, co-chair of NYC Council Black, Latino, Asian Caucus Council Member Rita Joseph, Council District 40 Council Member Shekar Krishnan, Council District 25 Council Member Farah N. Louis, Council District 45 Council Member Christopher Marte, Council District 1, vice co-chair of NYC Council Black, Latino, Asian Caucus Council Member Sandy Nurse, Council District 37, co-chair of Progressive Caucus Council Member Chi Ossé, Council District 36 Council Member Lincoln Restler, Council District 33 Council Member Kevin Riley, Council District 12, co-chair of NYC Council Black, Latino, Asian Caucus Council Member Pierina Sanchez, Council District 14 Council Member Althea Stevens, Council District 16, secretary of NYC Council Black, Latino, Asian Caucus Council Member Nantasha Williams, Council District 27, treasurer of NYC Council Black, Latino, Asian Caucus Council Member Julie Won, Council District 26, vice co-chair of NYC Council Black, Latino, Asian Caucus cc: Dr. Mohammad Khalil and Jonathan Darche, Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB)

  • A Letter from Win Rozario's Family to Tisch & Adams

    June 26, 2025 Mayor Eric Adams City Hall New York, NY 10007 NYPD Commissioner Tisch 1 Police Plaza New York, NY 10038 Re: Investigation & Discipline of NYPD Who Killed Bangladeshi Teen Win Rozario & Mistreated Our Family in Aftermath   Dear Mayor Adams and Commissioner Tisch, We are the parents and younger brother of Win Rozario, who was murdered in our home by NYPD Officers Salvatore Alongi and Matthew Cianfrocco  on March 27, 2024. We are writing to you in your capacities as mayor and police commissioner - the only two government officials who have the power to ensure that Alongi and Cianfrocco are fired, that other NYPD who were responsible for mistreating our family after Win was killed are publicly identified and disciplined, and that police are removed from mental health response protocols in New York City.  We’re also writing to you in your capacity as parents - to urge you to treat us as you would wish to be treated if your child was recklessly and unjustly killed in front of you, in what should have been the safety of your home, by NYPD officers . We can’t imagine that you would be okay with the mistreatment, disrespect, and disregard that we’ve had to endure. Next week marks what should have been Win’s 21st birthday . Instead of celebrating with him, we will be mourning him. It has been 15 months of lies, obstruction, and inaction from your administration  since Win was killed in our home. In case you need to be reminded, here are some  facts: If Alongi and Cianfrocco had not come to our home, Win would be alive today. One of the first things they did when they got to our house was refer to Win as “schizo”, offensive language that reveals their discriminatory attitude towards people with mental health challenges. They immediately created a crisis upon arrival that they repeatedly escalated, chose to bark orders and draw their guns instead of de-escalating in spite of multiple opportunities, didn’t follow the NYPD’s own protocols, and shot Win at least five times in less than 2 minutes of entering our apartment. It’s a miracle we (Win’s mother and brother) weren’t also killed in the chaotic crisis that Alongi & Cianfrocco created.  After Win was killed, NYPD officers, whose names we still don’t know, refused to allow us (Win’s mother and younger brother) to go to the hospital with Win - instead forcing us to go to the precinct. We were interrogated individually, without counsel, and weren’t informed that Win was dead until afterwards. We didn’t even get to say goodbye.  Following this, the NYPD refused to allow our family to go back to our apartment for more than two days  - preventing us from getting medication and clothes or even feeding our cat. We were only allowed back in after Public Advocate Williams’ office intervened, demanding we be allowed back - and the NYPD and city left the apartment a mess with blood all over. In 15 months, we have received ZERO updates from Mayor Adams or the NYPD on the Force Investigation Division’s investigation into the murder of Win. Two months after Win was killed, Mayor Adams lied, claiming he had personally reached out to us . That never happened. The NYPD refused to release the names of the officers who killed Win and the mayor didn’t even bother to publicly acknowledge the killing of Win until after the Attorney General’s office released partial body camera footage. Mayor Adams’ response at the time was to release a short statement  that mis-spelled Win’s name and focused more on himself than on Win or our family. At a press availability soon after, the mayor falsely stated that discipline would have to wait until after the AG’s investigation concluded. This was also a lie  - there is no legal requirement to delay discipline.  There’s much more we can say about the NYPD misconduct and mistreatment of our family - some of it is here  in Win’s mom’s words in the Daily News, marking one-year without Win.  We’re writing to you because it’s unacceptable that your administration has given us no information about the FID investigation – and because of your inaction, Alongi & Cianfrocco are still being paid as police. 2024 payroll records show that in the year they killed Win, both Alongi and Cianfrocco took home close to $200,000 each in pay  - much higher than the prior year, and even though their base salaries are only $105,146 annually. This is corrupt and outrageous. Mayor Adams:  In 2024, you promised to resolve police-involved shootings within 6 months  - it’s been 15 months with no updates or resolution, and what seems like only lies, misdirection and disregard from you. Commissioner Tisch: As a more-recently appointed Police Commissioner, we know that you were not with the NYPD when Win was killed. You have stated that officers should be disciplined for misconduct. We need you to turn your immediate attention to this case - the killing of Win and the misconduct and mistreatment following the killing - and we need you to take immediate action towards firing Alongi and Cianfrocco.  We need action, not just words from both of you. Our requests : Make good on your words about accountability and ensure that Alongi & Cianfrocco are fired  for unjustly killing Win, for almost killing two of us (Win’s mother and brother), for not providing competent medical attention after shooting Win at least five times, and more. Alongi and Cianfrocco’s actions were unjustified, reckless and against the NYPD’s own protocols. They are a danger to New Yorkers and must be fired. Provide an update to us on the FID investigation  and the employment status of Alongi and Cianfrocco immediately. Fifteen months of silence and keeping us in the dark is unacceptable. You would not want your family to be treated this way if you were in our situation. Contact information for our representatives is included at the end of this letter.  Release the names of all officers and NYPD officials who were involved in our mistreatment  in the aftermath of Win being killed - and implement substantive discipline.  Mayor Adams : We are requesting a meeting with you, along with our team . We hope you will stop acting as if Win wasn’t killed under your watch, and agree to this as soon as possible.  To contact our representatives regarding the above requests, please reach out to the Justice Committee, who will coordinate with us directly and the rest of our team. We hope to hear from you as soon as possible.  Sincerely, Notan Eva Costa, mother of Win Rozario Francis Rozario, father of Win Rozario Utsho Rozario, brother of Win Rozario cc: NYS Attorney General Letitia James, Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, NYC Speaker Adrienne Adams, Civilian Complaint Review Board

  • Oversight Board Substantiates Charges Against Police Who Killed Bangladeshi Teen Win Rozario, while Mayor Adams & NYPD Commissioner Tisch Continue to Ignore Win’s Family

    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Friday September 12, 2025   MEDIA CONTACT Yul-san Liem, yul-san@justicecommittee.org Oversight Board Substantiates Charges Against Police Who Killed Bangladeshi Teen Win Rozario, while Mayor Adams & NYPD Commissioner Tisch Continue to Ignore Win’s Famil y Family renews calls for Attorney General to indict the officers and for the NYPD to fire them New York - On Wednesday September 10, 2025, the New York City Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) moved to substantiate numerous misconduct allegations against Officers Salvatore Alongi and Matthew Cianfrocco related to their killing of 19-year-old Win Rozario on March 27, 2024. The police review board substantiated a total of eight allegations of misconduct  - four allegations against each officer - including excessive force and abuse of authority. The CCRB also referred other possible misconduct for the NYPD to investigate, related to allegations that are outside the review board’s jurisdiction.  Officers Alongi and Cianfrocco tased Win multiple times and shot him five times in less than two minutes of their arrival at the family’s apartment, killing Win in front of his mother and younger brother.  The allegations substantiated by the CCRB’s board represent misconduct that requires “departmental charges and specifications” be served on the officers.  Departmental charges are the highest level of discipline recommended for the most serious instances of misconduct and initiate discipline proceedings that allow the CCRB to prosecute officers in an NYPD departmental discipline trial.  Officers Alongi and Cianfrocco face penalties up to termination. The NYPD Commissioner is authorized to make final decisions on officer discipline.  In response to news of the ruling, Win Rozario’s mother, Notan Eva Costa (she/her), released the following statement: "The past year and a half have been incredibly hard for me and my family. I still feel the trauma of Alongi and Cianfrocco murdering Win in front of me, and almost killing me and my other son too. There isn't a day that goes by that I don't miss my son. My heart is still broken. CCRB's decision gives us some relief in this moment that they understand that Win's life mattered and that Alongi and Cianfrocco are dangerous. That means something to us especially because Mayor Adams and Commissioner Tisch have continued to ignore us, not even responding to letters we hand-delivered and sent in June, and Attorney General James still hasn't indicted Alongi and Cianfrocco. We thank the CCRB for moving forward on disciplining Alongi and Cianfrocco, we thank those who have been supporting our family and we'll continue to fight to make sure Alongi and Cianfrocco are both fired as soon as possible so they can't hurt or murder any other New Yorkers."  Loyda Colon (they/them), Executive Director of the Justice Committee and a representative of the family shared: “The CCRB decision to bring fireable discipline charges against NYPD Officers Salvatore Alongi and Matthew Cianfrocco for recklessly murdering Win Rozario was the right and only acceptable decision that it could have made, but these officers should have already been charged and fired by Commissioner Tisch and the mayor and they should have already been indicted by Attorney General James. Firing cops for unjustly killing a teenager who was safe in his home until they arrived should not take this long, and we’re at an early step in the process. We’re demanding the NYPD serve the discipline charges immediately, instead of their usual tactic of stalling to shield the cops, as they have done with so many other cases.  Alongi and Cianfrocco must be fired and prosecuted without further delay.”  Simran Thind (she/they) , Organizer at Desis Rising Up & Moving (DRUM) and a representative of the family stated : "It is clear that the CCRB saw that Officers Alongi and Cianfrocco acted dangerously, violating the NYPD's own protocols, and they are rightfully moving forward on fireable charges against these officers. We are calling upon and demanding that Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch, who has the power to do the right thing, to make sure that these officers are fired so that no other New Yorker fears that their loved one could be harmed by Officers Alongi and Cianfrocco.”  Luna Droubi (she/her), partner with Beldock Levine & Hoffman, LLP stated: “It’s vindicating that the CCRB has substantiated claims against the officers who killed Win Rozario. It won’t bring Win back, but it is one step closer to the accountability needed to push change forward. The City of New York must stop sending police officers to mental health responses.” BACKGROUND Teenager Win Rozario was in his Ozone Park, Queens home when he was killed by NYPD Officers Salvatore Alongi and Matthew Cianfrocco on March 27, 2024, in front of his mother and younger brother. Officers Alongi and Cianfrocco created a crisis when they arrived and repeatedly escalated the situation, tasing and shooting 19-year-old Win at least five times within less than two minutes after entering the family’s apartment, unjustifiably killing the teen and risking the lives of Win’s mother and brother.   Immediately following the shooting, NYPD officers forced Win’s mother and younger brother to go to the precinct to be interrogated, preventing them from accompanying Win to the hospital. Ms. Costa was questioned at length without counsel before being told her son had died, and Win’s 17-year-old brother was also interrogated alone. NYPD officers blocked re-entry to the Rozario family’s home for more than two days, refusing the family’s requests to retrieve belongings, access medications, or even to have someone feed their cat.   For over a month after Win Rozario was killed, the NYPD blocked transparency, including refusing to release the names of the officers involved. Alongi and Cianfrocco’s names were first publicly identified by the Attorney General’s Office when they released officer body camera footage on May 3, 2024. Mayor Adams’ first and only public statements regarding the killing were issued only after the Attorney General released body camera footage, over five weeks after Win was killed, after he was questioned by reporters. At this point Mayor Adams falsely claimed that he had reached out to the family after the incident and that discipline would have to wait until after the Attorney General’s investigation concluded with a determination, which has never been accurate.   For the past year, Win Rozario’s family, along with the Justice Committee, Desis Rising Up & Moving, and others have called for the NYPD to fire – and for the NYS Attorney General to prosecute – NYPD officers Alongi and Cianfrocco. Win’s family is also calling for police to be removed from the city’s mental health response. Win Rozario’s mother wrote about the year since Win was killed and the NYPD’s mistreatment of her family in a March 2025 Daily News Op-Ed .    The NYPD’s Force Investigation Division (FID) is required to investigate the killing, but the family has received no information or updates from Mayor Adams or the NYPD about their mandated investigation since Win was killed in March of 2024. Mayor Adams has falsely claimed that the NYPD must wait until the Attorney General’s investigation has concluded before they can act on  discipline. The New York State Attorney General is also investigating the killing. ### About the Justice Committee: Since the 1980s, the Justice Committee (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice.  About Desis Rising Up & Moving: DRUM - Desis Rising Up & Moving is a multigenerational, membership led organization of low-wage South Asian and Indo-Caribbean immigrants, workers and youth in New York City. Founded in 2000, DRUM has mobilized and built the leadership of thousands of low-income, South Asian and Indo-Caribbean immigrants to lead social and policy change that impacts their own lives- from immigrant rights to education reform, racial justice, and worker’s justice.  Our membership of over 5,000 adults, youth, and families is multigenerational and represents the diaspora of the South Asian communities – Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Guyana, India, Nepal, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Suriname, Trinidad and Tobago, and beyond.  In over a decade, we have built a unique model of South Asian and Indo-Caribbean undocumented workers, women, and youth led organizing for rights and justice from the local to the global rooted in base building, leadership development, running short and long term campaigns to reform policies on all levels, strong cross-community alliances locally and nationally, and building democratic and mass participatory spaces.

  • [Hellgate] 'It Makes Us Feel Like the Trial Itself Was a Sham'

    In an interview, the brother of Allan Feliz talks about NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch's decision to keep the cop who killed Feliz on the force, even after the department's own trial judge said he should be fired. By Jessy Edwards, Hellgate In February, NYPD Administrative Judge Rosemarie Maldonado issued a rare ruling : She said police officer Jonathan Rivera should be fired for shooting and killing 31-year-old Allan Feliz on October 17, 2019, during a traffic stop.  For his family, Maldonado's decision was a hopeful indication that the officer who killed Feliz might be held accountable. But Commissioner Jessica Tisch, who began her tenure by promising to hold officers who commit misconduct accountable , didn't agree with her own department's judge. In July, she declined to fire the cop . Earlier this month Tisch doubled down on her decision to allow Rivera, now a lieutenant, to stay on the force. Her decision came over the objections of the Civilian Complaint Review Board, which stood firmly behind Maldonado's determination that Rivera's testimony was in parts "fabricated" and "self-serving." In her August 15 ruling , obtained by the CITY, Tisch said she made her decision in part due to a 2020 report from Attorney General Letitia James that found Rivera's claims that he was worried another officer might be hurt could not be disproven beyond reasonable doubt. "Given the timeline of what transpired, by far the most plausible reason that [Rivera] discharged his firearm was because he believed that doing so was necessary to save Officer Barrett's life," Tisch wrote.  For Allan's brother Samy Feliz, Tisch's final decision was "devastating," he told Hell Gate. "It would have allowed us to tell Allan's son, who is currently six years old, that we were able to get a semblance of justice for his father," he said. "Now we're unable to tell him that."  Allan's family is now demanding the next mayor of New York City remove Tisch as NYPD commissioner: "I am calling on NYC's next mayor, whoever they may be, to ensure Jessica Tisch has no place in their administration," Allan's mom Mery Verdeja said in a statement this week.  Hell Gate reached out to each of the mayoral candidates and asked them to respond to the family's request that the future mayor remove Tisch from her job as NYPD commissioner. Zohran Mamdani, Curtis Sliwa, and Andrew Cuomo did not respond to multiple requests for comment. Jim Walden said he reviewed the AG's report and agreed that the officer’s use of deadly force was reasonable in the circumstances. Eric Adams said he supported Tisch's "thoughtful decision": "While I was not mayor at the time of this incident, the attorney general herself investigated the case and chose not to bring charges because it was clear that Officer Rivera had a reasonable belief that his partner’s life was in danger." In an interview with Hell Gate, Samy laid out the grief he and the rest of his family have experienced after losing his brother. As for Tisch's decision, he said, "It makes us feel like the trial itself was a sham, the five years that we fought for justice." He added, "They already had their mind made up." This interview has been lightly edited and condensed for clarity. Hell Gate: We found out recently that Jessica Tisch's final decision on NYPD Lieutenant Jonathan Rivera was the same as her preliminary decision: that the officer would not face any discipline, a decision that flew in the face of the recommendation of the CCRB and the NYPD's administrative judge. What was your reaction to this?  Samy Feliz: We were completely devastated by it. This was our shot at getting this officer removed from the force and making our city safer.  But it would have also allowed us to tell Allan's son, who is currently six years old, that we were able to get a semblance of justice for his father. That the officer responsible for his death is no longer a cop, and that the City agreed with us—at least on that point—that an officer of that caliber shouldn't be part of the NYPD. And now we're unable to tell him that.  That's probably the most devastating part. Raising this young man and having to let him know that the city that he lives in is not one that cares for people like me and him, and that had no care about his father's life, even when it had an opportunity to provide justice. Has all of this changed your perception of the NYPD? Coming into this country, my mother taught me as a young boy that police officers were here to protect us. She told us, "That's who you call to rescue you." Then growing up and experiencing police officers and how you're treated as an individual and how you're categorized, profiled, harassed, stopped, frisked for no apparent reason, just because of where you live, what you look like—that gives you a different shape of what the truth is. It kind of dissolves that illusion that you once had as a child of what policing really is in your city.  And then continuing to grow, and experiencing something that me and my family used to see on the news, something that, even as you're reading this, might feel so distant from you, so far from home. But that bell can ring. It might not be someone directly related to you, like how it was for me, like Allan. But it might be someone who you care for, because of how often these things are happening in this country, this city as well.  How has it affected your family since that bell rang for you? We've been fighting for almost six years now, and probably will for countless more. Hitting the streets, not only with Eli—Allan's son—but also with my two children, Mauricio and Rose, from a very young age, I would say toddlers.  I've marched with my children and Allan's child and my family probably more than any child should experience at those ages. I would say the kids in my family—and I include Eli as one of my kids—they've been to more rallies, marches, trips to One Police Plaza, than they've been able to even celebrate Christmas or birthdays or holidays or vacations, any of these kinds of feel-good things.  They haven't had the opportunities to enjoy them as normal kids. But they do know their chants. They do know their rally cries. They know how to protect themselves, and are also having to experience and learn things that no child should be learning at this age. And then they're also building a perception that police aren't here to protect us, and that the police took someone who's so dear and so close to you, with no remorse. What have you learned going through the process of trying to hold Rivera and the NYPD accountable for the killing of your brother? You can fight for justice, you can go through their courts, their system, their judge, you can get a historic CCRB verdict recommending the officer's termination, but he still will not be fired. We sat through that trial—right alongside NYPD Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado—and we listened to these officers lie under oath, and Maldonado was able to discredit them and say, "Hey, this officer lied on the stand and yeah, I think he's guilty. He should be fired. He shouldn't be part of the force," validating what me and my family have fought for for so long.  And then Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch had the opportunity to do the right thing and fire this officer for his wrongdoing, and she completely overlooked all of that, because she has the authority to pretty much do what she pleases.  It makes us feel like the trial itself was a sham, the five years that we fought for justice. They already had their mind made up. They promoted this officer while having an open disciplinary case for the killing of Allan, showing where their allegiance lies.  When Jessica Tisch was appointed head of the NYPD, she came in saying that she was going to be a reformer, that she was going to hold officers who committed misconduct accountable. What do you think of that now?  It's clear that that was all a mockery. That was all part of the facade that we were sold by this person. We were thinking, yes! That she's a billionaire heiress, that she really doesn't need to really take on this position, but it's one that she chooses to take on.  When you tell folks that you're going to do the right thing and that you can't be bought, and you're going to clean up the NYPD, well, this was your real, true opportunity to show the community and to show the people that you were going to be doing the right thing. And you chose to go against that. You chose allegiance to the NYPD and to the lieutenants' union, knowing that your job is in jeopardy, that you're just as corrupt as Adams, and that he's not going to win this next election.  It's an election year, and your family has a call for the mayoral candidates to commit to not keeping Tisch as commissioner. Talk to me about that decision. We're not a family that's going to sugarcoat what our demands and our expectations are, because we want the safest thing for our city.  We want to make sure that police officers are held accountable and that we get transparency within the NYPD. To ask that shouldn't be too complex. If we can't get that, then what does it all mean? We have to ensure that we move in the right direction and are not working with folks who are counterproductive in getting the right things done for our city and the things that we deserve, like Jessica Tisch is showing us now.  For those who are running and who have an opportunity to win, just know that we will be watching. Families like mine are going to be present and demanding that you don't hire someone like Jessica Tisch as the next police commissioner for New York City, because we're already seeing that the talk was all talk, and New York is tired of politicians taking these positions and just promising things that are never going to happen. We deserve better. Have you heard from any of the mayoral candidates? No, I haven't.  There has been a lot written, including the attorney general's report, about what happened the day that your brother was killed. It's hard to read some of those details.  I want to be completely transparent with you. I saw the video of Allan, there's body cam footage that is available. For those who are younger in age, I wouldn't recommend watching it, the images are very graphic, very sensitive. I watched the video one time. And for someone who saw that video one time, I can recount pretty much the entire video, which is disturbing, right? This is someone who I love, someone who I held dear to me, who was a role model, a father figure to me, and just hearing my loved one scream in agony, asking for help, and just seeing him get brutalized by two officers…that was super hurtful.  But the most hurtful thing of all was the indecency that they had with my brother. He was pulled out of the car, and they removed his pants, or they came off when they yanked him out of the car. So after they had shot him in the chest, they had removed his pants, and his genitals were out to the public. And they didn't have the decency to cover him up. They decided to cuff him and allow him to bleed out and suffer there on the ground for over 10 minutes, bleeding out, and this all happened half a block away from Montefiore Hospital in the Bronx.  So that lack of decency, not to cover him up, in the worst type of position that you can ever be in, and not holding any threat to you, and you can't have the decency to do that, and you also don't have the mindset or the wherewithal to try to save someone's life…that just speaks to the inhumanity that the NYPD currently is operated under.  As somebody who is a people person and who doesn't wish that upon anyone, it's disturbing to know that those who are out there to protect and serve us really have intentions that are really to harm and destroy us, and who are able to get away with these things.  And that's a real concern that everyone who's reading this should really sit with—that we can experience this at any given time. It is not under our control, and then once it's in their control, we are in their hands, and it is in their hands that it is decided whether we make it home in one piece or not.

  • [AmDam] Allan Feliz remembered on Father’s Day as his family awaits justice

    By Tandy Lau “He showed me what love looks like, what safety feels like, and how a girl should be treated,” wrote Kilsi Polanco about her stepfather Allan Feliz. She penned her letter this past Father’s Day to NYPD commissioner Jessica Tisch, who gets the final say on firing the cop who killed him. “I’m proud of her for sharing her story,” said Julie Aquino, Polanco’s mother and Feliz’s partner. “But it makes me sad that she has to. She should be focused on her studies, her friends, the things that other 20 year olds should be doing. She shouldn’t have to raise her voice to get the cop who killed her dad fired. “We know Tisch cannot bring our loved ones back, but she can take steps towards making sure that no mother, no child, has to suffer what we had at the hands of her officers.” This past February, an NYPD disciplinary trial determined Lt. Jonathan Rivera violated department protocol when he beat, tased and fatally shot Feliz during a 2019 traffic stop. He should be terminated based on the NYPD guidelines. However, Tisch remains the final say and has remained largely mum four months after the trial’s decision. Eric Garner’s death provides the only precedent for Feliz’s family regarding an NYPD court greenlighting an officer’s termination after a successful Civil Complaint Review Board (CCRB) prosecution. Then-commissioner James O’Neill fired Daniel Pantaleo just a few weeks after his disciplinary trial concluded. Tisch does not face a deadline to make her decision. Feliz raised Polanco since she was three years old and also had a son with Aquino shortly before his death. “To me, he is my dad in every way that matters,” Polanco wrote in the letter. Before his death, Feliz looked forward to taking them to Disney World and moving into a larger space with a backyard. And picking out a tiny Halloween costume for his toddler. “Those are things that we got to experience, me and Allan got to go to Disney World and experience that together,” said Feliz’s brother Samy. “He remembered being a child, and how it will stick with us for the rest of our lives and what kind of impact those moments have of being with your family and then being in such a huge place and having those memorable moments. “For Allan, it was just like trying to get a running start in creating those everlasting, memorable moments.” His son recently graduated from kindergarten. Polanco was 15 when the shooting occurred and is now in college studying social work. And Rivera received a promotion from sergeant to lieutenant. The family mentioned challenges for explaining what happened to Feliz’s son. “For a while, it even hurt to look at him, because he looks just like our dad,” wrote Polanco in the letter. Aquino recounted how her son recently devised a plan to “bring his dad back.” “To explain to my son that’s impossible is super emotional,” she said. “It’s really hard. It gets me sad, but I stay strong and I just tell him ‘you look just like him.’ He tells me, ‘why do people say, oh look a little Allan. Oh, just like his dad.’ And I’m like you’re his twin. You look just like him, you smile like him.” Aquino and Feliz’s mother Mery Verdeja also penned a letter to Tisch this past Mother’s Day calling for Rivera’s termination. Other mothers of police violence victims — including Amadou Diallo’s mother Kadiatou Diallo — signed the letter. Tisch responded to them roughly two weeks later with a neutral statement about how she could not comment on pending matters. But while justice may be delayed, Aquino believes justice will be served if Tisch terminates Rivera. “We will have some sort of peace, but we won’t get Allan back,” she said. Meanwhile, the NYPD promoted Rivera, who was a sergeant, when he shot Feliz. Tisch’s first major test on officer discipline follows her predecessor Edward Caban burying misconduct cases with “retention” powers. He prevented more than 50 substantiated CCRB investigations from reaching trial in just his first year, reported ProPublica . To be clear, the NYPD handles disciplinary in-house even before the commissioner’s final stamp of approval. Cases like Rivera’s go in front of a NYPD deputy commissioner who serves as a de facto judge. The CCRB cannot impose disciplinary actions on offending officers and does not “recommend” an officer’s punishment, as is commonly reported. Instead, a “presumptive penalty” assigned by the NYPD disciplinary matrix determines how misconduct is dealt with. Since her appointment last November, Tisch is credited with overhauling NYPD culture. She cracked down on excessive overtime and several controversial figures like chief Jeffrey Maddrey — who evaded disciplinary measures under Caban — departed under her leadership. She previously headed the Department of Sanitation and worked for the NYPD in a civilian capacity. Three democratic mayoral candidates previously supported Feliz’s family in their current elected roles: NYC Comptroller Brad Lander, Assemblymember Zohran Mamdani, and State Senator Jessica Ramos. Lander hails as Tisch’s biggest proponent in the race and promised to retain her as police commissioner if elected. Ramos and Mamdani did not raise their hands when moderators asked candidates on who would keep Tisch in her role during the first primary debate. “Whoever the next mayor is — and whether they change the police commissioner or not — my direct ask for me and my family would be to grant us the [police accountability] that you all love to run on,” said Samy Feliz. Allan Feliz’s grand ambitions of a Disney World family vacation remain on hold after his death six years later. But Aquino is determined to take their son to Orlando. “I feel like his dream [wasn’t fulfilled], but I’ll make sure that my son does go to Disney World and gets to see what his father wanted him to see.”

  • Family of Allan Feliz Outraged by Commissioner Tisch’s “Despicable” Refusal to Fire Killer Cop Rivera 

    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Wednesday, August 20, 2025 MEDIA CONTACTS:  Tess Weiner, tess@justicecommittee.org , 224.213.5495 Family of Allan Feliz Outraged by Commissioner Tisch’s “Despicable” Refusal to Fire Killer Cop Rivera  Feliz family and supporters say “the fight is not over”; call for next mayor to remove Tisch as NYPD Commissioner New York, NY  – Today, the family of Allan Feliz was joined by the brother of Ramarley Graham (killed by NYPD in 2012), Councilmember Carmen De La Rosa, civil rights and grassroots organizations, and community members to condemn NYPD Commissioner Tisch’s refusal to fire or in any way discipline Lt. Jonathan Rivera, who killed Allan Feliz during an unjust traffic stop in 2019. Tisch’s shameful final decision , announced quietly on Friday afternoon, comes amidst a flurry of corruption lawsuits  against the NYPD, including sweeping allegations of dismissing misconduct. Samy Feliz, Allan Feliz’s brother , shared, “My family and I are outraged and devastated by Commissioner Tisch’s decision to overturn the guilty verdict against Lt. Jonathan Rivera for killing Allan. Tisch’s refusal to fire this abusive officer, who shot a teenager before killing my brother and has harmed New Yorkers since, is despicable. It proves that she cannot be trusted, and that she is just as corrupt as the rest of the NYPD and the Eric Adams administration.” The Feliz family has suffered through the arduous discipline process for nearly six years, facing intentional delays and obstructions from the NYPD and the Adams administration at each turn. Deputy Commissioner of Trials Maldonado issued a rare guilty verdict  and recommended firing Jonathan Rivera in February. The case languished on Commissioner Tisch’s desk for another 6 months before she issued her final decision, continuing NYPD’s legacy of impunity.  TheFeliz family and their supporters say they are not giving up the fight. “As devastating as Commissioner Tisch’s final decision is, we know New Yorkers are on our side, and our fight is not over,” said Julie Aquino, Allan Feliz’s partner and mother of his son, Eli.  “We are pursuing all options to continue our fight to ensure Rivera is fired.” Last month, in response to a preliminary decision that indicated that Tisch was moving to overturn the guilty verdict, LatinoJustice PRLDEF, Center for Constitutional Rights, New York Civil Liberties Union and others submitted a letter to the NYPD that called such a decision arbitrary, capricious and an abuse of discretion. “Commissioner Tisch’s decision to shield Lt. Rivera after he shot Allan Feliz at point-blank range is a betrayal of justice,"  said Lourdes M. Rosado, President and General Counsel, LatinoJustice PRLDEF . "For nearly six years, the Feliz family has endured lies, delays, and obstruction only to see Tisch overturn her own deputy’s recommendation and side with a killer cop with a long record of misconduct. LatinoJustice stands with the Feliz family and all New Yorkers demanding justice.”  The Feliz family and their supporters say this decision proves Jessica Tisch cannot be trusted to serve and protect New Yorkers. “Commissioner Tisch, despite her promises, has made one thing clear: her allegiance is not to the people of New York, but to her own interests and to violent, unaccountable cops who terrorize our communities,” said Mery Verdeja, Allan Feliz’s mother. “I am calling on NYC’s next mayor, whoever they may be, to ensure Jessica Tisch has no place  in their administration.” “Despite Commissioner Tisch’s attempts to brand herself as a new kind of police commissioner with talks of reform, she has chosen political self-interest over the truth and continued the NYPD’s pattern of protecting officers with histories of misconduct,” said Yul-san Liem (she/they), Deputy Director of Justice Committee.  “Jessica Tisch is just as corrupt as Eric Adams, all his other police commissioners and the rest of his administration. She cannot be trusted to serve or lead New Yorkers. We are calling on whoever becomes the next mayor to remove her as police commissioner and ensure she holds no position in city government.”  "In addition to the egregious harm Tisch's decision to overturn the guilty verdict against Rivera will cause Allan’s family, this choice endangers the residents of NYC,” said Councilmember Alexa Avilés  (she/her). “I hope our next mayor will see this public safety hazard for what it is and remove both Tisch and Rivera from their respective roles." “For years, many of our members have stood with the Feliz Family, Justice Committee, and allies demanding accountability for the murder of Allan Feliz. We are outraged that years of pleading for the Department to do what is right, of being told to trust in the process has only netted a never-ending maze of delays and bureaucratic smoke and mirrors for the Feliz family. We mourn with you and remain committed in this fight for dignity, transparency, and justice,” said Emmet Teran, Executive Director of the New York City Council Progressive Caucus.

  • [Hellgate] Adams and Tisch Promised Police Accountability. The Families of Two Men Killed by Police Are Still Waiting

    Win Rozario was killed a year ago. Allan Feliz five years ago. The investigative and disciplinary process for the cops who killed them is still dragging on. By Nick Pinto, Hellgate On March 27 of last year, 19-year-old Win Rozario called 911 seeking medical assistance as he struggled with a mental health crisis at the Queens home he shared with his parents and brother. Two police officers arrived shortly after. Body-camera footage from the officers shows them escalating the situation so rapidly that within two minutes of walking in the door, they had shot Rozario to death in front of his younger brother and mother as she begged them not to. The NYPD promised it would investigate the shooting, but more than a year later, the status of that investigation is unknown, shrouded behind an NYPD wall of silence. "They treated him like he didn't matter and it's a miracle they didn't also kill my other son and wife who were there," Rozario's father said at a rally to commemorate the killing and call for action last week. "The NYPD is too powerful in this city, they are getting away with murder." As Rozario's family demands answers and accountability for a deadly NYPD encounter, so is the family of Allan Feliz, who was killed by police more than five years ago. They are still waiting for NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch to rule on disciplinary charges against the cop who killed him.  The long delays in investigating and adjudicating deadly police violence stand in stark contrast to the public statements of Mayor Eric Adams, who campaigned on promises of transparency and swift accountability for police misconduct, and of his police commissioner, who has presented herself as taking police discipline accountability seriously after an especially anarchic era for the NYPD. When Hell Gate asked Mayor Eric Adams in October 2023 about ongoing delays in the department's disciplinary case against the officers who killed Kawaski Trawick, another young man shot to death by police in his home seconds after they opened his door, he said disciplinary cases need to move faster. "I want this to be a hallmark of this administration, that we need to shorten the time," he said. "When we make mistakes in the police department, we have to live up to them. We have to own them. We don't need to be covering them up. And I want to make sure we start creating a culture of turnover evidence, making sure we shorten the time that it takes." The mayor echoed that promise at his State of the City address a few months later. "When a civilian brings a complaint, we must act more swiftly to resolve the matter," he said. "Right now, some internal discipline cases in our police department can take as long as a year to resolve, if not more. That is far too long. This year, the NYPD will further reform their internal case process to cut that time in half—setting stricter timelines so that cases do not languish for months." Why then, more than a year after Rozario's killing, is the NYPD's investigation still pending? What even is the status of that investigation? When might we expect it to conclude? We asked all of these questions to the NYPD, which simply answered, "The incident remains under investigation by the Force Investigation Division." Feliz's case is also seemingly languishing without resolution.  In October 2019, then-Sergeant Jonathan Rivera shot 31-year-old Allan Feliz to death in his car in the Bronx, and was subsequently cleared of wrongdoing by an NYPD internal investigation. In 2023, after a long delay in receiving evidence from the NYPD, the Civilian Complaint Review Board substantiated departmental charges of assault and menacing against Rivera. After another long delay in serving the CCRB's charges against Rivera, the NYPD finally held a disciplinary trial last November, and in February, the department's deputy commissioner for trials, who acts as a sort of internal police judge, found Rivera guilty and recommended he be fired.  All that remains is for NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch to act—to either accept or reject the recommendation. But more than a month later, Tisch has taken no final action on the case, and though Feliz's family and their supporters had urged her to finally resolve the matter by the end of March, there's no indication of when she will make a determination.  What's the hold up? When will Tisch—who has pledged to take police accountability more seriously than her predecessors—act on the case? We asked the NYPD. "In regard to the [sic] Lt Rivera," came the answer, "the disciplinary process remains ongoing." Given his stated interest in speeding up NYPD accountability, how does the mayor feel about how long his department is taking to resolve these two cases? We tried to ask him at his press conference today, but weren't allowed a question. We then tried again, asking his communications staff if Adams is satisfied with the speed of the NYPD resolution of the Rozario and Feliz cases, and if not, what he's doing about it. We're still waiting to get an answer.

  • Family of Win Rozario Reacts To Release of Police Body Worn Camera Footage of His Killing

    MEDIA CONTACTS: Yul-san Liem, yul-san@justicecommittee.org Akash Singh, akash@drumnyc.org   FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: May 3, 2024 New York, NY:   Today, New York State Attorney General James released body camera footage of the March 27th killing of 19-year-old Win Rozario by NYPD Officers Salvatore Alongi & Matthew Cianfrocco. In response, the family of Win Rozario, their representatives from the Justice Committee and Desis Rising Up & Moving, and the family’s attorneys released the following statements:  Statement from Win Rozario’s family - Notan Ava Costa, Utsho Rozario, and  Francis Rozario  (mother, brother and father of Win Rozario):  “It’s been over a month since we lost Win and our hearts are broken. We feel his absence every day. Reliving this is traumatic and painful. We wish it wasn’t necessary for the video to be public. The video that was released makes it clear that Win should be alive but the police came and murdered him in our kitchen without any care for him or us. The police created a crisis and killed him in cold blood. The officers should be fired and prosecuted for murder as soon as possible.” "The footage is horrifying - this was an execution," said Loyda Colon, Executive Director of the Justice Committee . "From the start, the insulting language made clear these cops shouldn't be interacting with anyone who might have or be perceived to have mental health complexities. Contrary to the NYPD's lies that began soon after Win was killed, the video shows that the way these cops came in created a crisis situation that they unilaterally escalated multiple times. The cops made no attempt to de-escalate the crisis they created or engage with Win and his family other than to bark orders, tase and shoot. This was a cold-blooded murder where they killed Win in minutes, tasering and shooting him repeatedly. They were so reckless it's a miracle they didn't also kill Win's mother and brother. Officers Salvatore Alongi and Matthew Cianfrocco need to be suspended without pay immediately, fired and prosecuted. Mayor Adams needs to answer for why his administration has refused to release Alongi and Cianfroccos names and he needs to ensure that the years of cover-up and obstruction faced by Kawaski Trawick's family aren't repeated here." "How many times do we have to stand with families because their loved one was killed by the NYPD, after the NYPD created a crisis and escalated it?,” said Simran Thind (she/they), Desis Rising Up & Moving Racial Justice Organizer.  “Why don't we have teams of trained mental health emergency responders in New York City when it has proven to be more effective than police? We need New York City to implement more effective and proven public safety measures, rather than gaslight the impacted families and the public with false propaganda after such tragedies." “They shot the man in the back. The NYPD’s recklessness killed one person and almost killed two more. These officers should be fired and prosecuted. It’s a disgrace,” said David Rankin (he/him), Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP. “There was absolutely no reason for Win Rozario’s life to be cut short. It is a devastating reminder that the police are not equipped to be first responders in mental health response,” said Luna Droubi (she/her), Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP ### Background 19-year-old Win Rozario was in his Ozone Park, Queens home when he was killed by NYPD Officers Salvatore Alongi & Matthew Cianfrocco on March 27, 2024. He was killed in his family’s kitchen, in front of his mother and his younger brother.  After Rozario was killed, the NYPD did not release body camera footage, the names of the officers or information about their employment status. About the Justice Committee : Since the 1980s, the  Justice Committee  (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police. violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice. About Desis Rising Up and Moving: DRUM - Desis Rising Up and Moving  is a multigenerational, membership led organization of low-wage South Asian and Indo-Caribbean immigrants, workers and youth in New York City.  Founded in 2000, DRUM has mobilized and built the leadership of thousands of low-income, South Asian and Indo-Caribbean immigrants to lead social and policy change that impacts their own lives- from immigrant rights to education reform, racial justice, and worker’s justice.  Our membership of over 5,000 adults, youth, and families is multigenerational and represents the diaspora of the South Asian communities – Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Guyana, India, Nepal, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Suriname, Trinidad & Tobago, and beyond.  In over a decade, we have built a unique model of South Asian and Indo-Caribbean undocumented workers, women, and youth led organizing for rights and justice from the local to the global rooted in base building, leadership development, running short and long term campaigns to reform policies on all levels, strong cross-community alliances locally and nationally, and building democratic and mass participatory spaces.

  • RELEASE: Family of Teen Win Rozario Sues NYC and NYPD Officers for Wrongful Death and Civil Rights Violations

    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Monday, June 23, 2025   MEDIA CONTACT Tess Weiner, tess@justicecommittee.org , 224-213-5495 Akash Singh, akash@drumnyc.org , 347-901-2815   Family of Teen Win Rozario Sues NYC and NYPD Officers for Wrongful Death and Civil Rights Violations   New York, NY  –  The family of 19-year-old Win Rozario, killed in his home in front of his mother and younger brother by two NYPD officers in 2024, filed a lawsuit today against the City of New York, NYPD Officer Salvatore Alongi, Officer Matthew Cianfrocco, and other NYPD who violated the rights of Win’s mother and younger brother directly after the killing.   The lawsuit, filed by Beldock, Levine & Hoffman LLP  on behalf of Win’s mother Notan Eva Costa  and brother Utsho Rozario , outlines the reckless actions of NYPD officers Salvatore Alongi and Matthew Cianfrocco that resulted in the killing of the Bangladeshi teen, within less than two minutes of the cops’ arrival to the apartment. Alongi & Cianfrocco violated multiple NYPD protocols, the lawsuit alleges, including those involving police use of force and response to individuals perceived to be in emotional distress; violated Win’s and his family’s civil rights; created and repeatedly escalated the crisis that resulted in Win’s death; and unnecessarily endangered the lives of the teen’s mother and younger brother in the process.  The complaint states that Alongi & Cianfrocco’s “quick resort to force, repeated and loud shouting, and aggressive actions escalated and exacerbated the situation, making [Win]  fear for his life, Eva fear for her son’s, and Utsho fear for his mother’s.”      Notan Eva Costa , Utsho Rozario  and Win’s father Francis Rozario  released the following statement upon the filing of the lawsuit:  “It’s been over a year since Matthew Cianfrocco and Salvatore Alongi murdered Win, and nothing has happened - they still haven’t been fired, arrested or prosecuted. Cianfrocco & Alongi created a crisis and escalated at every turn, recklessly gunning Win down in our home in less than two minutes – and almost killing two of us too. We know this lawsuit won’t give us true justice but we’re fighting for Win with every tool we have. Mayor Adams has given us zero updates on the NYPD’s investigation and has done nothing since Win was murdered to protect New Yorkers from these dangerous police - he doesn’t seem to care about justice. We’re suing the city, Cianfrocco, Alongi and the other police whose names we still don’t know who murdered Win, forced us to be interrogated at the precinct when we should have been allowed to go in the ambulance with Win, and who refused to let us go back to our home for more than two days. We wish Win was still with us and pray that what we do helps prevent other families from having to go through this.”   Directly after Alongi & Cianfrocco shot Win at least five times, the lawsuit alleges that medical attention was haphazard and improper and multiple still-unidentified NYPD officers forcibly prevented Win’s mother and brother from going with Win when he was being transported to the hospital – instead unlawfully detaining them at the local precinct for questioning, without legal representation and without allowing them to retrieve essentials or additional clothing from their home in spite of the cold weather. Officers did not disclose that Win had died until after separately interrogating Win’s mother and brother. Following the interrogations, Win’s parents and brother were not permitted to return to their home for over two days – and only after Public Advocate Jumaane Williams’ office demanded that the NYPD allow the family to return home. Win’s family was not permitted to access their medications or even retrieve their cat, who was without food for days. In total, the suit includes sixteen counts against the defendant officers and the city, including excessive force and unreasonable seizure, violations of substantive due process, and other violations of constitutional, civil and human rights. In addition to suing the city, Win Rozario’s family is calling on Mayor Adams and the NYPD to fire Officers Alongi and Cianfrocco, demanding that Attorney General Tish James prosecute them for all misconduct related to the killing and aftermath, and supporting calls to remove police from mental health encounters.   In support of the family’s demands, their attorney, David B. Rankin  (he/him), Beldock Levine & Hoffman, LLP stated: “The NYPD must immediately fire Officers Salvatore Alongi and Matthew Cianfrocco. They shot and killed Win and nearly shot Notan Eva Costa and Utsho Rozario and they are still working, it is a disgrace. The officers are being paid nearly 200k a year by the people of New York, this has to stop. In no other job can you fail so spectacularly that someone is dead, you’re under investigation, and you’ve been sued yet you still cash a handsome paycheck. It must end, they must be fired.”   Luna Droubi  (she/her), Beldock Levine & Hoffman, LLP  stated: “Win Rozario should be alive today. His death could have been avoided if police officers are removed from mental health responses. This lawsuit demands justice and accountability for the failures of the City. The Rozario family deserves nothing less.”   Loyda Colon  (they/them), executive director of the Justice Committee , who has been working closely with Win’s family on their campaign to fire and prosecute Alongi and Cianfrocco for killing Win, stated: “From the moment Alongi and Cianfrocco got to Win’s home, they used derogatory language in relation to Win and then created a crisis when everything had been calm, resulting in their murder of this teenager who should be alive today, getting ready to celebrate his 21st birthday next month. Their reckless actions violated multiple provisions of the NYPD’s patrol guide.  It’s outrageous that 15 months after Win was killed, Mayor Adams & the NYPD have refused to provide any information about their investigation to the family. Alongi and Cianfrocco should be fired and prosecuted immediately – they’re a danger to New Yorkers.” Simran Thind, an organizer with Desis Rising Up & Moving (DRUM) , who has also been working with family, added: “The reckless and vicious murder of Win Rozario by NYPD officers is something no family should ever have to experience. Not only did the officers come into the apartment deriding Win before they even encountered him, but then they mistreated the family by keeping them in a police car while officers made jokes and bantered, not notifying them of Win's death, questioning the family at the precinct, and locking them out of their apartment for days. All of these things indicate the rot at the heart of the NYPD, and this case is a manifestation of that culture.” The legal complaint can be made available upon request. BACKGROUND 19-year-old Win Rozario was in his Ozone Park, Queens home when he was killed by NYPD Officers Salvatore Alongi and Matthew Cianfrocco on March 27, 2024, in front of his mother and younger brother. Officers Alongi and Cianfrocco created a crisis when they arrived and repeatedly escalated the situation, tasing and shooting Win at least five times within less than two minutes after entering the family’s apartment, unjustifiably killing the teen and risking the lives of Win’s mother and brother.   Immediately following the shooting, NYPD officers forced Ms. Costa and Utsho, Win’s mother and younger brother, to go to the precinct to be interrogated, preventing them from accompanying Win in the ambulance. Ms. Costa was questioned at length without counsel before being told her son had died, and 17-year-old Utsho, was also interrogated alone. NYPD officers blocked re-entry to the Rozario family’s home for more than two days, refusing the family’s demands to retrieve belongings, access medications, or even feed their cat.   For over a month after Win Rozario was killed, the NYPD blocked transparency, including refusing to release the names of the officers involved. Alongi and Cianfrocco’s names were first publicly identified by the Attorney General’s office when   they released officer body camera footage  on May 3, 2024. Mayor Adams’ first, and only, public statements regarding the killing were issued only after the Attorney General released body camera footage, over five weeks after Win was killed after being questioned by press. After being questioned by reporters,   Mayor Adams falsely claimed  that he had reached out to the family after the incident and that discipline would have to wait until after the Attorney General’s investigation concluded with a determination, which has never been accurate.   For the past year, Win Rozario’s family, along with the Justice Committee and Desis Rising Up & Moving, have called for the NYPD to fire - and for the NYS Attorney General to prosecute - NYPD officers Alongi and Cianfrocco. They are also calling for police to be removed from the city’s mental health response.    The Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) and the New York State Attorney General are still investigating the killing. The family has received no updates from Mayor Adams or the NYPD about the NYPD’s mandated investigation. While mayors sometimes falsely claim that officer disciplinary processes must wait until after prosecutor determinations, there is no mandate to delay discipline. Francis Livoti, who killed Anthony Baez in 1994, was fired from the NYPD before federal prosecutors convicted Livoti for violating Baez’s civil rights. ### Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP  has been at the forefront of ground-breaking civil rights cases involving police misconduct, wrongful convictions, the First Amendment, and employment discrimination around the country for sixty years. The firm was responsible for the class action, Floyd v. City of New York , which successfully overturned the NYPD’s decade-long unconstitutional stop-and-frisk policy. Other notable representations include the family of Eric Garner, members of the Exonerated Five, George Whitmore, and Rubin “Hurricane” Carter. Recently, BLH represented the family of Nicholas Feliciano, a young man who attempted suicide while under watch in a Rikers Island holding cell as correction officers stood by. Sixty years after its formation, BLH remains a force for justice, accountability, and social progress. With decades of impact behind it and critical cases underway, the firm is dedicated to using the law as a tool for change—advocating for individuals, confronting systems of abuse, and shaping a more just and equitable future.  About the Justice Committee : Since the 1980s, the  Justice Committee  (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice. About Desis Rising Up and Moving :   DRUM - Desis Rising Up and Moving  is a multigenerational, membership led organization of low-wage South Asian and Indo-Caribbean immigrants, workers and youth in New York City. Founded in 2000, DRUM has mobilized and built the leadership of thousands of low-income, South Asian and Indo-Caribbean immigrants to lead social and policy change that impacts their own lives- from immigrant rights to education reform, racial justice, and worker’s justice.  Our membership of over 5,000 adults, youth, and families is multigenerational and represents the diaspora of the South Asian communities – Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, Guyana, India, Nepal, Pakistan, Sri Lanka, Suriname, Trinidad & Tobago, and beyond.  In over a decade, we have built a unique model of South Asian and Indo-Caribbean undocumented workers, women, and youth led organizing for rights and justice from the local to the global rooted in base building, leadership development, running short and long term campaigns to reform policies on all levels, strong cross-community alliances locally and nationally, and building democratic and mass participatory spaces

  • Family of Allan Feliz “Furious and Devastated” by Commissioner’s Dismissal of Charges Against Lt. Rivera

    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Thursday, July 3, 2025 MEDIA CONTACTS:  Tess Weiner, tess@justicecommittee.org , 224.213.5495 Family of Allan Feliz “Furious and Devastated” by Commissioner’s Dismissal of Charges Against Lt. Rivera Nearly 5 months after Deputy Commissioner Maldonado finds Rivera guilty and recommends he be fired, Tisch shamefully reverses course New York, NY  — Today, Police Commissioner Tisch reversed Deputy Commissioner Maldonado’s guilty verdict and recommendation to fire Lt. Jonathan Rivera for killing Allan Feliz. The decision comes over five years after Allan Feliz’s murder during an illegal traffic stop in October 2019. In response to the decision, the Feliz family issued the following statement: We are furious and devastated by Commissioner Tisch’s outrageous, cowardly, and shameful decision to overturn Deputy Commissioner Maldondo’s guilty verdict and refusal to fire or, in any way discipline, Lt. Jonathan Rivera for killing Allan. With this reversal, Tisch has made one thing unmistakably clear: her allegiance is not to the people of New York, but to violent, unaccountable cops who terrorize our communities. Both the CCRB and NYPD’s own Deputy Commissioner of Trials found Rivera guilty of unjustly killing Allan, because he is. Rivera has continued to abuse New Yorkers since killing Allan, has a record of 39 misconduct allegations, and is named in at least 6 lawsuits. Commissioner Tisch’s decision sends a clear and terrifying message to officers that they can racially profile, abuse, and kill people with absolute impunity—and they’ll be protected at the highest levels. For almost six years, our family has mourned Allan while simultaneously fighting for Rivera to be fired. In the midst of unimaginable suffering, we have fought and overcome countless roadblocks, delays, and obstructions by the administration, the NYPD, and the Lieutenants Union. To have come this far only for the Police Commissioner to spit in the face of justice by capriciously and dangerously flipping Maldonado’s ruling is heartbreaking. This disgraceful outcome lays bare what we’ve always known to be true: the NYPD discipline system is rigged to protect cops, no matter how vile their actions. The authority to discipline officers must be stripped from the police commissioner and we will continue to fight for this and for all victims of police violence in Allan’s name. Yul-san Liem (she/they), Deputy Director of Justice Committee, issued the following statement: Commissioner Tisch’s decision not to fire Lt. Jonathan Rivera is grave injustice to the Feliz family, an unforgivable betrayal of New Yorkers, and proof that the NYPD will never hold itself accountable. Lt. Rivera brutally murdered a New Yorker without cause and he had a laundry list of complaints against him from both before and after he killed Allan. He should have been fired years ago - and Commissioner Tisch and Mayor Adams’ refusal to do this puts all New Yorkers at risk. Tisch’s attempts to brand herself as a different kind of commissioner has lulled some elected officials into complacency or even praise, but with this decision, she has shown her true colors: she is no different from any of Eric Adams’ other police commissioners. When faced with a clear-cut case of deadly misconduct, she sided with the killer. The Commissioner and Mayor should be ashamed at the excruciatingly long and traumatizing discipline process they have forced the Feliz family to endure. This process has nothing to do with justice or safety. It is a system designed to protect abusive cops at all costs, to wear down families, and to delay and dissolve any change at disciplining officers. The authority to discipline officers must be removed from the police commissioner. ###   Background: On October 17, 2019, NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera (who was a sergeant at the time) and Officers Edward Barrett and Michelle Almanzar pulled Allan Feliz over on the corner of E 211 St and Bainbridge Ave for allegedly not wearing a seatbelt. Bodyworn camera (bwc) footage shows officers acknowledging that Mr. Feliz was wearing his seatbelt, but rather than allowing him to drive away, the officers escalated by illegally detaining him and attacking him. Lt. Rivera climbed into the passenger side of the car, tasered, beat and threatened to shoot Mr. Feliz, and then shot him point blank in the chest. After Mr. Feliz was shot, Officer Barrett yanked Mr. Feliz’s limp body from the car, exposing his genitals. None of the officers immediately covered Mr. Feliz or provided medical aid. Instead, they left Mr. Feliz to bleed out, cuffed, and exposed. Moments after shooting Mr. Feliz, Lt. Rivera exclaimed, “I was fighting. My hand was getting tired.” After  years of delays  and obstruction, in May 2023, the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB)  substantiated  fireable charges against Lt. Rivera for the killing of Allan Feliz. The NYPD delayed the process further by failing to deliver the charges to Lt. Rivera so that a discipline trial could be scheduled for over a year. Finally, after multiple rallies and press conferences, the NYPD delivered the charges in June 2024 and a discipline trial was held in Nov. 2024. In February, Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado determined Lt. Rivera to be guilty of excessive force and assault in the first degree and is recommended he be fired. In March and April, over 30 elected officials and 50 organizations signed on in support of the Feliz family’s demands to fire Rivera. About the Justice Committee: Since the 1980s, the  Justice Committee  (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice.

  • Family of Allan Feliz & Legal Advocates Challenge Commissioner Tisch’s “Abuse of Discretion” in Preliminary Decision to Let Killer Cop Rivera Walk

    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Friday, July 11, 2025 MEDIA CONTACTS:  Tess Weiner, tess@justicecommittee.org , 224.213.5495 Family of Allan Feliz & Legal Advocates Challenge Commissioner Tisch’s “Abuse of Discretion” in Preliminary Decision to Let Killer Cop Rivera Walk As the CCRB prepares response, Feliz family is joined by LatinoJustice PRLDEF, NYCLU, Center for Constitutional Rights and others to deliver a legal letter to the Commissioner New York, NY  — Today, the family of Allan Feliz was joined by Eric Vassell, father of Saheed Vassell (killed by NYPD in 2018), State Senator Julia Salazaar, Public Advocate Jumaane Williams, Justice Committee, LatinoJustice PRLDEF, New York Civil Liberties Union (NYLCU), Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR), other civil rights and community organizations, and dozens of community members outside One Police Plaza to demand that NYPD Commissioner Tisch fire Lt. Jonathan Rivera — the officer who fatally shot 31-year-old Allan Feliz during an unjust traffic stop in 2019. The rally coincides with the Civilian Complaint Review Board’s (CCRB) deadline to submit a rebuttal of Tisch’s shocking preliminary  ruling to overturn the guilty verdict issued against Lt. Rivera by her own Deputy Commissioner of Trials in February.  Ashley Verdeja, the sister of Allan Feliz, recounted the suffering her family has endured for almost six years: “I am standing here today, yet   again , because Commissioner Tisch refuses to do what’s right. When we learned that she had quietly issued a preliminary decision to overturn  her own deputy commissioner’s guilty verdict—late in the day before a holiday weekend—it wasn’t just a slap in the face. It was retraumatizing. The disrespect the NYPD and Adams administration have shown my family is staggering.” Alongside the Feliz family, advocates from LatinoJustice, NYCLU, CCR, Beldock, Levine & Hoffman and other legal institutions delivered a letter  to Commissioner Tisch challenging the legality of her decision. The letter states,  “the Preliminary Decision is wrong as a manner of law. It constitutes arbitrary and capricious agency action and an abuse of discretion.. It is at odds with the department’s stated position regarding the priority of the fact finder before the NYPD monitor. The Preliminary Decision exceeds the discretion afforded the police commissioner under the laws.” “ When the Feliz family finally got their day in court, Deputy Commissioner Maldonado looked Lieutenant Rivera in the eye, listened to his testimony, and determined that he was lying,” said Andrew Case, Supervising Council at PRLDEF . “Commissioner Tisch was not in the hearing room and did not see the testimony. She nevertheless decided that she was a better judge of credibility. But the hearing officer is the best person to judge witnesses—this is a basic principle of law that the Commissioner should have learned in law school. Tisch’s decision violates that principle and therefore constitutes an abuse of her discretion to impose discipline.” “The Commissioner’s move to overturn her own Deputy Commissioner’s guilty verdict is not just shameful - it’s corrupt,” said  Yul-san Liem, Deputy Director of Justice Committee.  “ Tisch is retraumatizing the Feliz family, ignoring the findings of her own Deputy Commissioner, and trampling on city procedure to keep a killer cop on our streets. This is a self-interested political maneuver to gain favor within the NYPD and the police unions that is not based on the facts of the case. We are demanding she reverse course, uphold the guilty verdict and fire Jonathan Rivera immediately. “Commissioner Tisch’s decision to overturn the recommendation of her own Deputy Commissioner of Trials is a blatant abuse of power. Lt. Jonathan Rivera killed Allan Feliz, a young man who was pulled over for not wearing his seatbelt. In what world does not wearing your seat belt warrant a death sentence? While Mr. Feliz’s family has been grieving his loss and fighting for accountability, Jonathan Rivera got away with murder and got a promotion. That’s not justice, that’s corruption. I’m calling on the Commissioner to immediately reverse her decision, and fire Lt. Rivera,” said Senator Julia Salazar. "It's hard to accept that the known facts around the killing of Allan Feliz could lead to a determination of no wrongdoing, that his killer should remain on the force,” said Public Advocate Jumaane Williams.  “Lt. Rivera will walk away from this incident still an officer, while Allan cannot not walk away at all. My heart and voice are with his family. I n the past, this commissioner has shown a willingness to increase accountability, and with it, trust. There's still a chance to change course and follow through on accountability." ________________ Background:  On October 17, 2019, NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera (who was a sergeant at the time) and Officers Edward Barrett and Michelle Almanzar pulled Allan Feliz over on the corner of E 211 St and Bainbridge Ave for allegedly not wearing a seatbelt. Bodyworn camera (bwc) footage shows officers acknowledging that Mr. Feliz was wearing his seatbelt, but rather than allowing him to drive away, the officers escalated by illegally detaining him and attacking him. Lt. Rivera climbed into the passenger side of the car, tasered, beat and threatened to shoot Mr. Feliz, and then shot him point blank in the chest. After Mr. Feliz was shot, Officer Barrett yanked Mr. Feliz’s limp body from the car, exposing his genitals. None of the officers immediately covered Mr. Feliz or provided medical aid. Instead, they left Mr. Feliz to bleed out, cuffed, and exposed.  After years of delays  and obstruction, in May 2023, the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB)  substantiated  fireable charges against Lt. Rivera for the killing of Allan Feliz. The NYPD delayed the process further by failing to deliver the charges to Lt. Rivera so that a discipline trial could be scheduled for over a year. Finally, after multiple rallies and press conferences, the NYPD delivered the charges in June 2024 and a discipline trial was held in November 2024. In February 2025, Deputy Commissioner of Trials Rosemarie Maldonado determined Lt. Rivera to be guilty of excessive force and assault in the first degree and recommended he be fired.  In the months following, dozens of elected officials  and 50 organizations  added their voices to the demand that Lt. Rivera be fired. On July 3, the afternoon before a holiday weekend, Commissioner Tisch released a shameful and out-of-process announcement that she was reversing the guilty verdict against Lt. Rivera. In spite of the fact that this decision was reported on as final, the CCRB has five business days (until Friday 7/12) to respond, after which the Commissioner will make a final decision. About the Justice Committee: Since the 1980s, the Justice Committee (JC) has worked to end police violence and systemic racism in NYC. We organize with families who have lost loved ones to the NYPD, train communities in CopWatch and ICE Watch, and develop grassroots alternatives to policing. Our work builds public safety rooted in care, not criminalization.

  • [El Diario] El NYPD mató a mi hijo. Ahora la comisionada Tisch quiere que el policía culpable quede libre

    Mi hijo, Allan Feliz, fue brutalmente asesinado por el entonces sargento Jonathan Rivera Ninguna madre está preparada para enterrar a su hijo. El dolor es insoportable. Pero lo que hace aún más difícil el sufrimiento es cuando los responsables nunca rinden cuentas, cuando la justicia se retrasa y se niega repetidamente. En el caso de mi hijo, ahora la comisionada Jessica Tisch del Departamento de Policía de Nueva York está a punto de ser completamente descartada. Mi hijo, Allan Feliz, fue brutalmente asesinado por el entonces sargento del Departamento de Policía de Nueva York, Jonathan Rivera, en 2019. Tras ser detenido por no llevar puesto el cinturón de seguridad (que lo llevaba puesto), Allan fue detenido ilegalmente, golpeado, electrocutado, baleado y abandonado en la calle con los genitales expuestos por los agentes Barrett, Almanzar y Rivera del Departamento de Policía de Nueva York. Durante casi seis años, mi familia ha vivido un infierno: estamos traumatizados, de luto y luchando por la responsabilidad más básica: que Rivera sea despedido por dispararle a Allan a quemarropa en el pecho. Nos hemos enfrentado a un sinfín de obstáculos, retrasos y excusas por parte del Departamento de Policía de Nueva York y la administración Adams en cada etapa del proceso disciplinario, un patrón que ahora sabemos que es demasiado común para las víctimas de violencia policial. Sin embargo, tras dejar este caso languidecer en su escritorio durante casi cinco meses, la Comisionada de Policía Tisch planea ahora revocar la decisión de su propia subcomisionada que deja a Rivera en libertad sin medidas disciplinarias. Esta decisión preliminar no sólo es increíblemente cruel e injusta, sino también cobarde. Allan, mi primogénito, siempre fue un niño de mamá. No pasaba un día sin decirme que me quería. Era un padre devoto de su hijastra, Kilsi, y estaba muy emocionado de dar la bienvenida al mundo a su hijo, Eli, tan solo seis meses antes de que lo mataran. Gracias a Rivera, mi nieto se ve obligado a crecer sin un padre. Cuando llegué a este país, realmente creí que la policía estaba aquí para protegernos. En cambio, vi cómo Rivera ascendía a teniente después de matar a mi hijo, bajo la supervisión de la alcaldesa Adams. Eso no es protección. Eso es corrupción. Es un sistema construido para protegerse a sí mismo, no a nosotros. Desde que Jessica Tisch se convirtió en la sexta comisionada del Departamento de Policía de Nueva York (NYPD) tras el asesinato de Allan, ha intentado convencernos de que le importan la reforma y la rendición de cuentas, pero sus acciones demuestran lo contrario. Revocar el veredicto de su propia comisionada adjunta tras un juicio completo ?donde el testimonio de Rivera se consideró poco creíble? es solo otro ejemplo de la profunda corrupción que hunde al NYPD . Allan no fue el primer neoyorquino al que el teniente Rivera hirió, ni el último. Disparó a un adolescente antes de matar a Allan y desde entonces tiene múltiples denuncias por mala conducta. Debería haber sido despedido hace mucho tiempo, pero en cambio, sigue aterrorizando a nuestras comunidades. Si a Tisch realmente le importara la justicia y la seguridad de los neoyorquinos, habría acatado el veredicto de culpabilidad de su propia comisionada adjunta y habría despedido a Rivera sin demora. Está claro a quién le debe su lealtad: proteger a los policías abusivos y sus propios intereses, en lugar de a los de neoyorquinos como nosotros. Le escribí a la comisionada Tisch en mayo , apelando a su humanidad, de madre a madre. Le rogué que hiciera lo correcto. Semanas después, envió una respuesta de una sola frase y continuó alargando un proceso ya de por sí insoportablemente largo. La falta de respeto es asombrosa. La vida de Allan importaba. El dolor y el sufrimiento de mi familia importan. Pero para la comisionada Tisch, parece que nada de eso importa más que proteger a un policía asesino. Solo pedimos que el Departamento de Policía de Nueva York cumpla su propia decisión. Solo que el agente que mató a mi hijo pierda el trabajo que nunca debió haber tenido. Comisionada Tisch, aún tiene la oportunidad de demostrar algo de valentía: despida a Jonathan Rivera. Proteja a los neoyorquinos, no a los agentes que nos hacen daño. Mery Verdeja es la mamá de Allan Feliz. Esta es su opinión personal sobre el caso. _____________ NYPD Killed My Son. Now Commissioner Tisch Wants to Let the Cop Who Did It Walk Free. No mother is ever prepared to bury her child. The grief is unbearable. But what makes the pain even harder to carry is when those responsible are never held accountable—when justice is repeatedly delayed and denied. In my son’s case, now it’s on the brink of being discarded entirely by NYPD Commissioner Jessica Tisch. My son, Allan Feliz, was brutally murdered by NYPD then-sergeant Jonathan Rivera in 2019. After being pulled over for not wearing his seatbelt (which he was), Allan was illegally detained, beaten, tased, shot, and left bleeding out on the street with his genitals exposed by NYPD officers Barrett, Almanzar, and Rivera. For nearly six years, my family has been living in hell—we’re traumatized, grieving and fighting for the most basic accountability: for Rivera to be fired for shooting Allan at close range in the chest. We’ve faced endless obstacles, delays, and excuses from the NYPD and the Adams administration at every step of the discipline process - a pattern we now know is far too common for victims of police violence. However, after letting this case languish on her desk for nearly five months, Police Commissioner Tisch is now planning to overturn her own deputy commissioner’s own ruling to let Rivera walk free with no discipline.  This preliminary decision is not just incredibly cruel and unjust - it is cowardly.  Allan, my first-born, was always a mama’s boy. He never went a day without telling me he loved me. He was a devoted father to his stepdaughter, Kilsi, and he was so excited to welcome his son, Eli, into the world just six months before he was killed. Because of Rivera, my my grandson is forced to grow up without a dad.  When I arrived in this country, I truly believed the police were here to protect us. Instead, I watched Rivera be promoted to lieutenant after killing my son, under Mayor Adams’ watch. That’s not protection. That’s corruption. That’s a system built to protect itself, not us. Ever since Jessica Tisch became the sixth NYPD commissioner since Allan was killed, she has been trying to convince us that she cares about reform and accountability, but her actions say the opposite. Overturning her own deputy commissioner’s verdict after a full trial—where Rivera’s own testimony was deemed not credible–is just another example of the corruption that runs deep in the NYPD .  Allan was not the first New Yorker that Lt. Rivera hurt - nor the last. He shot a teenager before killing Allan and has multiple misconduct complaints against him since. He should have been fired long ago, but instead, he is still terrorizing our communities.  If Tisch truly cared about justice and safety for New Yorkers, she would have followed her own Deputy Commissioner’s guilty verdict and fired Rivera without delay. It is clear where her allegiance lies: with protecting abusive cops and her own interest instead of New Yorkers like us. I wrote to Commissioner Tisch in May , appealing to her humanity, mother-to-mother. I begged her to do the right thing. She sent a one-sentence response weeks later and continued to drag out an already excruciatingly long process. The disrespect is staggering.  Allan’s life mattered. My family’s pain and suffering matters. But to Commissioner Tisch, it seems none of it matters more than protecting a killer cop. All we’re asking for is the NYPD to follow its own ruling. Just for the officer who killed my son to lose the job he never should have had in the first place. Commissioner Tisch, you still have a chance to show some courage: fire Jonathan Rivera. Protect New Yorkers, not the officers who harm us. Mery Verdeja is the mother of Allan Feliz.

bottom of page