top of page

Search Results

Search this site

419 results found with an empty search

  • Family of Allan Feliz Call On Mayor Adams To End Corruption And Hold NYPD Lt. Rivera Accountable For Murder

    Media contact: Eliel Cruz press@justicecommittee.org FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE Family of Allan Feliz Call On Mayor Adams To End Corruption And Hold NYPD Lt. Rivera Accountable For Murder   New York, NY, October 18, 2024–– Yesterday, the siblings, mother, five-year-old son and partner of Allan Feliz were joined by community groups and, Councilmember Carmen De La Rosa, and Executive Director of the NYC Council Black Latino Asian Caucus Malik James, in front of Gracie Mansion to call on the mayor and the NYPD Commissioner to fire Lt. Jonathan Rivera for killing Mr. Feliz in 2019. Next month, Lt. Rivera will face a disciplinary trial at One Police Plaza on Nov. 12, 13, and 15, 2024. The Feliz family and their supporters are calling on Adams administration to heed the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) recommendations and fire Lt. Rivera.  “For five years, my family has fought for justice and maneuvered this complex system that works to protect abusive cops. Finally, a disciplinary trial will show what we’ve known all along that Lt. Rivera should be fired for the murder of my brother,” said Samy Feliz, brother of Allan Feliz.  “Every day Lt. Rivera stays on the force, New Yorkers' lives are at risk, and our communities are robbed of resources as his pay continues to go up year after year. I’m asking New Yorkers to come out to witness the trial, stand with my family, and call on Mayor Adams and the next Police Commissioner, the sixth in this long process, to do what’s right and fire Lt. Rivera.” The disciplinary trial will take place in the midst of multiple corruption scandals within the Adams administration and the NYPD. The Feliz family and their supporters highlighted the NYPD’s pattern of protecting abusive officers - which has worsened under Mayor Adams - as a fundamental part of the culture of impunity and corruption of the administration. Earlier this year, then-Police Commissioner Edward Caban and Mayor Adams allowed the officers who killed Kawaski Trawick to walk, without facing any consequences, in spite of CCRB substantiated fireable charges. A recent ProPublica exposé exposed massive NYPD coverups  of misconduct  during the Adams administration. “Let’s be clear: the corruption of the Adams administration goes far beyond favor-trading and illegal donations and what the Feliz family has had to suffer is part of it,” said David Galarza, a representative of the Justice Committee.  “The culture of impunity and corruption that Eric Adams brought to City Hall comes directly from the NYPD. And the NYPD’s pattern of protecting abusive officers has gotten completely out of control since he became mayor. New Yorkers are demanding that this pattern end with Lt. Rivera. The mayor and Commissioner must promptly fire him from the NYPD once the discipline trial has concluded.” “Allan Feliz was a brother, father, son, and a neighbor whose life was cut short in an undignified manner by those sworn to protect and serve,” said Council Member Carmen De La Rosa.  “After five years, progress was made toward justice, accountability, and transparency. This progress has been put at risk by the volatility and uncertainty of the changing leadership of the NYPD, prolonging the suffering of the Feliz family. Lt. Rivera’s discipline trial must move forward without further delay and fire Lt. Rivera swiftly after it’s over so that we may close a chapter for this family and not absolve the NYPD of the responsibility to those they serve.”  OTHER QUOTES: “Today we mark 5 years since the murder of Allan Feliz at the hands of the NYPD,” said City Council Deputy Speaker Diana Ayala . “Since then, we’ve been calling for justice for his senseless death and for Sgt. Jonathan Rivera to be held responsible for his reckless actions that day. A simple traffic stop should have not ended with his death.  And while there has been some movement in getting a disciplinary trial for Lt. Rivera, we will continue to call for his dismissal and get the justice Allan Feliz and his family deserve. Until that day comes, we will continue to stand united with the Feliz family.” “Next month, the NYPD commissioner will again be presented with an opportunity to hold a member of the police department accountable for excessive force charges substantiated by the Civilian Complaint Review Board," said Malik James, Executive Director of the City Council's Black, Latino and Asian Caucus . "Lieutenant Jonathan Rivera is a threat to New Yorkers and does not belong on our streets. He has a history of at least 41 misconduct allegations and six misconduct lawsuits that not only dishonor his commitment to keeping New Yorkers safe, but that also make him a liability to the NYPD and the City of New York. For Allan Feliz, the Feliz family, complainants against Lt. Rivera and the city at-large, the commissioner must allow next month's discipline trial to proceed without further interruption or delay, and must terminate Lt. Rivera following its conclusion." “It is truly abhorrent that almost half a decade later after Allan Feliz was unjustly killed, that his family continues to fight for even a sliver of justice,” said Robert Willis, Justice Advocate Coordinator at LatinoJustice PRLDEF . “The continued delay and obstruction of cases by NYPD to shield its officers is an abuse to our community. We stand with the Feliz family and uplift their demand that Mayor Adams fire Lt. Jonathan Rivera and vow to continue our work to ensure cops are held accountable for their actions."  "The NYPD disciplinary system shields officers who violate the constitutional rights of New Yorkers and it is time for this to end,” said Samah Sisay, staff attorney for the Center for Constitutional Rights.  “Five years ago, then Sergeant Jonathan Rivera murdered Allan Feliz. Instead of firing him, the NYPD rewarded his terrible actions by promoting him to lieutenant. Lt. Rivera must be held accountable and fired."  ### Background: On October 17, 2019, NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera (who was a sergeant at the time) and Officers Edward Barrett and Michelle Almanzar pulled Allan Feliz over on the corner of E 211 St and Bainbridge Ave for allegedly not wearing a seatbelt. Bodyworn camera (bwc) footage shows officers acknowledging that Mr. Feliz was wearing his seatbelt, but rather than allowing him to drive away, the officers escalated by illegally detaining him and attacking him. Lt. Rivera climbed into the passenger side of the car, tasered, beat and threatened to shoot Mr. Feliz, and then shot him point blank in the chest. After Mr. Feliz was shot, Officer Barrett yanked Mr. Feliz’s limp body from the car, exposing his genitals.  None of the officers immediately covered Mr. Feliz or provided medical aid. Instead, they left Mr. Feliz to bleed out, cuffed, and exposed.  After years of delays  and obstruction, in May 2023, the Civilian Complaint Review Board (CCRB) substantiated  fireable charges against Lt. Rivera for the killing of Alan Feliz. The NYPD delayed the process, which led to 39 elected officials sending a letter  in September 2023 t o Mayor Adams and then NYPD Police Commissioner Edward Caban calling on the administration not to interfere. Finally, after multiple rallies and press conferences putting pressure on the administration, CCRB scheduled the trial for November. The Feliz family is calling for the Mayor and NYPD commissioner to make a swift decision post trial that accepts the CCRB recommendation to fire Lt. Rivera. About the Justice Committee: Since the 1980s, the  Justice Committee  (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice.

  • Parents of Antonio Williams Slam CCRB Decision Not To Bring Charges Against Officers Who Killed Their Son During an Improper Stop

    FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE   Press Contact:  Kristine Mikkelsen,  kmikkelsen@spitfirestrategies.com   Parents of Antonio Williams Slam CCRB Decision Not To Bring Charges Against Officers Who Killed Their Son During an Improper Stop   New York –  Today, the family of Antonio Williams learned that the Civilian Complaint Review Board has decided not to substantiate disciplinary charges against Officers Robert Wichers, Keith Figueroa, Brian Mahon, and Sgt. Jase D. Valentino for unconstitutionally stopping, chasing, beating and shooting Antonio Williams and then failing to render aid on the night of September 29, 2019.    Shawn and Gladys Williams, father and stepmother of Antonio Williams issued the following statement:   For the past five years, our family has faced unimaginable suffering because of the NYPD’s murder of our son. This outrageous decision by the CCRB has amplified that pain to a degree we didn’t know was possible. It’s clear the CCRB didn’t look at the evidence or the law and just went with the NYPD’s narrative, even though it kept changing and the officers’ testimonies make no sense.   Today we learned that the statements of Officers Mahon and Wichers contradict video evidence. Mohan has a history of at least 47 misconduct allegations, including substantiated charges for lying, unjust stops, excessive force and more - and Officer  Wichers has at least 29 misconduct allegations. It’s mind-boggling how the CCRB Board thought their statements were credible.   Valentino, Mahon and Figueroa were so reckless they shot at Antonio and three cops from 60 feet away in the dark and in the process, they killed one of their own - similar to what happened during the recent L train incident. Yet somehow the CCRB decided this is not excessive force.   Mahon, Beddows and Figueroa did everything in their power to try to save Officer Mulkeen, but left Antonio to bleed out in the street. Valentino didn’t even check Antonio’s pulse when he handcuffed our son. Calling for an ambulance is not enough. The NYPD patrol guide says cops are supposed to call an ambulance and then provide assistance. How is this not failing to render aid?    Our son should be alive! The Adams administration is corrupt from bottom to top. The NYPD discipline system is rigged to protect cops. The message the CCRB’s corrupt decision sends is clear: Cops can lie, break the law, and kill New Yorkers without consequences. Our family will continue to fight to eliminate this corruption and win real safety for our communities in Antonio’s name.   Loyda Colon (they/them) Executive Director of Justice Committee and member of Communities United for Police Reform issued the following statement:   “This Sunday will mark five years since NYPD officers unconstitutionally stopped, chased, beat and murdered Antonio Williams, a Black man waiting for a cab. The cops shot 15 bullets so recklessly that they also killed a cop. The CCRB’s decision to not substantiate charges against these officers is wrong and in line with Mayor Adams’ attempt to manipulate the discipline process through his dismissal of its former Interim Chair, Arva Rice.    The Williams family, Justice Committee and the family’s attorneys have serious concerns about the inconsistencies in the CCRB’s investigation and the Board decision, which values NYPD lies over video evidence and the law.   Reckless, violent shootings by the NYPD–like Antonio’s and like the recent shooting in Brownsville– will only increase until we remove discipline authority from the police commissioner and completely transform the police discipline system and NYC’s approach to public safety.”   David B. Rankin of Beldock Levine & Hoffman, LLP, attorney for the Williams Family:   “Waiting for a cab is not a crime. Talking to your friend is not a crime. These officers had no reason to stop Antonio Williams and it is a shame the CCRB didn't see this."   Background   On September 29, 2019, Antonio Williams was standing on the street, waiting for a taxi, when plainclothes officers jumped out of an unmarked car. NYPD officers chased, tackled, and beat Antonio. Shortly after, they recklessly opened fire,  killing Williams  and an NYPD officer, Brian Mulkeen, in a hail of 15 bullets – some shot from over 60 feet away. For almost two years, the NYPD provided no explanation for why officers chased Williams in the middle of the night and have never articulated the reasonable suspicion required to stop Antonio.    In November 2020,  security footage  supporting the family’s statements that the NYPD engaged in an unconstitutional stop and unnecessarily escalated the interaction was released. In September 2021 the Civilian Complaint Review Board told the Williams family they would investigate the officers responsible for stopping, brutalizing, and killing Antonio Williams.    On Tuesday, September 24, 2024, nearly five years after Antonio was killed, the CCRB informed the family that it chose not to substantiate charges against the officers who killed him.   CCRB Board’s decision is part of a long and dangerous pattern in which officers recklessly and unjustly kill and abuse New Yorkers, and the police discipline system shields them from facing consequences for their actions, which is made clear by a  damning report  released yesterday.    ### ###

  • NYPD Corrupt Commissioner Caban forced to resign. Mayor Adams and Other Top Cops Should Follow.

    Media Contact  Yul-san Liem yul-san@justicecommittee.org September 12, 2024 – In response to the resignation of Police Commissioner Edward Caban, the Justice Committee released the following statement from Executive Director Loyda Colón (they, them): “Good riddance! We welcome the forced resignation of corrupt NYPD Commissioner Edward Caban. Mayor Eric Adams and other top NYPD officials should follow. In his almost three years as mayor, Adams has accelerated the NYPD’s 180-year history of corruption to crisis levels in the form of rampant racial profiling, with officers unconstitutionally stopping-and-frisking more New Yorkers than in almost a decade. Mayor Adams’ consistent refusal to discipline abusive cops means misconduct complaints are at their highest since the Bloomberg era, while the NYPD is burying approximately half of the substantiated complaints investigated and referred for discipline by the Civilian Complaint Review Board . On top of this, Mayor Adams’ primitive caveman approach to addressing poverty and other social issues has expanded the criminalization of unhoused, mentally ill, low-income and other vulnerable New Yorkers. Mayor Adams needs to go, too: New Yorkers need leaders who will prioritize our needs over their pockets and political ambitions and we must stand for nothing less.” ###

  • Family of Andre Mayfield Reacts to Viewing Footage of His Killing by NYPD

    Media Contact  Yul-san Liem press@justicecommittee.org September 4, 2024 – After meeting with the Attorney General’s Office and viewing partial bodyworn camera footage and security footage of the NYPD killing of Andre Mayfield, his father, Joseph Mayfield, released the following statement: "Losing Andre was hard enough. Viewing the video of his death doubles the pain my family feels.  My son clearly wasn’t well at that moment and the officers should have realized this. Any reasonable person would have. Andre was a quiet young man who kept to himself. He liked playstation games and going for walks.  This was a young man who needed care. Why didn’t the NYPD try harder to save my son’s life? Why didn’t Officers Elijah A. Chaer  and Jefferson Bellevue try to deploy their tasers again? The officers could have made so many different choices to de-escalate the situation, but instead they gunned Andre down in under a minute. We appreciate that the Attorney General’s Office showed us partial video before releasing it publicly, but we’re disappointed that they did not show us the full video, as agreed. Only seeing partial video leaves us with more questions: Did the officers even try to provide medical aid? What is the reason for keeping the rest of the video from us?" ###

  • NYPD Disciplinary Trial Finally Scheduled for Cop Who Killing Allan Feliz after Four and a Half Years of Delays

    MEDIA CONTACT: Eliel Cruz, press@justicecommittee.org FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:  NYPD Disciplinary Trial Finally Scheduled for Cop Who Killing Allan Feliz after Four and a Half Years of Delays  September 3, 2024–– At a closed court conference last Thursday, the NYPD disciplinary trial was scheduled for Lt. Jonathan Rivera, who shot and killed Washington Heights father, Allan Feliz, after illegally detaining him during a car stop in 2019. This step forward comes after four and a half years of advocacy by the Feliz family and their supporters while the NYPD stalled the Civilian Complaint Review Board’s investigation for years, refusing to serve CCRB-substantiated charges to Lt. Rivera for over a year and engaged in other delay tactics , a standard practice across all police killing cases  “Finally, after fighting for almost five years as the administration, the NYPD, administration, Lieutenants Union, stalled and played games,” said Samy Feliz, the brother of Allan Feliz.  “We are relieved that we finally have a date for the trial, but it never should have taken this long and any further delays will be completely unacceptable. My family knows this fight is far from over. We will be at One Police Plaza every day of the trial, even though we will have to miss work and disrupt our lives, because Lt. Rivera is a threat to public safety and he should have been fired years ago. We’re calling on New Yorkers to join us. All New Yorkers should be afraid while Lt. Rivera remains a police officer and we cannot rest until Mayor Adams and Commissioner Caban fire Rivera from the NYPD.” “The level of disrespect for the Feliz family and the lack of remorse from Lt. Rivera, his police union attorneys and the NYPD are outrageous,” said Loyda Colon, Executive Director of the Justice Committee.  “By the time Rivera’s discipline trial begins, it will be over five years since the NYPD brutally shot Allan and then dragged him into the street to bleed out with his genitals exposed. The Feliz family has remained steadfast through four and a half years of delays and obstruction. The trial date is a step forward, but Rivera - along with the other officers involved in Allan’s murder - should have been fired the day he climbed into Allan’s car on top of a passenger, threatened Allan with deadly force, and then beat, tased and shot him point blank in the chest. In every one of these cases, the City and the NYPD employ delay tactics to protect officers instead of New Yorkers, wear families down and deter them and their supporters from fighting. Mayor Adams and NYPD Commissioner Caban must ensure this process moves forward and they must fire Lt. Jonathan Rivera for killing Allan Feliz. Lt. Rivera’s discipline trial is scheduled to take place on Nov. 12, 13, and 15, 2024 at One Police Plaza. Other Quotes “This is welcomed news and a positive step forward for the Feliz family who continue to endure the pain and loss of their beloved Allan at the hands of the NYPD,” said Deputy Speaker of the City Council Diana Ayala.  “Although the needle has moved slightly in this case, we must recognize the continued obstruction into disciplinary processes in pending cases only undermine public safety efforts. New Yorkers deserve transparency and accountability, which are paramount to public trust and safety. We look forward to justice being served.”  “Allan Feliz was a brother, father, son, and a neighbor to many," said Council Member Carmen De La Rosa. "His life was cut short in an undignified manner by those sworn to protect and serve. This process was arduous and unnecessarily lengthy — four and a half years dedicated to confronting delays and obstructions that inhibit the public from proper police transparency. We celebrate this step in the journey of justice as the admin trial dates are confirmed and hope other families impacted by this unjust system of police brutality can have their voices heard as well. We continue to stand by the Feliz family until justice is served and Lieutenant Rivera is fired,” “It’s beyond belief that it has taken the NYPD almost half a decade and only after the threat of being sued, to finally serve charges and set a trial date for the officer who shot and killed Allan Feliz during an unjust traffic stop,” said Norma Esquivel, Senior Counsel at LatinoJustice PRLDEF.  “NYPD has and continues to obstruct discipline to shield its officers from abusing and killing our community members. This abhorrent practice is far too common and continues to stall many other disciplinary cases. LatinoJustice vows to continue our work to ensure cops are held accountable and put an end to this illicit behavior by the NYPD.”  ”Lt. Rivera should have been fired years ago, but we now have a chance to see an accountability process through,” said Council Member Alexa Aviles.  “With dates set for November, the CCRB must be allowed to conduct their work without any departmental interference. I call on the Mayor and Commissioner to allow this trial to proceed. To delay any further is to deny the Feliz family the fair and just process they deserve.”   ### Background: On October 17, 2019, NYPD Lt. Jonathan Rivera (who was a sergeant at the time) and Officers Edward Barrett and Michelle Almanzar pulled Allan Feliz over on the corner of E 211 St and Bainbridge Ave for allegedly not wearing a seatbelt. Bodyworn camera (bwc) footage shows officers acknowledging that Mr. Feliz was wearing his seatbelt, but rather than allowing him to drive away, the officers escalated by illegally detaining him and attacking him. Lt. Rivera climbed into the passenger side of the car, tasered, beat and threatened to shoot Mr. Feliz, and then shot him point blank in the chest. After Mr. Feliz was shot, Officer Barrett yanked Mr. Feliz’s limp body from the car, exposing his genitals.  None of the officers immediately covered Mr. Feliz or provided medical aid. Instead, they left Mr. Feliz to bleed out, cuffed, and exposed.  About the Justice Committee: Since the 1980s, the  Justice Committee  (JC) has been dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City. The heart of our work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police. By building solidarity with other anti-racist, immigrant and people of color-led organizations, the Justice Committee seeks to contribute to a broad-based movement for racial, social, and economic justice.

  • Justice Committee Testimony Urging City Council To Vote No on Randy Mastro Appointment

    My name is Donavon Taveras. I was born and raised in Bushwick and am the Community Safety Coordinator for the Justice Committee, a 40-year-old grassroots organization that is dedicated to building a movement against police violence and systemic racism in New York City.  The heart of JC’s work is organizing and uplifting the leadership of families who have lost loved ones to the police and survivors of police violence. We empower our community to deter police violence, hold law enforcement accountable, and build people-led community safety through grassroots organizing campaigns, community empowerment, political education, our CopWatch program, and by developing safety mechanisms and projects that decrease reliance on police.  It is through this lens and expertise that the Justice Committee strongly opposes the appointment of Randy Mastro as corporation counsel. Given Mr. Mastro’s long history of supporting racist policing and other racist policies and as part of the Giuliani administration, his return to NYC government as corporation counsel will only serve to further Mayor Adams’ agenda to erode police accountability and build New York City as a police state. A Guilani loyalist to the core, Mastro played an essential role in the administration under which the NYPD murdered Anthony Baez, Antonio Rozario, Hilton Vega, Yong Xin Huang, Amadou Diallo, Anibal Carrasquillo, Frankie Arzuaga, Nicholas Heyward Jr. (with whose families the Justice Committee organized) and which shielded the officers who took their lives from. Mastro defended Guiliani’s violent broken windows policing that plagued Black and Latine communities in the 90s and set the stage for the further ballooning of unconstitutional stop-and-frisk under Mayor Bloomberg, which is resurging under Eric Adams. Mastro backed Guiliani up in his dismissal of police accountability and transparency recommendations of the Task Force on Police/Community Relations, including the dismal of a 48-hour rule (which allowed NYPD officers involved in a shooting to refuse to speak with investigators until two days after the fact) and more rigorous screenings of new police officers. While Mastro may be an experienced litigator, he has used his legal knowledge to undermine public safety and health. In both his public service and private practice, his record demonstrates his inability to serve the interests of our City as corporation counsel, a role that requires a commitment to justice, equity, and the public interest. In his private practice, Mastro fought against public health and safety initiatives such as housing individuals who were homeless during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, worked to keep housing and shelter from being built in the Upper East Side and litigated to weaken the city’s rent stabilization laws as well as to end New York State’s eviction moratorium. Time and time again, Mastro has proven to put the interest of corporations, corrupt politicians, and police over the needs of the public's health, safety, and well-being. Since he took office as mayor, Eric Adams has been working diligently to expand the NYPD’s power and role in New Yorkers lives and shield abusive officers from accountability. Adams’ sham charter revision process and proposed charter changes to make the process for passing public safety legislation more difficult is case in point, as is the systemic burying of police misconduct complaints  during his tenure as mayor and his refusal to ensure accountability for the officers who killed Kawaski Trawick in his home in under two minutes, a case in which substantiated fireable charges were dismissed because of NYPD delays and obstruction.  With the families of Win Rozario, Allan Feliz, Delrawn Small, and Antonio Williams in the midst of fighting for the officers who killed their loved ones to be fired and Civilian Complaint Review Board investigations or prosecutions pending, we’re deeply concerned about what it would mean for Mastro to take on the role of corporation council, especially given that this position is tasked with representing the CCRB when police union attorneys use bogus legal maneuvers to try to shield their clients and delay administrative trials. If his appointment is confirmed, Mastro would be at the legal helm as the Adams administration continues to erode police accountability while working to expand the NYPD’s power to use force against and involuntarily remove from public space and hospitalize New Yorkers without suspicion of criminality.   As an organization dedicated to true safety for all New Yorkers, we urge the City Council to reject Mastro’s nomination.

  • Iris Baez Testimony Against Randy Mastro Appointment

    My name is Iris Baez, I am the mother of Anthony Baez, who was murdered by NYPD Officer Francis Livoti in 1994 with a chokehold that was banned by the NYPD, even back then. I’ve fought for over three decades to try to make sure no other families have to suffer as I have. This Eric Adams is unbelievable! He’s doing everything in his power to take us back to the Guiliani era and make things even worse. Trying to bring Randy Mastro back in just his latest scheme. With his new Cop City, the games with the City Charter, and the crackdown on New Yorkers who can’t afford subway fare or have mental illness, Mayor Adam’s administration is shaping up to be Giuliani 2.0. We cannot allow this to happen.  As someone who lived through Guilani, I’m here today to tell the City Council - you must reject Mayor Adams’ appointment of Randy Mastro as New York City’s corporation counsel.  Back then, Mastro was rightfully called “Guiliani’s pitbull.” He spent years defending racist, abusive policing by Guiliani’s NYPD. Mastro was Guliani’s Chief of Staff when my son, Anthony, Nicholas Heyward Jr, Anthony Rosario, and Hilton Vega were murdered by the NYPD.  He defended Giuliani’s Broken Windows Policing that targeted Black and Latinx communities, like mine in the South Bronx. As Deputy Mayor, he joined Guilani in mocking and dismissing nearly all of the 1998 recommendations of the Task Force on Police/Community Relations. Allowing Randy Mastro to become corp counsel in charge of 800 lawyers would be a disaster for New York City. It would mean creating a legal regime that supports NYPD excessive force, racial profiling and the criminalization of poor and low-income communities of color. I urge the City Council to reject Mayor Adams’ appointment of Randy Mastro to Corp Counsel.

  • Under Mayor Adams, CCRB Report Shows NYPD Refusal To Discipline Abusive Cops

    Media Contact  Eliel Cruz  press@justicecommittee.org Under Mayor Adams, CCRB Report Shows NYPD Refusal To Discipline Abusive Cops In response to CCRB’s 2024 semi-annual report, the Justice Committee released the following statement: “ Mayor Adams has become the police crime mayor, emboldening the NYPD and cops to routinely disregard the rights of New Yorkers and engage in violence and disrespect without consequence,” said Justice Committee’s executive director Loyda Colon (they/them). “The data released underscores what New Yorkers already know: under Eric Adams, the NYPD is increasingly a violent, rogue agency that acts with impunity and sets its own rules, regardless of the law, to shirk any pretense of accountability.  “Under Adams, there have been more cop misconduct complaints in the first six months of this year than the first half of any year since 2012, an increase from last year’s reporting which was also a ten-year high. In spite of this, CCRB was forced to close 616 complaints because of the mayor’s budget cuts.  “In addition to his budget cuts to the oversight agency, Mayor Adams has enabled the NYPD to shield even more cops from discipline by letting them rig the system: Instead of 18 months that the CCRB has to investigate and file most misconduct charges under the law, the NYPD has unilaterally reduced that time by at least 5 months by refusing to review certain cases that are filed within 2-3 months of the statutory deadline and delaying evidence from being turned over to the CCRB by at least 3 months. This is on top of the NYPD exploiting other rules in bad-faith to bury discipline cases against cops for egregious brutality.  “It’s clear that the NYPD is doing everything possible to keep its officers from facing accountability and discipline and is emboldened by the support they receive from Mayor Adams. The majority of New Yorkers filing complaints are Black and Latinx. As discriminatory and abusive policing runs rampant and CCRB complaints skyrocket, the CCRB must be able to investigate all of the complaints filed with adequate timing, funding, and power to do so. This is a crisis of police violence and New Yorkers deserve more from our city government - cops should be fired for misconduct, but Mayor Adams has given them free reign to violate our rights.” Background Following the NYPD’s refusal to turn over body camera footage for over 20 months until forced to by court order in the 2019 killing of Kawaski Trawick, the CCRB and NYPD entered into a new memorandum of understanding in which the NYPD agreed to turn over body camera footage and other evidence to the CCRB within 90 days. But this MOU has largely allowed the NYPD to institutionalize a 3-month delay, which essentially negates the first 3 months of the 18-month statute of limitations (SOL) that CCRB is required to meet to bring discipline charges for most incidents that don’t meet the SOL’s crime exception (which allows discipline cases to be brought after 18 months when there are penal law equivalents to the misconduct). Additionally, the NYPD is unilaterally refusing to review any charges that are brought against its officers within 60 days of the expiration of the SOL. With 90 days taken at the beginning of the SOL and at least 60 at the end, CCRB effectively has a year for its investigations, all while facing budget cuts that undermine their investigations of all complaints made by New Yorkers.

  • Over 70 Organizations Denounce Mayor Adams' Last-Minute Scheme to Change City Charter, Call for Charter Revision Commission to Reject Attempt to Include on November Ballot

    Letter from 70+ Organizations to Mayor Adams & Charter Revision Commission July 17, 2024 Mayor Adams                         Charter Revision Commissioners City Hall                                  charterinfo@citycharter.nyc.gov New York, NY 10007 Dear Mayor Adams & Charter Revision Commission members, We, the undersigned, represent a broad cross-section of New Yorkers from every background, community, and borough. We understand that Charter Revision Commissions are among this city’s most sacredly important undertakings; they have been used to reconfigure city government and balance power relationships to produce a more perfect union. All of us have an interest in a New York City Charter that is thoughtful and deliberative, while modernizing governance and creating a city that works for all New Yorkers. It is in this spirit that we urge you to refrain from placing any charter revision initiatives on the ballot in November 2024. The mayor announced this Charter Revision Commission on May 21. On June 24, after only five public input sessions within a two-week period, at which only a small handful of New Yorkers spoke, the commission issued a preliminary report that made a series of recommendations addressing “fiscal responsibility,” “public safety,” “minority-and-women owned businesses,” “modernization,” and “other proposals.” A July 12 deadline was established for the receipt of written testimony, and according to the commission’s website, the commission will vote on final ballot language at their final meeting on July 25. We submit that the 2024 Charter Revision Commission and the subsequent preliminary report were created in poor faith and are antidemocratic: ●      It is widely understood that this Charter Revision Commission’s timing and primary purpose is to enable the mayor to block the New York City Council’s advice and consent ballot measure from being considered by voters in November. The measure would allow the Council the opportunity to consider more mayoral appointments for city commissioners, increasing voter transparency over mayoral appointments. While we don’t take a position on the Council’s proposal, we know that there is no mandate or public call for this commission; it seems to simply be a retaliatory and preemptive attempt to attack the City Council’s role in government and to further expand mayoral power. ●      The commission does not represent a broadly-interested cross-section of impartial New York City stakeholders. Instead it has been stacked with appointees characterized by their close ties to the mayor. ●      The timeline for the commission has been unreasonably rushed and compressed. New Yorkers have barely had time to learn what a charter revision is let alone figure out how to meaningfully participate in it. ●      The hearings have been poorly attended and underpublicized. The commission’s first hearing, on June 5, was so hastily thrown together that members of the public only found out about it the night before, resulting in only a handful of attendees. In fact, less than half of the commissioners attended the first hearing of their own commission. The commission’s hearing in Staten Island on June 25 featured just five in-person testimonial statements, and took place in an auditorium that can only be described as nearly empty. ●      Absent robust public debate, testimony, and data, it can only be assumed that the recommendations in the preliminary report were either conceived in a matter of days or in advance of the hearings. Meanwhile, the report left advocates, experts, and concerned citizens just 13 business days to read, research, and respond to its recommendations before public testimony closed on July 12. No process this harried, disorganized, and non-transparent could possibly produce charter revisions that are thoughtfully considered, informed by the public, and placed on the ballot with any democratic legitimacy. The process has been opaque since it was launched, with hearings and meetings publicized in a piece-meal, largely last-minute fashion. As of July 16, there is still no information on the commission’s website to indicate when the final report and recommendations would be released for consideration by the public and commissioners. This charter revision process is unbecoming of the mayor, our city, and our charter itself. The charter is the heart of New York City’s governing structure. Given the many serious concerns, we urge you to refrain from placing any items on the November 2024 ballot.  Absent any apparent emergency, heart surgery is performed with patience, deliberation, and care, none of which is to be found in this process. New York City should be an example of how good, transparent, and participatory government should function, and how real democracy should flourish. Sincerely, Ali Forney Center ALIGN: The Alliance for a Greater New York Alliance for Quality Education Anthony Baez Foundation Arab American Association of New York CAAAV: Organizing Asian Communities Campaign Zero Caribbean Equality Project Center for Constitutional Rights Center for Law and Social Justice at Medgar Evers College Center for Popular Democracy Churches United for Fair Housing Committee of Interns and Residents SEIU Common Justice Communities United for Police Reform Community Connections for Youth Community Education Council 14 Community for a Cause Defending Rights & Dissent Drug Policy Alliance DRUM - Desis Rising Up & Moving El Puente Equality for Flatbush Faith in New York Families For Freedom Freedom Agenda Housing Works Immigrant Defense Project IntegrateNYC Jews for Racial and Economic Justice (JFREJ) Jim Owles Liberal Democratic Club Justice and Beyond Justice Committee Katal Center for Equity, Health, and Justice LatinoJustice PRLDEF Legal Action Center Make the Road New York Malcom X Grassroots Movement Mekong NYC Met Council on Housing Metropolitan Community Church of New York Middle Collegiate Church MomsRising Together Muslim Community Network National LGBTQ Task Force Action Fund Neighbors Together New Kings Democrats New Settlement Parent Action Committee New York Civil Liberties Union New York Communities for Change New York Progressive Action Network North Star Fund NY Working Families Party NYC Anti Violence Project OAAARS Parole Preparation Project Parole Preparation Project Partners for Dignity & Rights Public Science Project Release Aging People in Prison Campaign (RAPP) Surveillance Resistance Lab Surveillance Technology Oversight Project Suspension Representation Project - Education Advocacy Chair TakeRoot Justice The Center for Anti-Violence Education The Gathering for Justice The People's Plan NYC Transgender Law Center Urban Justice Center Mental Health Project Urban Youth Collaborative VOCAL-NY Youth Represent

  • Gladys Williams Charter Revision Commission Hearing Testimony

    Gladys Williams Charter Revision Commission Hearing Testimony 07-08-24 I’m Gladys Williams and my son Antonio Williams was killed by the NYPD in 2019. He was just a Black man standing on the street in the Bronx waiting for his cab when plainclothes cops jumped out of their vehicle, chased, beat and murdered my son without cause. Those police were so reckless in shooting all over the place that they killed one of their own that night too. I’m testifying to call for the Charter Commission to not place anything on the November 2024 ballot. I was shocked to learn about this commission, your rushed timeline and reporting that cites the How Many Stops Act as one of the supposed reasons this commission was created. I’m speaking as a mother and as someone who fought for the How Many Stops Act. When the NYPD murdered my son Antonio, it was because they illegally escalated what would have just been a level-one stop. I was proud to fight for the How Many Stops Act and speak at rallies, to elected officials and at the hearing because this was also a way to fight for my son. It took a long time before the City Council passed the legislation – and it wasn’t a secret or rushed or hidden process the way this commission seems to be. In fact part of why it took so long to pass the legislation was that the NYPD has too much power in any legislation related to them – whether it’s at the city or the state level. They held up the passage and with the mayor they led a massive misinformation campaign with their press access and their money for public relations. I was proud of the City Council for overriding the mayor’s veto – especially after the huge misinformation and bullying by the NYPD about these common-sense, simple laws. I’m calling on you to say no to putting anything on the November ballot because I think you’ve been misinformed and that as a result you’re misinforming New Yorkers. If anything, there needs to be fewer obstacles to pass police accountability bills for NYers’ safety -- and the NYPD and police unions shouldn’t be able to interfere as much as they do. The NYPD already acts like they’re above the law – there’s multiple laws they don’t comply with and they shield officers who kill and brutalize New Yorkers from discipline. The police already have outsized influence, they’re not elected by the people and they shouldn’t have as much control as they do. Letting the police have so much power in public affairs is bad for democracy and it’s bad for public safety. The rushed timeline already makes this seem like a rigged process – if it’s not, then I’m calling on you to not put anything on the ballot in November. It’s outrageous to think that you’ve rushed hearings through for a month, only since Jun 5th and you’re scheduled to vote on final ballot language on July 25th even though you haven’t told New Yorkers what the final ballot language will be. There’s no good reason to rush charter changes through in less than 2 months. That’s not democracy, that’s a sham. I call on you to do the right thing and don’t put anything from this commission on the November ballot.

  • Chinnor Campbell Charter Revision Commission Hearing Testimony

    Chinnor Campbell Charter Revision Commission Hearing Testimony 07-08-24 My name is Chinnor Campbell. I’m a student at the University of Mount Saint Vincent. I’m also the younger brother of Ramarley Graham, who was killed in front of me and my grandmother, in our home by the NYPD in 2012 when I was just 6 years old . I’m here today because even though lots of people don’t want to vote, next year is the election year for the mayor's seat and I want to bring that to light because he is using the undemocratic charter revision process to expand the NYPD’s power instead of focusing on protecting the people he was elected to represent. Adams seems to be using this last minute process as a way to silence the people and their voices and my statement to everyone is if the person who is supposed to represent us is not doing that we need to vote and represent ourselves. When my brother was murdered, stop-and-frisk was at an all time high. Now, under Mayor Eric Adams, stop-and-frisk is on the rise again and at the highest it's been in almost a decade. These days I see more and more officers harassing people in neighborhoods. There are more and more cops in the subways. None of this really helps to increase safety for New Yorkers. That’s why I joined 27 other family members of New Yorkers killed by the NYPD in endorsing the How Many Stops Act. It’s also why I’m urging Commission members not to use this process to make it harder for New Yorkers to pass police reform laws. It’s already really difficult for us to pass anything that touches on police transparency or accountability because the NYPD already has too much power over the legislative process and in public affairs. The How Many Stops Act went through a rigorous, democratic process, in which there was significant public input and the bills were even held up to make time for negotiation between communities, the Council and the administration, including the NYPD. In contrast, this charter revision process is rushed and politically motivated to block the Council’s “advice and consent law” from going on the ballot.  The process for this charter revision is being rushed into just 7 weeks from when you held your first hearing to when commissioners will vote on what will be on the November ballot. You’re scheduled to vote in two weeks but you still haven’t shared the final language with the public. There’s no need for that kind of rush unless this is a biased, rigged process. In fact, I heard that - at a hearing last month - two other family members of New Yorkers who were killed by the NYPD got muted before they could even finish their sentences. It seems like this happened because they were raising concerns, when people who were just repeating the mayor and NYPD’s lines were allowed to go over time to finish their comments. All of this makes it seem that this process is about the Mayor trying to grab even more power – when it should be about improving things for New Yorkers. I’m urging you, the Commission, to recognize this and to not put any so-called “public safety” measures or any other measures on the November ballot. Just leave it alone.

  • After Dragging Its Feet for Over A Year, NYPD Finally Serves Charges to Lt. Jonathan Rivera for Killing Allan Feliz

    Media Contact Eliel Cruz, press@justicecommittee.org FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: July 2, 2024 “It’s been almost five years since my brother Allan Feliz was murdered during an unjust traffic stop and we miss him every single day. While my family and I are relieved that the NYPD has finally served the CCRB’s fireable charges to Lt. Jonathan Rivera for racially profiling, assaulting, tasing, shooting, and then leaving my brother to bleed out in the street with his genitals exposed, it’s unacceptable that it took the NYPD over a year to simply serve charges to one of their employees. Mayor Adams and Police Commissioner Caban’s refusal to discipline NYPD officers that engage in misconduct has kept my family tortured in an emotional limbo with an open wound instead of being able to mourn Allan. The NYPD has been protecting Lt. Rivera by obstructing the discipline process with endless delays for the past 4.5 years - including stalling the CCRB investigation for over two years, blowing past the 18-month deadline for most discipline charges. The NYPD also stopped the CCRB from scheduling Lt. Rivera’s discipline trial by threatening to retain the case from the CCRB for 10 months despite it not meeting the criteria laid out in the MOU. I truly believe the only reason the charges have finally been served is because of my family’s relentless fight to ensure Lt. Rivera is fired and all the groups and elected officials that have continued to support us. In the midst of this, I was subjected to an unjust traffic stop eerily similar to my brother’s. Officers pulled me over for a phony traffic violation I had not committed and then falsely arrested me. The entire ordeal was traumatic and it’s something that still keeps me from sleeping at night .I still think about how easily my brother’s story could have become mine and I filed a claim, which we recently settled, so there is record of it. Based on how me, my family and Allan are being treated by the NYPD and the Adams administration, Mayor Adams’ devastating cuts to the CCRB’s budget, the way Mayor Adams and Commissioner Caban handled the Kawaski Trawick, Debra Danner and Delrawn Small cases, and Commission Caban’s rampant burying of police misconduct complaints, my family and I are concerned that without significant pressure Lt. Rivera will be allowed to continue to abuse and murder New Yorkers in spite of the fact that he has record of 34 misconduct allegations and has cost New Yorkers $115,000 in civil suit settlements so far. It’s all too clear that the NYPD will stop at nothing to protect and empower officers who kill and abuse us, and this has only gotten worse under Mayor Adams. However, we will not back down until Lt. Rivera is fired without access to a good guy letter and his pension. My family is calling on the CCRB to schedule the discipline trial immediately. Ultimately, we call on Mayor Adams and Commissioner Caban to fire Lt. Rivera for murdering Allan. Lt. Rivera and the other officers involved in murdering my brother are a threat to public safety and should have been fired years ago.” ###

bottom of page